⚡ 快速结论：
- 定价： Bitwarden paid plans start at $1/month. Proton Pass paid plans start at $2.99/month. Both run a free plan.
- 最适合： Bitwarden suits people who want unlimited passwords cheaply and the ability to self-host. Proton Pass suits privacy-first users already inside Proton services.
- 主要区别： Bitwarden adds self-hosting and Bitwarden Send. Proton Pass adds hide my email aliases and an integrated 2fa authenticator.
- 我们的选择： Bitwarden for most users, because its premium plan costs a third of what Pass Plus does.
Two open source password managers. Two very different price tags.
Bitwarden charges $1 a month for its premium version.
Proton Pass charges nearly three times that for Pass Plus.
Yet Proton Pass throws in tools Bitwarden simply does not build.
That gap decides which one belongs on your 设备.
概述
This Bitwarden vs Proton Pass comparison covers pricing, security features, and daily password management.
我们的 作家 spent hands-on time inside Bitwarden directly.
Notes on Proton Pass come from Proton’s documentation, published security audits, and G2 reviews.
By the end you will know which 密码管理器 fits your budget.
Bitwarden是什么？
Bitwarden is an open source password manager for people who want unlimited passwords at almost no cost.
It stores your logins, usernames, and secure notes inside one encrypted vault.
A free account covers unlimited devices with no cap on entries.
Anyone can inspect the code, which is rare among most password managers.
You can also self-host the whole thing on your own server.
Here is a walkthrough of how the vault and browser extension fit together.
🏆 获胜者：Bitwarden
Unlimited passwords on unlimited devices, at no cost. Open code, regular security audits, and the option to run your own server.
Bitwarden定价
Bitwarden keeps its price list short and cheap. Personal accounts start at nothing and top out near pocket change.
| 计划 | 价格 | 最适合 |
|---|---|---|
| 自由的 | $0 | Unlimited passwords on unlimited devices |
| 优质的 | $1 | Reports, file sharing, and emergency access |
| 家庭 | $3.33 | Up to 6 people sharing one vault |
价格已于2026年7月核实。
免费试用： Not needed for personal use. Bitwarden offers a free forever plan, and Families, Teams, and Enterprise carry a 7-day free trial.
退款保证： Paid plans are refundable within 30 days of purchase.
📌 笔记： 商业 accounts sit on a separate list. Teams runs $4 per user each month and Enterprise runs $6 per user each month.
⚠️ Pricing conflict: Our CSV lists Premium at $1 and Families at $3.33, and those figures are used in every table here. Separate research quotes the same tiers billed yearly at $10 and $40. Check the checkout page before you buy.
Bitwarden 的主要优势
Here is what makes Bitwarden worth a look:
- A free plan with no caps: You can store unlimited passwords across unlimited devices without paying. 达什莱恩 caps its free tier at 25 entries and one device.
- 开源代码： The source is public, so anyone can hunt for flaws and report them. That openness is unusual among the best password managers.
- Clean breach record: Bitwarden has never been hacked or breached. Regular third party security audits back the claim up.
- 自托管： You get the ability to run the whole vault on your own hardware. Almost no rival offers this.
- Bitwarden 发送： 分享 文本 and files with end to end encryption and an expiry date, without email.
- Wide reach: The apps ship in over 60 languages, and the cloud vault sits on Microsoft Azure.
- 2026 additions: A phishing blocker now flags malicious sites before you type, and password coaching calls out weak passwords as you work.
我们的团队注意到了什么
Our writer created a free account and moved a real vault across. Here is what stood out during that hands-on time:
Bitwarden 的优点和缺点
✅ 优点
- Free version stores unlimited passwords on unlimited devices
- Open source code that anyone can inspect for flaws
- Premium features cost less than 1Password or Dashlane
- Self-hosting lets you keep the vault on your own server
- Never been breached, with regular third party security audits
❌缺点
- The interface feels less polished than Dashlane or 1Password
- Autofill takes more clicks than rival extensions
- No built-in email alias tool
- Self-hosting asks for skills many users do not have
什么是质子传递？
Proton Pass is an open source password manager from the makers of Proton Mail.
