⚡ Краткий вывод:
- Цены: ProtonVPN starts at $2.99/mo vs Hotspot Shield at $7.99/mo
- Лучше всего подходит для: ProtonVPN for privacy-first users, Hotspot Shield for fast streaming
- Ключевое отличие: ProtonVPN has 8,600+ servers and open-source apps; Hotspot Shield uses a proprietary Hydra protocol for speed
- Наш выбор: ProtonVPN for most users — better privacy, lower price, and a more generous free plan
Privacy and speed pull VPN buyers in opposite directions.
ProtonVPN is built by the team behind Proton Mail.
Hotspot Shield bets everything on its Hydra protocol for raw speed.
One is based in Switzerland. The other sits in the United States.
That single detail changes almost everything about how they handle your data.
Обзор
This ProtonVPN vs Hotspot Shield comparison covers pricing, privacy, speed, and streaming access.
We also break down the free plans on both sides.
В качестве источников информации мы используем опубликованные технические характеристики, официальную документацию и отзывы пользователей.
В итоге вы поймете, какой VPN-сервис лучше всего соответствует вашим потребностям.
Что такое ProtonVPN?
ProtonVPN is a VPN service from Proton Technologies AG.
The same team built Proton Mail, Proton Calendar, and Proton Drive.
It runs from Switzerland under some of the world’s strongest privacy laws.
Proton VPN offers a free tier and paid plans for all users.
All Proton apps are open-source, so anyone can аудит the code.
Is Proton VPN good? Yes — it’s well-suited for privacy-focused users.
ProtonVPN
Swiss-based VPN with open-source apps and a verified no-logs policy. Includes Secure Core servers, NetShield ad-blocker, and a free tier with no ads.
Цены на ProtonVPN
ProtonVPN has three plans. Here’s the cost breakdown.
| План | Цена | Лучше всего подходит для |
|---|---|---|
| Бесплатно | 0,00 долл./месяц | Обычный просмотр веб-страниц на одном устройстве |
| Плюс | 2,99 доллара в месяц | Streaming, torrenting, and full access |
| Без ограничений | 7,99 долларов в месяц | Full Proton suite with Mail, Calendar, and Drive |
Pricing verified May 2026.
Бесплатная пробная версия: No free trial needed. The free plan works with no time limit and no credit card.
Гарантия возврата денег: Возврат средств по всем оплаченным тарифным планам осуществляется в течение 30 дней.
📌 Примечание: The Plus plan gives access to all 8,600+ VPN servers, Secure Core routing, NetShield, and up to 10 simultaneous device connections.
⚠️ Предупреждение: The free plan limits you to one device and servers in only three countries: the US, Netherlands, and Japan.
Основные преимущества ProtonVPN
Here’s what makes ProtonVPN worth considering:
- Швейцарская юрисдикция: Switzerland is outside the Five Eyes, Nine Eyes, and 14 Eyes surveillance alliances. Your data stays protected by Swiss law.
- Подтвержденная политика отсутствия журналов регистрации: An independent third-party audit confirmed that ProtonVPN does not store user activity or IP logs.
- Защита основных серверов: Traffic routes through privacy-friendly countries before reaching the endpoint server. This adds an extra layer of protection.
- Блокировщик рекламы NetShield: Built-in DNS-level blocking stops ads, trackers, and malware before they reach your device.
- Код с открытым исходным кодом: Every Proton VPN app is published on GitHub. Security researchers can inspect the code at any time.
- Щедрый бесплатный уровень: The free version has no ads and unlimited bandwidth. Most other free VPNs show ads or cap data usage.
- Tor через VPN: Connect to the Tor network through dedicated Tor servers for extra anonymity. This is useful for blocking access to tracking scripts and protecting sensitive browsing.
Что заметила наша команда
Наш писатель signed up for ProtonVPN and explored the Proton VPN app across desktop and mobile. Here’s what stood out:
Плюсы и минусы ProtonVPN
✅ Плюсы
- Ad-free VPN with no data caps on the free plan
- Швейцарская юрисдикция с проверенной политикой отсутствия регистрации данных.
- Приложения с открытым исходным кодом на всех платформах
- Более 8600 серверов в 112 странах.
