⚡ Краткий вывод:
- Цены: Surfshark starts at $1.99/month (2-year plan) vs Tailscale’s free Personal plan ($0) or $5/month for Personal Plus
- Лучше всего подходит для: Surfshark for online privacy, streaming, and browsing protection. Tailscale for secure remote access and device-to-device networking.
- Ключевое отличие: Surfshark hides your IP address and encrypts internet traffic. Tailscale creates a private mesh network between your own devices.
- Наш выбор: Surfshark for most users — it covers privacy, streaming, and безопасность in one affordable package
Surfshark VPN and Tailscale both call themselves VPN services.
Но они решают совершенно разные проблемы.
Surfshark hides your IP address and encrypts your web traffic.
Tailscale connects your own devices into a secure private network.
Picking the wrong one wastes your money and leaves gaps in your setup.
This comparison breaks down both tools so you pick the right fit.
Обзор
This SurfsharkVPN vs Tailscale comparison covers pricing, features, and real-world use cases.
We reviewed published specs, documentation, and G2 reviews for both tools.
Наши авторы также провели некоторое время непосредственно с каждым из них.
By the end, you’ll know which VPN type fits your needs.
Что такое Surfshark?
Surfshark is a consumer VPN service for online privacy and network security.
It encrypts your internet connection and hides your real IP address from websites.
Приложение Surfshark работает на Windows. Мак, iOS, Android app, and Linux.
Most people choose it for streaming access, browsing on public Wi-Fi, and standard vpn features like a kill switch.
Серфшарк
Budget VPN with unlimited connections and a no logs policy audited by Deloitte. Protect your entire household with one Surfshark subscription. Includes ad and malware blocker, MultiHop, and Alternative ID.
Цены Surfshark
Вот сколько будет стоить Surfshark в 2026 году.
| План | Цена | Лучше всего подходит для |
|---|---|---|
| 24 месяца + 3 дополнительных месяца | 1,99 доллара в месяц | Наилучшее соотношение цены и качества для пользователей, использующих сервис длительное время. |
| 12 месяцев + 3 дополнительных | 3,19 доллара в месяц | Среднесрочные обязательства |
| 1 месяц | 15,45 долларов в месяц | Краткосрочное или тестовое |
Pricing verified May 2026.
Бесплатная пробная версия: 7-дневная бесплатная пробная версия Android and iOS. No credit card needed for the trial.
Гарантия возврата денег: 30-day money-back guarantee on all plans. Monthly plans are excluded from refunds.
📌 Примечание: Surfshark offers three tiers: Starter (VPN only), One (adds Surfshark Antivirus and alerts), and One+ (adds data removal via Incogni). The Surfshark pricing above reflects the Starter tier. One starts at $2.29/month and One+ at $4.19/month on the 2-year plan. Surfshark’s servers include both physical and virtual servers across 100 countries.
⚠️ Предупреждение: Renewal prices jump after the first term. The Starter plan renews at $99/year. Check the renewal rate before you subscribe. The 30-day money-back guarantee only applies to the first subscription term.
Основные преимущества Surfshark
Вот почему Surfshark заслуживает внимания:
- Неограниченное количество устройств: Connect every device in your home with one subscription. No cap on simultaneous connections.
- Глобальная сеть серверов: Over 3,200 VPN servers in 100 countries. All Surfshark servers support WireGuard for fast connections.
- Проверенная политика отсутствия журналов регистрации: Deloitte and Cure53 have both confirmed that Surfshark does not store browsing history or session data. Surfshark security extends to AES-256 encryption on all connections, keeping your data encrypted end to end.
- CleanWeb Blocker: Blocks ads and trackers while you browse. Works as an ad and malware blocker across all connected devices.
- Многошаговое шифрование: Route your VPN connection through two servers for extra privacy. Dynamic MultiHop lets you pick custom server pairs. Surfshark also offers an IP rotation feature that changes your IP address periodically.
- Альтернативный идентификатор: Create a fake identity and email address for online sign-ups. Keeps your real info private.