Proton AG owns Proton Pass and runs it from Switzerland under strict privacy law.
Proton Pass launched in 2023 and now sits beside Proton VPN, Proton Drive, and Proton Calendar.
Every field is end to end encrypted before it reaches Proton’s servers.
Only you hold the key, so Proton cannot read your vault.
One Proton account unlocks the password manager plus other Proton services.
质子通道
A free password manager with unlimited logins on unlimited devices. Open code, independent audits, and email aliases built in.
Proton Pass Pricing
Proton Pass free is the entry point. Paid plans add privacy tools rather than extra storage.
| 计划 | 价格 | 最适合 |
|---|---|---|
| 自由的 | 每月 0 美元 | Unlimited logins, unlimited devices, 10 email aliases |
| Pass Plus | 每月 2.99 美元 | Dark web monitoring and vault sharing with 10 people |
| 帕斯家族 | 每月 4.99 美元 | Up to 6 users with Plus features each |
| 质子无限 | 每月 9.99 美元 | Full suite including Proton Mail and Proton VPN |
价格已于2026年7月核实。
免费试用： Not needed. The free version is free forever and covers just your passwords.
退款保证： Paid tiers carry a 30 day money back guarantee.
📌 笔记： Business buyers get two extra tiers. Pass Essentials covers small teams, and Pass Professional adds admin controls for bigger ones.
⚠️ 数据 gap: Proton Pass has no row in our CSV yet. The figures above come from our own published Proton Pass review and Proton’s rate card. Confirm your local currency at checkout.
Key Benefits of Proton Pass
Here is what Proton Pass offers that most rivals do not:
- Free tier with no caps: You can store unlimited passwords and unlimited logins on every device you own without paying.
- Hide my email aliases: Generate a throwaway address so your personal email address never touches a signup form. Ten come free.
- 暗网监控： Pass Monitor warns you when your login credentials surface after a data breach.
- Open code, audited: The source is public, and the German firm Cure53 has run independent security audits.
- 质子哨兵： This program watches for suspicious sign-ins and alerts you quickly.
- Integrated 2fa authenticator: TOTP codes live in the same vault, so you get two factor authentication without a separate authenticator app.
- Easy migration: Import accepts CSV and JSON files plus ZIP and XML exports, so existing passwords move over quickly.
我们的团队注意到了什么
Note: We have not logged extensive hands-on time with Proton Pass yet. The points above come from Proton’s documentation, the Cure53 audit summary, and G2 reviews. Our full Proton Pass review will be updated once our writers finish a longer trial.
Proton Pass Pros & Cons
✅ 优点
- Free plan can store unlimited passwords on unlimited devices
- Hide my email aliases keep your real address private
- Open source code audited by Cure53
- Integrated 2fa authenticator removes the need for a second app
- Secure password sharing through encrypted links
❌缺点
- Paid plans cost more than Bitwarden or NordPass
- Proton Pass lacks live chat support
- No emergency access for a trusted contact
- Autofill can need configuration in some browsers
功能对比
Both tools cover the basics of password management well. The gaps appear once you look past the vault itself, so we lined up ten areas that decide most purchases.
| 特征 | 比特沃登 | 质子通道 |
|---|---|---|
| 起价 | $0 | 每月 0 美元 |
| 最便宜的付费方案 | $1 | 每月 2.99 美元 |
| Unlimited Passwords | ✅ | ✅ |
| Open Source Code | ✅ | ✅ |
| 自托管 | ✅ | ❌ |
| Hide My Email Aliases | ❌ | ✅ |
| Integrated 2FA Authenticator | ✅ | ✅ |
| 暗网监控 | ✅ | ✅ |
| 紧急通道 | ✅ | ❌ |
| Windows macOS Linux Apps | ✅ | ✅ |
| 最适合 | Budget and self-hosting | Privacy-first Proton users |
1. 安全性和加密
Bitwarden： Bitwarden uses AES 256 encryption to protect your vault, paired with a zero knowledge design. Your master password is the only key that can decrypt the vault, and data is encrypted before it leaves your device. Sensitive information stays secure in transit and at rest.
