Choosing the right online security tool can feel overwhelming, right?
You’re juggling work, streaming, and everyday browsing and must stay safe.
Two names often pop up: Surfshark VPN and Tailscale.
But which one is the best fit for you 2025年？
This isn’t just about tech specs.
It’s about your needs, your budget, and how you use the internet.
We’ll compare SurfsharkVPN vs Tailscale so you can choose smartly. Let’s dive in!
概述
We’ve tested Surfshark VPN and Tailscale for speed, security, and ease of use.
Our hands-on experience and in-depth research form the basis of this comparison, helping you navigate the key differences and choose the right tool for your needs.
It’s a fantastic choice for budget-conscious users or those who need to connect multiple devices.
定价： 30-day money-back guarantee. Plan starts at $1.99/month
主要特点：
- 分割隧道
- Lightway Protocol
- TrustedServer Technology
想要以更简单、更安全的方式连接设备？Tailscale 设置简单！
定价： Free Plan Available. Plan Starts at $5/month
主要特点：
- WireGuard 协议、
- 网状网络、
- 访问控制。
What is Surfshark VPN?
Surfshark VPN is a popular choice for secure browsing.
It’s known for its speed and user-friendly apps. You get a lot of features at a competitive price.
It’s a good option for families or anyone wanting to protect multiple devices.
此外，探索我们最喜欢的 Surfshark 替代品…
我们的看法
Surfshark VPN 之所以受欢迎，是因为它在功能、安全性和价格方面实现了出色的平衡。对于注重预算或需要连接多台设备的用户来说，它是一个绝佳的选择。
主要优点
- 无限同时连接数： 连接所有设备！
- 价格实惠： 物超所值。
- 强大的安全功能： 包括 AES-256 加密和终止开关。
- 速度快： 适合流媒体和下载。
- 30天退款保证： 有足够的时间来尝试。
定价
所有价格均按年计费。
- Surfshark Starter： 每月 1.99 美元 + 额外 3 个月
- Surfshark One： 每月 3.19 美元 + 额外 3 个月。
- Surfshark One+： 每月 15.145 美元
优点
缺点
什么是 Tailscale？
Tailscale is a bit different.
It’s not just a VPN; it creates a 安全的 network between 你的 devices, wherever they are.
Think of it like your own private internet.
It’s great for accessing files, servers, or anything else on your network, no matter where you are.
Also, explore our favorite Tailscale alternatives…
我们的看法
使用 Tailscale 简化网络访问并增强安全性。立即开始免费试用，探索 Tailscale 提供的无缝连接和高级功能。
主要优点
- 设置简单： 几分钟内即可开始使用，无需复杂的配置。
- 强大的安全性： 使用 WireGuard 协议进行稳健加密。
- 网状网络： 设备之间直接连接，速度更快。
- 访问控制： 控制谁能访问网络上的内容。
- 随处可用：跨不同网络和地点连接设备。
定价
- 个人的： 0美元/月
- 个人加分： $5/月
- 起动机： 每月 6 美元
- 优质的： $18/月
- 企业： 定制定价
优点
缺点
功能比较
Surfshark and Tailscale represent opposing ends of the vpn providers spectrum.
This surfshark vpn review contrasts a consumer vpn service for anonymous public internet connection browsing with a specialized tool for secure networking across personal ip addresses, illustrating different goals for network security.
1. Primary Purpose and Use Case
- Surfshark: Offers public vpn services for maximizing anonymity, competing directly with alternatives like 私人互联网接入 for general internet connection privacy.
- 尾标: Provides dedicated network security and secure networking, focusing on creating a private mesh network among devices owned by the same user or organization.
2. Connection Limits and Compatibility
- Surfshark: Allows unlimited simultaneous connections per subscription, securing all devices including the android app and browser extensions, and runs on all major operating systems.
- 尾标: Free users face device limits, but the software is designed to easily install tailscale clients on all major operating systems for private use.
3. Server Infrastructure Type
- Surfshark: Relies on a proprietary network of managed vpn servers, including physical and virtual servers and dedicated surfshark servers, for widespread geographic coverage.