- Особенность туннелирования с разделением на две части: Choose which apps go through the VPN and which use your regular internet connection. Surfshark calls this feature “Bypasser.”
- Вариант с выделенным IP-адресом: You can purchase a dedicated IP address add-on for a static IP in 20 locations. This is useful for accessing services that block shared VPN IPs.
Что заметила наша команда
Наш писатель signed up for Surfshark and spent several days testing the apps. Here’s what stood out:
Плюсы и минусы Surfshark
✅ Плюсы
- Неограниченное количество одновременных подключений на всех тарифных планах.
- Starts at $1.99/month on the 2-year plan
- Политика отсутствия журналов регистрации проверена компаниями Deloitte и Cure53.
- Разблокирует Netflix. Хулу, and Disney+ reliably
- CleanWeb blocks ads and trackers across devices
❌ Минусы
- Базируется в Нидерландах (страна альянса «Девять глаз»).
- Renewal prices increase after the first subscription term
- Connection times vary on some distant servers
- Monthly plan costs $15.45 — expensive without a long commitment
Что такое хвостовая чешуя?
Tailscale is a zero-trust mesh VPN for secure networking between devices.
It builds a private network (called a “tailnet”) using the WireGuard protocol.
The Tailscale app runs on Windows, Mac, Linux, iOS, and Android.
Developers and IT teams use it for remote access to servers and internal tools. You can install Tailscale on any device in minutes.
Хвостовая чешуя
Zero-trust mesh VPN that connects your devices directly. Free plan supports up to 100 devices. No port forwarding or firewall changes needed.
Цены на хвостовые части
Вот сколько будет стоить Tailscale в 2026 году.
| План | Цена | Лучше всего подходит для |
|---|---|---|
| Личное | Бесплатно навсегда (0 долларов) | Individual users and homelabs |
| Персональный Плюс | 5 долларов в месяц | Families or small groups |
Pricing verified May 2026.
Бесплатная пробная версия: Персональный тарифный план предоставляется бесплатно навсегда и рассчитан на 3 пользователей и 100 устройств. Бизнес Предлагаемые тарифные планы включают 14-дневный бесплатный пробный период.
Гарантия возврата денег: No formal money-back guarantee. The free plan serves as a risk-free way to test Tailscale.
📌 Примечание: Компания Tailscale также предлагает бизнес plans: Standard at $6/user/month, Premium at $18/user/month, and Enterprise (custom pricing). These target teams and organizations.
⚠️ Предупреждение: Signing up with a custom company domain automatically starts a 14-day Enterprise trial. Use a personal email (Gmail, etc.) if you want the free Personal plan.
Основные преимущества хвостовой чешуи
Here’s what makes Tailscale worth considering:
- Архитектура нулевого доверия: Every device connects directly to every other device. No traffic flows through Tailscale’s servers.
- Протокол WireGuard: All tunnels use WireGuard encryption. This provides fast, low-latency connections between devices.
- MagicDNS: Access your devices by name instead of IP address. No need to remember 100.x.y.z addresses.
- Маршрутизаторы подсети: Reach devices that can’t run the Tailscale client, like printers or IoT gadgets.
- Доступ на основе идентификаторов: Control who can reach which device based on user identity, not IP addresses.
- Выходные узлы: Route your internet traffic through any device on your tailnet. Turn any machine into a VPN exit point.
Что заметила наша команда
Our writer installed the Tailscale client on a MacBook Pro and a Linux server to test the setup process. Here’s what stood out:
Преимущества и недостатки Tailscale
✅ Плюсы
- Free plan supports up to 100 devices for 3 users
- Setup takes under five minutes with no port forwarding
- Direct device-to-device connections eliminate lag from central servers
- Works across all major operating systems including Linux
- SSO integration with over 100 identity providers
❌ Минусы
- По умолчанию не скрывает ваш IP-адрес от веб-сайтов.
- Невозможно разблокировать потоковые сервисы, такие как Netflix или Hulu.