质子通道： Proton Pass applies the same 256 bit standard with end to end encryption on every field, not just the password box. Encryption and decryption happen on your device. That strong encryption also underpins Proton’s secure communication tools.
⚠️ 警告： Both publish code and both run security audits. Bitwarden has the longer audit history. Proton Pass has the Cure53 report. Neither claim can be checked without reading the reports yourself.
2. 密码生成器
Bitwarden： 密码 发电机 builds long, complex, and distinct strings for every site. It handles passphrases as well as random characters. That makes replacing weak passwords with unique passwords quick work.
质子通道： Its generator switches between random strings and memorable word chains. Both modes produce strong passwords. Password generation happens locally, so nothing travels before it is encrypted.
3. Password Health and Breach Alerts
Bitwarden： Vault reports grade your stored passwords and flag reused or exposed entries. In 2026 Bitwarden added real-time health alerts and password coaching that surface problems as you work. A phishing blocker now catches malicious sites before you enter a secure password.
质子通道： Pass Monitor pairs reuse warnings with dark web monitoring. It scans for compromised credentials and alerts you when your details appear in a data breach. Continuous monitoring needs Pass Plus.
4. Two-Factor Authentication
Bitwarden： You can enable two factor authentication by email or through third-party tools like Google Authenticator. Premium adds hardware key support. Biometric authentication unlocks the mobile apps and desktop apps with a fingerprint or face scan.
质子通道： An integrated 2fa authenticator stores TOTP codes inside each entry. Your Proton Pass account fills the password and the code together, so you securely log in with one tap. Proton Sentinel watches the account itself for odd sign-ins.
5. Sharing and Emergency Access
Bitwarden： Password sharing runs through Organizations, which hold shared data for a household or team. Emergency access lets a trusted contact reach your vault if something happens to you. Bitwarden Send moves files and text with an expiry date attached.
质子通道： Secure sharing works through encrypted links, and Pass Plus extends vault access to ten recipients. These are advanced security features aimed at households. Emergency access is still missing, which reviewers regularly flag.
6. Import and Export
Bitwarden： The data importer reads exports from other password managers and every major browser. You can find instructions for each source in the help centre. Export runs the other way if you ever leave.
Getting your data back out matters just as much as getting it in.
质子通道： Import accepts CSV, JSON, ZIP, and XML files, so moving existing passwords across is quick. Export is available on paid plans. Managing passwords after the move works the same on every platform.
7. Email Aliases and Custom Domains
Bitwarden： There is no native alias tool, though the generator can hook into third-party masking services. Custom domains are supported for organisations that run their own mail. Your personal email address still goes into most signup forms.
质子通道： Hide my email aliases generate a random address per site and forward mail to your real 收件箱. The free plan includes ten. This is the clearest privacy gap between the two, and it keeps personally identifiable information off marketing lists.
8. 平台覆盖范围
Bitwarden： You get a web vault, desktop apps for Windows macOS and Linux, mobile apps for iOS and 安卓, plus a browser extension for all major web browsers. The apps ship in over 60 languages. Coverage is one reason it ranks with the best password managers.
质子通道： Proton Pass apps cover the same platforms, with a browser extension alongside them. G2 reviews note autofill sometimes needs a settings tweak first. Once set, the browser extension behaves like any rival.
9. Self-Hosting and Bundled Services
Bitwarden： You can run the vault on your own server instead of the cloud. Nothing else on this page offers that. The hosted option keeps your encrypted vault on Microsoft Azure.
质子通道： No self-hosting. Instead, Proton Unlimited folds in Proton Mail, Proton VPN, Proton Drive, and Proton Calendar. It is a privacy suite rather than a single tool.