- Includes Tor over VPN and port forwarding
❌ Минусы
- Free plan limited to one device and three server locations
- Speeds can be slower than Hydra-based competitors
- Для бесплатных пользователей отсутствует поддержка в онлайн-чате.
- Время ответа службы поддержки клиентов может быть медленным.
Что такое Hotspot Shield?
Hotspot Shield is a VPN service owned by Aura (formerly Pango).
It’s known for its proprietary Hydra protocol, built for speed.
Компания базируется в Соединенных Штатах.
Hotspot Shield offers both a free version and premium accounts.
Защита от горячих точек
Speed-focused VPN with the Hydra protocol. Unblocks Netflix, Disney+, and other streaming platforms. Includes browser extensions for Chrome and Firefox.
Цены на Hotspot Shield
Hotspot Shield keeps its pricing simple. Here’s what it costs.
| План | Цена | Лучше всего подходит для |
|---|---|---|
| Бесплатно | $0 | Простой просмотр веб-страниц с ограниченным количеством серверов. |
| Премиум | 7,99 долларов в месяц | Full access to all servers and streaming |
Pricing verified May 2026.
Бесплатная пробная версия: 7-day free trial on the Premium plan. Credit card required.
Гарантия возврата денег: 45-day money-back guarantee on all paid plans.
📌 Примечание: The Hotspot Shield Premium plan allows up to ten devices with simultaneous connections. A Family plan is also available for $19.99/month, covering five users and 25 devices.
⚠️ Предупреждение: Hotspot Shield’s free version is ad-supported and limited to one US location. It also caps daily data at 500 MB and restricts speeds.
Основные преимущества Hotspot Shield
Вот почему Hotspot Shield заслуживает внимания:
- Протокол «Гидра»: A proprietary VPN protocol designed specifically for speed. It’s faster than standard OpenVPN in most speed tests.
- Доступ к потоковому вещанию: Hotspot Shield Premium unblocks US Netflix, Хулу, HBO Max, Disney+, and Amazon Prime Video.
- Расширения для браузера: Dedicated extensions for Chrome and Firefox let you connect from the browser without the full app.
- Fast Connection Times: The Windows app connects in about 4 to 5 seconds. Mobile apps connect even faster.
- Широкая поддержка платформ: Доступно для Windows и Mac. Android, iOS, Linux, and Amazon Fire TV.
- Срок возврата средств — 45 дней. Longer than the 30-day guarantee most VPN providers offer.
Что заметила наша команда
Our writer signed up for Hotspot Shield and tested the Hotspot Shield app on both desktop and mobile. Here’s what stood out:
Преимущества и недостатки Hotspot Shield
✅ Плюсы
- Hydra protocol delivers fast download and upload speeds
- Unblocks most major streaming platforms
- Simple app design with quick-connect feature
- Гарантия возврата денег в течение 45 дней – это дольше, чем в среднем.
❌ Минусы
- Базируется в США (под юрисдикцией альянса «Пять глаз»).
- Free version is ad-supported with 500 MB daily cap
- Logs session duration and bandwidth in anonymized format
- Функция аварийного отключения работает только с протоколом Hydra.
Сравнение характеристик
Let’s compare ProtonVPN and Hotspot Shield across 10 key areas.
This breakdown covers everything from privacy to speed to pricing.
| Особенность | ProtonVPN | Защита от горячих точек |
|---|---|---|
| Начальная цена | 2,99 доллара в месяц | 7,99 долларов в месяц |
| Бесплатный план | ✅ No ads, unlimited data | ✅ Ad-supported, 500 MB/day |
| Сеть серверов | Более 8600 человек в 112 странах. | Более 1800 в более чем 80 странах |
| Аудит без регистрации событий | ✅ Проверено третьей стороной | ❌ Not independently audited |
| Аварийный выключатель | ✅ Все протоколы | ⚠️ Только для Гидры |
| Разделение тоннелей | ✅ | ✅ |
| Поддержка потоковой передачи | ✅ Netflix, BBC iPlayer | ✅ Netflix, Hulu, Disney+ |
| Приложения с открытым исходным кодом | ✅ | ❌ |
| Одновременные устройства | До 10 | До 10 |
| Лучше всего подходит для | Пользователи, ориентированные на конфиденциальность | Speed and streaming users |
1. Конфиденциальность и юрисдикция
ProtonVPN: Based in Switzerland, which has a strict no logs policy backed by Swiss privacy law. Proton VPN passed a third-party audit confirming it stores no IP logs or activity data. The company publishes a transparency report showing how few legal requests it can fulfill. This makes it a truly secure VPN for anyone who cares about privacy.