- Email-only support on the free plan during business hours
- Business plans scale per user and can get expensive for large teams
Сравнение характеристик
Let’s compare Surfshark and Tailscale across 9 key areas. These two products serve different purposes, so the “winner” depends on what you need.
| Особенность | Серфшарк | Хвостовая чешуя |
|---|---|---|
| Начальная цена | 1,99 доллара в месяц | 0 долларов (бесплатно навсегда) |
| VPN Type | Consumer Privacy VPN | Zero-Trust Mesh VPN |
| Hides IP Address | ✅ | ❌ (по умолчанию) |
| Неограниченное количество устройств | ✅ | ✅ (100 on free plan) |
| Аварийный выключатель | ✅ | ❌ |
| Разблокировка потокового вещания | ✅ | ❌ |
| Удаленный доступ к устройствам | ❌ | ✅ |
| Аудит без регистрации событий | ✅ (Deloitte) | ❌ |
| Лучше всего подходит для | Конфиденциальность и потоковая передача | Secure networking & remote access |
1. Архитектура VPN
Серфшарк: Uses a traditional client-server VPN model. Your traffic goes from your device to a Surfshark VPN server, then to the internet. The VPN server masks your real IP address and assigns you a shared IP address. Surfshark’s servers include over 3,200 options in 100 countries, giving you plenty of server locations to choose from. All traffic is Surfshark encrypted with AES-256.
Хвостовая чешуя: Builds a peer-to-peer mesh network. Each device connects directly to other devices on your tailnet using WireGuard tunnels. Network traffic never passes through Tailscale’s servers. The control plane handles key exchange and device discovery, but the data plane stays between your own devices.
2. Online Privacy and IP Protection
Серфшарк: Hides your real IP address behind a VPN server IP. Websites see the VPN server’s IP, not yours. Surfshark’s no-logs policy has been independently audited by Deloitte. The service uses AES-256 encryption and supports WireGuard, OpenVPN protocol, and IKEv2 VPN protocols. In speed tests, Surfshark’s download speeds remain competitive when connected to nearby servers.
Хвостовая чешуя: Does not hide your IP address from websites by default. Your internet traffic goes directly to the destination. You can set up an exit node on your tailnet to route traffic through another device, but this requires manual VPN configuration. Tailscale focuses on device-to-device security, not browser privacy.
⚠️ Предупреждение: If your main goal is hiding your IP address or protecting your browsing history from your ISP, Tailscale is not built for that. You need a consumer VPN like Surfshark.
3. Device Connections
Серфшарк: Offers unlimited simultaneous connections on every plan. You can install Surfshark on your phone, laptop, tablet, smart TV, and router at the same time. There is no per-device fee. One Surfshark subscription covers your entire household.
Хвостовая чешуя: The free Personal plan supports up to 100 devices across 3 users. Paid business plans offer unlimited devices per user. Each device gets a unique 100.x.y.z IP address on your tailnet. You can connect your MacBook Pro, Linux servers, Raspberry Pi, and other clients to the same network.
4. Удаленный доступ
Серфшарк: Does not provide remote access to your own devices. Surfshark encrypts your internet connection, but you cannot use it to reach a computer at home from your office. It is a privacy tool, not a networking tool.
Хвостовая чешуя: Built for remote access. Install the Tailscale client on your devices and access them from anywhere. You can SSH into a server, reach a file share, or connect to a database without exposing it to the public internet. Subnet routers let you reach devices that can’t run the Tailscale client, like printers or IoT sensors.
5. Потоковая передача и доступ к контенту
Серфшарк: Unblocks Netflix, Hulu, Disney+, and other streaming platforms. You can connect to VPN servers in different countries to access region-locked content. Surfshark’s servers are regularly updated to stay ahead of streaming blocks. The service also works on Apple TV through the dedicated app or Smart DNS feature.
Хвостовая чешуя: Cannot unblock streaming services. Tailscale connects your own devices. It does not give you a new IP address in another country. If you route traffic through an exit node in another location, it would use that device’s residential IP — which is unreliable for streaming unblocking.