10. 定价与成本
Here are the paid plans side by side, using the figures from our data sheet.
| 层级 | 比特沃登 | 质子通道 |
|---|---|---|
| 自由的 | $0 | 每月 0 美元 |
| Individual paid | Premium: $1 | Pass Plus: $2.99/month |
| 家庭 | Families: $3.33 | Pass Family: $4.99/month |
| Full suite | ❌ | Proton Unlimited: $9.99/month |
Bitwarden： The premium plan undercuts almost everything else in this category. Free versions of rival tools rarely match what Bitwarden gives away. Premium features like reports and file sharing cost about a third of Pass Plus.
质子通道： The free plan already handles one person’s accounts online. Paid plans cost more than Bitwarden or NordPass, so the upgrade is worth it mainly for aliases and breach alerts. Proton Unlimited only makes sense if you want the whole suite.
不同场景
| 如果您需要…… | 选择 | 为什么 |
|---|---|---|
| The cheapest paid tier | 比特沃登 | $1 against $2.99 |
| Email aliases | 质子通道 | Ten free on the free tier |
| Your own server | 比特沃登 | Self-hosting is supported |
| 紧急通道 | 比特沃登 | Trusted contacts can reach the vault |
| Proton Mail already | 质子通道 | One account covers everything |
| 在线聊天帮助 | 两者都不 | Both lean on email and docs |
💰 您的预算
Bitwarden’s premium version costs about a third of what Pass Plus does. Both give you a genuine free plan, so nobody has to pay on day one.
🔌 您的技术栈
Already paying for Proton Mail or Proton VPN? Proton Unlimited rolls the password manager in at no extra charge. Running your own hardware instead? Only Bitwarden lets you host it.
🔐 Your Privacy Habits
If you sign up for a lot of services, aliases cut spam and limit breach exposure. Bitwarden has no answer to that feature.
🎓您的经验水平
Proton Pass has the friendlier first-run experience. Bitwarden asks for a little more patience, especially around autofill settings.
🆓 免费试用和演示
Neither asks for a card to start. Bitwarden adds a 7-day free trial on Families and business tiers if you want to test sharing.
🛟 支持选项
Support is email and documentation on both sides. Proton Pass lacks live chat support, and Bitwarden leans on community forums for free users.
切换指南
Already committed to one of these? Here is what changes when you move.
🔄 Switching from Bitwarden to Proton Pass?
✅ 你将获得：
- Ten hide my email aliases on the free tier
- Proton Sentinel alerts on suspicious sign-ins
- One login across Proton Mail, Drive, and Calendar
❌ 你会失去什么：
- Self-hosting on your own server
- Emergency access for a trusted contact
- Bitwarden Send for files and one-off text
📋 如何切换：
- Export your vault from the web app as a CSV or JSON file
- Create a free Proton account and open Pass
- Run the import tool, check the result, then delete the export file
🔄 Switching from Proton Pass to Bitwarden?
✅ 你将获得：
- A premium plan at roughly a third of the price
- Self-hosting and a longer public audit trail
- Emergency access and Bitwarden Send
❌ 你会失去什么：
- Every email alias you created
- The bundled Proton services on Unlimited
- Proton Sentinel login monitoring
📋 如何切换：
- Export from Pass, which needs a paid plan
- Open a free account and install the browser extension
- Use the data importer, then update any alias addresses at the source
⚠️ 警告： Aliases do not 旅行. If you leave Proton Pass, every alias address stops forwarding, so change the login on each affected account first.
我们的评测没有涵盖的内容
We looked at individual and family use, not business rollouts. Teams, Enterprise, Pass Essentials, and Pass Professional deployments were outside this comparison, along with SSO and admin reporting. We also did not test passkey handling at length or long-term sync reliability. Our Bitwarden notes come from one writer’s migration in 2026, so your results may differ.