- 尾标: Uses client software to form a peer-to-peer network, relying on a coordination service rather than relying on a traditional central vpn servers infrastructure.
4. IP Address Handling and Identity
- Surfshark: Assigns a shared public ip address to hide the user’s origin, rarely giving the same ip address on subsequent connections.
- 尾标: Assigns unique, fixed private ip addresses to each device, making all device ip addresses accessible across the private network.
5. Client Software and Network Control
- Surfshark: Uses the feature-rich surfshark app across major platforms for simple connection management and general network traffic control.
- 尾标: The tailscale app is the lightweight client deployed on every device, forming a private tunnel and eliminates single points of failure common in traditional VPNs.
6. Logging Policy and Private Traffic
- Surfshark: Maintains an audited no logs policy to protect user anonymity while using any public vpn server and concealing network traffic.
- 尾标: Secures private network traffic between your own devices; it’s a tool for secure networking of your existing ip addresses.
7. Public Internet Gateway Access
- Surfshark: All public internet-bound network traffic leaves the vpn tunnel via a chosen vpn server location, masking the true ip address and identity.
- 尾标: Devices can optionally be configured to use an exit node to direct public internet connection traffic out through a specific device.
8. Advanced Routing Capabilities
- Surfshark: Features like MultiHop and obfuscation are included but the internal routing logic is hidden from the user.
- 尾标: A key function allows configuring a device as a subnet router to expose entire local ip addresses ranges to the private Tailscale network.
9. Network Segmentation and Management
- Surfshark: Provides basic separation via its VPN tunnel; once connected to surfshark servers, the user can reach the general internet or other virtual servers.
- 尾标: Uses subnet routers to advertise routes to external subnets, which allows all other devices behind a NAT to be reached by the tailscale client devices.
选择 VPN 时要注意什么？
- Jurisdiction: Where is the VPN company based? Look for privacy-friendly locations.
- Logging Policy Details: “No logs” is good, but 什么 do they log? Read the fine print.
- 关闭开关： Does it have a kill switch to protect the 数据 if the VPN connection drops?
- DNS泄漏保护: Does it prevent DNS leaks that can reveal your browsing activity to google cloud or other clients?
- 服务器位置: More servers often mean better speeds and access to content, especially for new users connecting through different exit nodes.
- Simultaneous Connections: How many devices, including apple tv, can be used at once?
- 客户支持: Is help readily available if you have problems or need to file bugs?
- Money-Back Guarantee: A good guarantee lets you try the VPN risk-free..
最终裁决
Choosing between Surfshark VPN and Tailscale depends on what you need.
For everyday online privacy and unblocking content, Surfshark VPN is the clear winner.
It’s a solid VPN with fast WireGuard speeds and a user-friendly experience.
If your priority is secure remote access to your own devices and network, Tailscale is excellent.
We’ve tested dozens of VPNs, and our pick reflects real-world performance and value.
We hope this breakdown helps you 制作 the right choice for your digital life.
More of Surfshark VPN
We’ve looked at alternatives to SurfsharkVPN, so how does SurfsharkVPN stack up directly against them?
- SurfsharkVPN vs NordVPN: It allows unlimited device connections, whereas NordVPN offers a larger server network.
- SurfsharkVPN vs ExpressVPN: It is generally more affordable and allows unlimited devices, while ExpressVPN is known for its consistent speeds and strong reputation.
- SurfsharkVPN vs PureVPN: It is often faster and has more features, while PureVPN boasts a larger server count. Surfshark has better streaming support in tests.
- SurfsharkVPN vs ProtonVPN: It is generally more affordable and allows unlimited connections, while ProtonVPN focuses on strong security and privacy, and can be slightly faster.
- SurfsharkVPN vs PrivadoVPN: It offers unlimited connections and more features, often at a better long-term price, while PrivadoVPN has a decent free plan but a smaller server network.
- SurfsharkVPN vs AdGuard VPN: It is a comprehensive VPN with more features, while AdGuard VPN’s strength is its ad-blocking integration.
- SurfsharkVPN vs Virtual Shield: It offers more features and better performance than the simpler Virtual Shield.
- SurfsharkVPN vs StrongVPN: It allows unlimited connections and often has better pricing, while StrongVPN is known for strong encryption.