6. Функции безопасности
Серфшарк: Includes a kill switch that blocks your internet connection if the VPN drops. The Camouflage Mode disguises VPN traffic as regular internet traffic. MultiHop routes your connection through two VPN servers. CleanWeb blocks ads and malware trackers.
Хвостовая чешуя: Uses WireGuard encryption for all device-to-device traffic. Access control lists (ACLs) let you define who can reach which resources. The zero-trust model means no device is trusted by default. Tailscale eliminates single points of failure because traffic reroutes if one path fails.
7. Простота настройки
Серфшарк: Download the Surfshark app, sign in, and tap “Connect.” You can pick a VPN server or let the app choose the fastest one. Browser extensions are available for Chrome, Firefox, and Edge. The interface is clean and works well on mobile apps.
Хвостовая чешуя: Install the Tailscale client, sign in with your identity provider, and your device joins the tailnet. No firewall rules or port forwarding needed. Setup takes under five minutes. Managing access controls requires editing ACL policies, which is more technical than clicking “Connect.”
8. Поддержка платформы
Серфшарк: Works on Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, iOS, Android TV, Apple TV, and Fire TV. Browser extensions available for Chrome, Firefox, and Edge. You can also set it up on routers for whole-network coverage.
Хвостовая чешуя: Runs on Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, and Android. It also works on Raspberry Pi, Synology NAS, and other headless devices. No dedicated browser extensions since Tailscale operates at the network level, not the browser level.
9. Ценообразование и стоимость
| План | Серфшарк | Хвостовая чешуя |
|---|---|---|
| Бесплатно | ❌ (Только 7-дневный пробный период) | $0 (up to 3 users, 100 devices) |
| Вход платный | 1,99 доллара в месяц (на 2 года) | 5 долларов в месяц (Personal Plus) |
| Средний уровень | 3,19 доллара в месяц (1 год) | $6/user/month (Standard) |
| Премиум | 15,45 долларов в месяц (ежемесячно) | 18 долларов США/пользователь/месяц (Премиум) |
Серфшарк: One flat fee covers unlimited devices. The 2-year Starter plan at $1.99/month is among the cheapest consumer VPN options available. You pay for a subscription period, not per user or per device. Students get an extra 15% off through Студент Бобы.
Хвостовая чешуя: The free plan is genuinely free forever. No credit card required. For businesses, pricing scales per user: $6/user/month for Standard, $18/user/month for Premium. A 5-person team on Standard would pay $30/month total. Charities and educational groups get 50% off.
Различные сценарии
| Если вам это нужно | Выбирать | Почему |
|---|---|---|
| Конфиденциальность в интернете и потоковое вещание | Серфшарк | Hides IP, unblocks Netflix |
| Удаленный доступ к домашним устройствам | Хвостовая чешуя | Direct device-to-device connections |
| Защита общедоступных сетей Wi-Fi | Серфшарк | Шифрует весь интернет-трафик |
| Connecting servers across clouds | Хвостовая чешуя | Multi-cloud mesh networking |
| Cheapest option for one person | Хвостовая чешуя | Бесплатный тарифный план на 100 устройств. |
| Protecting a whole household | Серфшарк | Unlimited devices, flat rate |
💰 Ваш бюджет
If you want free, Tailscale’s Personal plan costs nothing. If you want a cheap paid VPN for privacy, Surfshark’s $1.99/month 2-year plan is hard to beat.
🔌 Ваш технологический стек
Surfshark has browser extensions for Chrome, Firefox, and Edge. Tailscale works at the network level and supports Google Cloud, AWS, and Kubernetes for developer workflows.
🔒 Ваши потребности в конфиденциальности
If you want to hide your browsing history and IP address from your ISP, pick Surfshark. If you want to create a secure private network between your own devices, pick Tailscale.
🎓 Ваш уровень опыта
Surfshark is a tap-and-go VPN. Anyone can use it. Tailscale is easy to install but managing ACLs and subnet routers requires some technical knowledge.