Защита точки доступа: Based in the United States, part of the Five Eyes alliance. Hotspot Shield claims a no-logs policy, but it does record session duration, bandwidth used, and accessed domains in anonymized format. Hotspot Shield recorded these VPN sessions as part of its logging process. Privacy on Hotspot Shield is weaker than Swiss-based providers. The VPN company has not released transparency reports since 2019.
⚠️ Предупреждение: Hotspot Shield’s free version shares user data with third-party advertisers. If privacy is your top concern, the free version should be avoided.
2. Серверная сеть
ProtonVPN: Offers over 8,600 Proton VPN servers spread across 112 countries. This is a much larger network than most VPN providers. The wide server coverage helps with finding a fast local server and accessing content from specific regions.
Защита точки доступа: Has around 1,800+ servers across 80+ countries with 35+ cities. Fewer server locations overall, but Hotspot Shield hosts dedicated servers optimized for streaming and gaming. Hotspot Shield’s servers cover virtual locations for some regions as well.
3. Скорость и производительность
ProtonVPN: Supports WireGuard, OpenVPN, and IKEv2 VPN protocols. The VPN Accelerator feature uses advanced networking to boost internet speeds on long-distance connections. Speeds are solid, though WireGuard gives the best results.
Защита точки доступа: Uses its proprietary Hydra protocol, designed from the ground up for speed. According to published speed tests, Hotspot Shield’s speeds reached 210 Mbps download and strong upload speeds in some regions. Hotspot Shield performed well in most testing scenarios, making it one of the faster VPN services for streaming and gaming.
4. Free Plan Comparison
ProtonVPN: ProtonVPN’s free VPN plan has no ads, no data caps, and unlimited bandwidth. Compared to other free VPNs, it’s the most generous. However, it limits access to servers in three countries and allows only one device at a time. No P2P or Tor access on the free tier.
Защита точки доступа: Hotspot Shield’s free VPN is ad-supported with a 500 MB daily data limit. It’s restricted to one US location and one device. Speeds are capped, and streaming platforms are blocked on the free plan.
⚠️ Предупреждение: If you want a free VPN with no strings attached, ProtonVPN offers the better free tier by a wide margin. No ads, no data limits, and no speed throttling.
5. Стриминг и разблокировка
ProtonVPN: Unblocks Netflix, BBC iPlayer, and Amazon Prime Video on its Plus plan. ProtonVPN support staff confirm streaming is a supported use case. The Stealth protocol helps bypass VPN blocks in restrictive networks.
Защита точки доступа: Hotspot Shield Premium unblocks Netflix, Hulu, HBO Max, Disney+, Amazon Prime Video, and BBC iPlayer. The service has servers optimized for streaming and gaming servers for lower latency. Hotspot Shield works with most major platforms. However, Hotspot Shield’s free version does not unblock any streaming services.
6. Функции безопасности
ProtonVPN: Uses AES-256 encryption with Perfect Forward Secrecy. Every connection goes through an encrypted tunnel that protects your data from your internet service provider. Includes a kill switch on all platforms, DNS leak protection, and NetShield to block ads and malware. A DNS leak test confirms no DNS leaks when connected. Secure Core servers create a double VPN path by routing traffic through privacy-friendly countries before reaching the endpoint server.
Защита точки доступа: Also uses AES-256 encryption with IP leak protection to hide your real IP address. The app creates a secure connection between your mobile device and the VPN server. However, the Windows kill switch only works with the Hydra protocol. If you switch to WireGuard or IKEv2, the kill switch is disabled.
7. Раздельное туннелирование
ProtonVPN: Split tunneling lets you choose which apps use the encrypted VPN tunnel and which connect directly. Available on Windows and the Android app. Not yet available on iOS or macOS.
Защита точки доступа: Hotspot Shield’s split tunneling works on Windows, Android, and iOS. You can select specific apps or websites to bypass the VPN connection. The Hotspot Shield app makes it easy to toggle this setting.