- SurfsharkVPN vs FastestVPN: It generally offers more features and better performance than the budget-friendly FastestVPN.
- SurfsharkVPN vs AuraVPN: It focuses on VPN features and unlimited connections, while AuraVPN includes identity theft protection.
- SurfsharkVPN vs CyberGhost: It allows unlimited connections and often has better long-term pricing, while CyberGhost has user-friendly apps and specialized servers.
- SurfsharkVPN vs McAfee VPN: It is a dedicated VPN service with more features and better performance than the basic VPN from McAfee.
- SurfsharkVPN vs Private Internet Access: It allows unlimited connections and often has better streaming capabilities, while PIA is known for customization and a large server network.
- SurfsharkVPN vs Mysterium: It uses a traditional server network known for speed and features, while Mysterium is a decentralized VPN.
Tailscale 的更多信息
我们已经探讨了 Tailscale 的替代品，那么 Tailscale 与这些替代品相比有何优势？
- Tailscale vs NordVPN: It creates a zero-trust private network, while NordVPN provides general online privacy and security.
- Tailscale 与 ExpressVPN: It’s MediaStreamer provides some device linking for content access, but Tailscale offers a more comprehensive private network solution.
- Tailscale 与 PureVPN: It’s port forwarding can enable direct device connections for specific uses, whereas Tailscale creates a seamless private network.
- Tailscale vs SurfsharkVPN: It’s Nexus aims to enhance the network, but Tailscale is specifically designed to create a private network between devices easily.
- Tailscale vs ProtonVPN: It allows secure server connections, but Tailscale directly links your devices in a private network.
- Tailscale vs PrivadoVPN： It secures connections, but Tailscale’s core function is to create a simple, private network between your devices.
- Tailscale 与 AdGuard VPN： It focuses on privacy and ad blocking, while Tailscale’s strength is in creating direct, secure device-to-device networks.
- Tailscale vs Virtual Shield: It offers secure VPN connections, but Tailscale is built to create a cohesive private network.
- Tailscale vs StrongVPN: It provides secure connections, but Tailscale simplifies creating a private network between devices.
- Tailscale 与 FastestVPN： It secures connections, while Tailscale’s focus is on creating an easy-to-manage private network.
- Tailscale 与 AuraVPN： It offers a security suite including VPN, while Tailscale specializes in creating secure, private device networks.
- Tailscale 与 CyberGhost： It allows multiple secure connections to its servers, while Tailscale creates a direct private network between your devices.
- Tailscale 与 McAfee VPN： It secures your devices’ internet connection, while Tailscale creates a private network for direct device linking.
- 尾随规模与专用互联网接入 PIA 提供安全连接和端口转发功能，而 Tailscale 则提供更简化的方法来创建专用设备网络。
- Tailscale vs Mysterium: It is a decentralized VPN that connects through other users, while Tailscale creates a private network directly between your trusted devices.
常见问题
Is Surfshark VPN or Tailscale better for streaming?
Surfshark VPN is generally better for streaming. Its extensive server network and fast speeds make it ideal for bypassing geo-restrictions and enjoying smooth playback. Tailscale’s focus is on secure network access, not streaming optimization.
Can I use both Surfshark VPN and Tailscale at the same time?
Yes, you can use both. Use Surfshark VPN for general browsing and streaming and Tailscale to access your home network or specific devices securely securely securely. However, they serve different purposes.
Tailscale 是 VPN 吗？
Tailscale is 不 a traditional VPN. It creates a mesh network, a peer-to-peer connection between your devices. While it offers security like a VPN, it functions differently and is designed for different use cases.
Which is easier to set up in SurfsharkVPN vs Tailscale?
Surfshark VPN is generally easier to set up, especially for beginners. Its apps are user-friendly. Tailscale requires more technical know-how, though they aim to simplify the process.
Which is more secure, Surfshark VPN or Tailscale?
Both offer strong security but in different ways. Surfshark VPN protects your IP address and online activity, while Tailscale secures the connection between your devices. The “better” security depends on your specific needs.
English 
Spanish 
Chinese 
German 
French 
Russian 
Portuguese 
Japanese 
Korean