🆓 Бесплатные пробные версии и демо-версии
Surfshark has a 7-day free trial on mobile and a 30-day money-back guarantee. Tailscale’s free plan is permanent — no trial limits, no credit card needed.
🛟 Варианты поддержки
Surfshark offers 24/7 live chat and email support on all plans. Tailscale provides email support only, limited to business hours on the free plan.
Руководство по переключению
Уже используете один из этих инструментов? Вот чего следует ожидать, если вы перейдете на него.
🔄 Переходите с Surfshark на Tailscale?
✅ Что вы получите:
- Direct remote access to your home or office devices from anywhere
- Контроль доступа на основе принципа «нулевого доверия» на основе идентификации пользователя.
- Free plan with up to 100 device connections
❌ Что вы потеряете:
- IP address masking for online privacy
- Streaming unblocking (Netflix, Hulu, Disney+)
- Ad and tracker blocking with CleanWeb
📋 Как переключиться:
- Cancel your Surfshark subscription (request a refund within 30 days)
- Create a free Tailscale account at tailscale.com using a personal email
- Установите клиент Tailscale на каждое устройство, которое вы хотите подключить.
🔄 Переходите с Tailscale на Surfshark?
✅ Что вы получите:
- Full IP address hiding and browsing privacy
- Access to streaming content from 100 countries
- Kill switch, ad blocker, and MultiHop encryption
❌ Что вы потеряете:
- Direct remote access to your home or office machines
- Zero-trust mesh networking between devices
- MagicDNS and subnet router access to internal resources
📋 Как переключиться:
- Remove Tailscale clients from your devices (keep the free plan as a backup)
- Sign up for Surfshark’s 2-year Starter plan at $1.99/month
- Install the Surfshark app on your devices and connect
Что не было рассмотрено в нашем обзоре
This comparison focused on individual users and small teams. We didn’t test Tailscale’s Kubernetes integration or Surfshark’s Dedicated IP add-on in depth. Enterprise SSO setups, custom ACL policies, and large-scale Tailscale deployments with 50+ users were outside our scope. Our observations are based on the May 2026 versions of both products — features may have changed since then.
Окончательный вердикт
| Категория | Победитель |
|---|---|
| 💰 Цены (для потребителей) | Серфшарк |
| 🔒 Конфиденциальность в интернете | Серфшарк |
| 📺 Доступ к потоковой трансляции | Серфшарк |
| 🔌 Удаленный доступ | Хвостовая чешуя |
| 🏗️ Network Architecture | Хвостовая чешуя |
| 👶 Простота использования | Серфшарк |
| 🆓 Бесплатный план | Хвостовая чешуя |
| 🏆 Общий победитель | Серфшарк |
🏆 ПОБЕДИТЕЛЬ: Surfshark
Surfshark побеждает в 4 из 7 категорий.
Лучше всего подходит для: online privacy, streaming access, public Wi-Fi protection, and household-wide VPN coverage
Surfshark and Tailscale are two very different products that share the “VPN” label. Surfshark protects your online privacy by hiding your IP address and encrypting web traffic. Tailscale connects your devices into a secure private network for remote access.
Tailscale is excellent for developers, homelabbers, and IT teams who need to reach devices across networks. But if you want to browse privately, stream content from other countries, or protect your household on public Wi-Fi, Surfshark is the better choice.
You can actually use both at the same time. Many users run Tailscale for device access and Surfshark for browsing privacy.
Больше информации о Surfshark в сравнении с другими сервисами.