8. Совместимость устройств
ProtonVPN: Работает на Windows. Мак, iOS, Android, Linux, Android TV, and Apple TV. Any Linux user will appreciate the full GUI Linux app, which is rare among VPN providers. Also works with smart TVs through the Android TV app. Supports up to 10 VPN connections at once on the Plus plan.
Защита точки доступа: Available on Windows, Mac, Android, iOS, and Amazon Fire TV. The Linux version is a command-line app only. Hotspot Shield’s mobile apps for Android and iOS are user-friendly with quick-connect features. Hotspot Shield also provides browser extensions for Chrome and Firefox. Premium allows up to ten devices with simultaneous device connections.
9. Поддержка клиентов
ProtonVPN: Offers email-based customer support and a detailed knowledge base on ProtonVPN’s website. Live chat support is not available. Response times vary, and some users report delays of 24-48 hours.
Защита точки доступа: Hotspot Shield’s support team provides live chat support for premium accounts only. Free users are limited to email support. The live chat typically responds within a few seconds during бизнес часы.
10. Ценообразование и ценность
| План | ProtonVPN | Защита от горячих точек |
|---|---|---|
| Бесплатно | $0.00/month (no ads) | $0 (ad-supported, 500 MB/day) |
| Paid (entry) | 2,99 доллара в месяц (плюс) | 7,99 долларов в месяц (Премиум) |
| Полный люкс | 7,99 долларов в месяц (безлимитный тариф) | $19.99/month (Family) |
ProtonVPN: At $2.99/month for the Plus plan, ProtonVPN is the cheaper paid option. The Unlimited plan at $7.99/month includes Proton Mail, Proton Calendar, and Proton Drive. You get the entire Proton services bundle for the same price as Hotspot Shield’s basic Premium plan.
Защита точки доступа: Premium costs $7.99/month, which is higher than many other VPN services at this level. A Hotspot Shield subscription on annual plans reduces the cost. The 45 day money back guarantee gives you time to test before committing.
Различные сценарии
| Если вам это нужно | Выбирать | Почему |
|---|---|---|
| Ограниченный бюджет | ProtonVPN | Plus plan is $5/mo cheaper |
| Лучший бесплатный VPN | ProtonVPN | No ads, no data caps |
| Быстрая потоковая передача | Защита от горячих точек | Hydra protocol + streaming servers |
| Максимальная конфиденциальность | ProtonVPN | Швейцарское законодательство, проверенные данные, отсутствие журналов регистрации. |
| Quick live chat help | Защита от горячих точек | 24/7 live chat for premium users |
| Linux desktop user | ProtonVPN | Full GUI Linux app |
💰 Ваш бюджет
ProtonVPN’s Plus plan costs $2.99/month. Hotspot Shield Premium costs $7.99/month. If cost matters most, ProtonVPN saves you about $60 per year.
🔌 Ваш технологический стек
ProtonVPN works well with the full Proton services suite — Mail, Calendar, and Drive. Hotspot Shield integrates with its parent company Aura’s security tools like antivirus and менеджер паролей.
📺 Ваши потребности в потоковой передаче
If you need to unblock Disney+, Hulu, and HBO Max, Hotspot Shield has a wider range of streaming servers optimized for those platforms. ProtonVPN handles Netflix and BBC iPlayer well but fewer services overall.
🎓 Ваш уровень опыта
Both apps are beginner-friendly. Hotspot Shield connects in a few seconds with one click. ProtonVPN has more settings, but the interface is clean and well-organized.
🆓 Бесплатные пробные версии и демо-версии
ProtonVPN’s free plan has no time limit and no credit card needed. Hotspot Shield offers a 7-day free trial of Premium, plus a 45 day money back guarantee.
🛟 Варианты поддержки
Hotspot Shield wins here with live chat support for paying users. ProtonVPN relies on email-only support, which can take a day or more to get a reply.
Руководство по переключению
Уже пользуетесь одним из этих VPN-сервисов? Вот чего следует ожидать, если вы перейдете на другой.
🔄 Переходите с ProtonVPN на Hotspot Shield?
✅ Что вы получите:
- Faster speeds via the Hydra protocol
- Dedicated streaming servers for more platforms
- 24/7 live chat support on premium accounts
❌ Что вы потеряете:
- Swiss jurisdiction and audited no-logs policy
- Приложения с открытым исходным кодом и маршрутизация Secure Core с двумя переходами.