最终判决
| 类别 | 优胜者 |
|---|---|
| 💰 定价 | 比特沃登 |
| 🔐 Security & Transparency | 领带 |
| 🔑 Password Generator | 领带 |
| 🚨 Breach Alerts | 质子通道 |
| 🤝 Sharing & Emergency Access | 比特沃登 |
| 💻 Platform Coverage | 比特沃登 |
| 🕵️ Privacy Extras | 质子通道 |
| 🖥️ Self-Hosting | 比特沃登 |
| 🏆 总冠军 | 比特沃登 |
🏆 获奖者：BITWARDEN
Bitwarden wins 4 of 8 categories, with two ties and two going to Proton Pass.
最适合： budget-conscious users, households that share logins, anyone who wants to self-host, people replacing weak passwords across dozens of accounts
These two chase slightly different buyers. Bitwarden is the value pick, and the cheapest credible way to get unlimited passwords with emergency access and a vault you can host yourself.
Proton Pass is a privacy tool first. Aliases, Sentinel, and the tie-in with other Proton services matter more to its audience than saving two dollars a month.
If you already live inside Proton Mail and Proton Drive, we recommend Proton Pass and the single account that comes with it. For everyone else, Bitwarden does more for less.
与 Bitwarden 相比，更多
The Bitwarden password manager lines up against three closer rivals here. If none fit, our full list of Bitwarden的替代方案 goes wider.
Bitwarden 胜出： a free tier that 1Password does not offer at all, self-hosting, a paid tier costing a fraction as much
1Password 在以下方面胜出： the extra Secret Key layer above your master password, Travel Mode for border crossings, richer item templates for cards and documents
Bitwarden 胜出： no 25-entry cap on the free tier, open code anyone can audit, far cheaper family pricing
Dashlane 获胜： smoother autofill in fewer clicks, a bundled VPN on paid tiers, a more polished onboarding flow
Bitwarden 胜出： a clean breach history, unlimited devices on the free tier, code that outsiders can read
LastPass 在以下方面胜出： a longer track record with enterprise buyers, wider legacy integrations, a more familiar interface for long-time users
This video runs through more options if neither name here fits your setup.
More of Proton Pass Compared
Here is where Proton Pass sits against its nearest competition.
Proton Pass wins on: Swiss jurisdiction and published audit reports, alias generation at signup, a free tier with no device limit
NordPass 胜出的原因： a lower renewal price on long plans, faster autofill on mobile, bundling with the wider Nord product family
Proton Pass wins on: an uncapped free plan, open code, email masking included rather than sold separately
Dashlane 获胜： emergency access for a trusted relative, a longer feature list on paid tiers, live chat when something breaks
Proton Pass wins on: a usable free tier, aliases and Sentinel bundled in, simpler pricing with no add-on maze
Keeper Security wins on: deeper admin controls for teams, secure file storage as a paid add-on, phone support lines
常见问题解答
Bitwarden真的安全吗？
Yes. It uses AES 256 encryption with zero knowledge architecture, so login details are stored securely and only you can decrypt them. It has never been breached.
Bitwarden有哪些缺点？
The interface trails rivals, autofill needs extra clicks, and there is no alias tool. Self-hosting also demands technical skill that most people will not have.
Can I use Proton Pass for free?
Yes. The free tier holds unlimited logins on unlimited devices and includes ten aliases. Dark web monitoring and vault sharing need Pass Plus at $2.99/month.
Is Proton Pass safe to use?
Yes. Cure53 audited the open code, and sensitive data never leaves your device unencrypted. Swiss privacy law covers how Proton Pass works with your records.
Bitwarden 和 Proton Pass 哪个更好？
Bitwarden, for most people. It keeps your passwords safe for a third of the price and lets you securely store shared logins with emergency access built in.
English 
Spanish 
Chinese 
German 
French 
Arabic 
Russian 
Portuguese 
Japanese 
Korean 
Italian 
Turkish 
Dutch 
Polish 
Indonesian 
Thai 
Vietnamese 