Вот как Surfshark выглядит на фоне других VPN-провайдеров:
Серфшарк против NordVPN
Surfshark побеждает по следующим критериям: lower price ($1.99 vs $3.09/month), unlimited device connections, Alternative ID feature
NordVPN лидирует по следующим параметрам: larger server network (6,000+ servers), faster raw download speeds, Threat Protection malware blocker
Surfshark против ExpressVPN
Surfshark побеждает по следующим критериям: significantly cheaper pricing, unlimited simultaneous connections, built-in ad blocker
ExpressVPN побеждает по следующим параметрам: wider router support, longer track record, Lightway protocol for faster connections
Surfshark против Proton VPN
Surfshark побеждает по следующим критериям: lower paid plan pricing, unlimited devices, CleanWeb ad blocking on all plans
Proton VPN выигрывает по следующим параметрам: free plan with no data limits, based in Switzerland (stronger privacy laws), open-source apps
Серфшарк против Киберпризрак
Surfshark побеждает по следующим критериям: unlimited device connections, smaller price gap on 2-year plans, MultiHop and Alternative ID
CyberGhost побеждает по следующим параметрам: larger server fleet (9,000+ servers), dedicated streaming-tagged servers, 45-day money-back guarantee
Больше информации о сравнении хвостовой части
Here’s how Tailscale stacks up against other secure networking tools:
Tailscale vs ZeroTier
Тейлскейл побеждает в следующих областях: easier setup (no manual network config), built-in MagicDNS, tighter SSO integration with identity providers
ZeroTier wins on: lower business pricing ($5/user/month), self-hosted controller option, supports Ethernet-level networking
Tailscale vs WireGuard (Manual)
Тейлскейл побеждает в следующих областях: automatic key management, no manual config files, NAT traversal handled automatically
WireGuard wins on: zero dependency on third-party services, full control over infrastructure, lower resource usage on servers
Tailscale vs Cloudflare Zero Trust
Тейлскейл побеждает в следующих областях: simpler setup for small teams, peer-to-peer mesh (no traffic routing through Cloudflare), generous free tier for personal use
Cloudflare wins on: free plan supports up to 50 users, deeper integration with Cloudflare’s CDN and DNS services, more enterprise compliance features
Часто задаваемые вопросы
Можно ли доверять VPN-сервису Surfshark?
Yes. Surfshark’s no-logs policy has been independently audited by Deloitte and Cure53. The company uses AES-256 encryption and is based in the Netherlands. While the Netherlands is part of the Nine Eyes alliance, the audits confirm that Surfshark does not store user data.
В чём разница между Tailscale и обычным VPN?
A normal VPN routes your traffic through a central server to hide your IP address. Tailscale creates a direct mesh network between your own devices using WireGuard. It does not hide your IP from websites. Tailscale is built for secure device access, not browsing privacy.
Can you use Tailscale and Surfshark together?
Yes. Many users run both. Tailscale handles device-to-device networking while Surfshark handles internet privacy and streaming. They serve different purposes and do not conflict with each other in most setups.
Можно ли бесплатно использовать Tailscale в личных целях?
Yes. The Personal plan is free forever. It supports up to 3 users and 100 devices. No credit card is required. Sign up with a personal email address like Gmail to get the free plan automatically.
Сколько стоит подписка на Surfshark?
The 2-year Starter plan costs $1.99/month. The 1-year plan costs $3.19/month. The monthly plan costs $15.45/month. Surfshark also offers One ($2.29/month on 2-year) and One+ ($4.19/month on 2-year) bundles with antivirus and data removal. For a full Surfshark VPN review, check our dedicated review page. Every premium VPN plan includes a 30 day money back guarantee.
Does Surfshark work with Private Internet Access?
Surfshark and Private Internet Access are competing VPN providers. You cannot run both at the same time on the same device. Pick one based on your needs. Surfshark offers unlimited connections while PIA limits you to 10 devices. A Surfshark review from most VPN review sites rates it higher on value.
Does Tailscale connect through multiple servers?
No. Tailscale does not route traffic through multiple servers like a consumer VPN. It creates direct peer-to-peer connections between devices. Surfshark’s servers span multiple servers across 100 countries, which is a different approach focused on giving you many server locations to choose from for online privacy.
English 
Spanish 
Chinese 
German 
French 
Arabic 
Russian 
Portuguese 
Japanese 
Korean 
Italian 
Turkish 
Dutch 
Polish 
Indonesian 
Thai 
Vietnamese 