- Ad-free VPN experience on the free plan
📋 Как переключиться:
- Отмените подписку на ProtonVPN в личном кабинете Proton.
- Download the Hotspot Shield app from hotspotshield.com
- Sign up for Premium and connect to a server
🔄 Переходите с Hotspot Shield на ProtonVPN?
✅ Что вы получите:
- Swiss privacy protection and verified no-logs policy
- Более 8600 серверов в 112 странах.
- Access to Proton Mail, Calendar, and Drive on the Unlimited plan
❌ Что вы потеряете:
- Hydra protocol’s raw speed advantage
- Расширения для браузеров Chrome и Firefox
- Онлайн-чат поддержки клиентов
📋 Как переключиться:
- Отмените подписку на Hotspot Shield в настройках своей учетной записи.
- Create a free Proton account at protonvpn.com
- Download the Proton VPN app and upgrade to Plus or Unlimited
Что не было рассмотрено в нашем обзоре
This comparison focused on individual users and small teams. We didn’t test enterprise VPN deployments or router-level setups. Our observations are based on the May 2026 versions of both apps. If you need a VPN for an entire office or for custom configurations, your priorities may differ from what we’ve covered here.
Окончательный вердикт
| Категория | Победитель |
|---|---|
| 💰 Цены | ProtonVPN |
| 🔒 Конфиденциальность | ProtonVPN |
| 🚀 Скорость | Защита от горячих точек |
| 📺 Трансляция | Защита от горячих точек |
| 🆓 Бесплатный план | ProtonVPN |
| 🔌 Поддержка устройств | ProtonVPN |
| 🛟 Служба поддержки клиентов | Защита от горячих точек |
| 🏆 Общий победитель | ProtonVPN |
🏆 ПОБЕДИТЕЛЬ: ProtonVPN
ProtonVPN wins 4 out of 7 categories.
Лучше всего подходит для: Privacy-focused users, budget-conscious buyers, Linux users, and anyone who wants a reliable free VPN.
ProtonVPN and Hotspot Shield serve different types of users. ProtonVPN is built for people who put privacy first. Swiss jurisdiction, open-source code, and an audited no-logs policy make it the stronger choice for protecting your internet traffic.
Hotspot Shield is a solid pick if raw speed and streaming matter most. The Hydra protocol delivers fast connections, and the streaming server network covers more platforms.
However, ProtonVPN costs less, has more servers, and offers a far better free version. For most VPN buyers, that combination is hard to beat.
Сравнение ProtonVPN: больше возможностей
Here’s how ProtonVPN stacks up against other VPN providers:
ProtonVPN против NordVPN
ProtonVPN побеждает по следующим показателям: Open-source apps, Swiss privacy jurisdiction, more transparent no-logs audit
NordVPN лидирует по следующим параметрам: Faster connection speeds, larger product lineup, dedicated IP addresses
ProtonVPN против ExpressVPN
ProtonVPN побеждает по следующим показателям: Lower pricing at $2.99/month, free plan availability, open-source codebase
ExpressVPN побеждает по следующим параметрам: Wider streaming unblocking, faster customer support response, TrustedServer RAM-only infrastructure
ProtonVPN против SurfsharkVPN
ProtonVPN побеждает по следующим показателям: Swiss jurisdiction versus Netherlands, Secure Core double-hop routing, ad-free free tier
SurfsharkVPN побеждает в следующих областях: Unlimited device connections, CleanWeb ad-blocker on all plans, lower long-term pricing
ProtonVPN против Киберпризрак
ProtonVPN побеждает по следующим показателям: Privacy transparency with open-source code, better free plan, Tor over VPN access
CyberGhost побеждает по следующим параметрам: More streaming-optimized servers, 45-day refund window, NoSpy dedicated server option
Сравнение функций Hotspot Shield
Вот как Hotspot Shield выглядит на фоне других VPN-провайдеров:
Hotspot Shield против NordVPN
Hotspot Shield побеждает в: Hydra protocol speed, browser extensions for Chrome and Firefox, longer 45-day refund period
NordVPN лидирует по следующим параметрам: Larger server network, stronger privacy reputation, lower annual pricing
Hotspot Shield против ExpressVPN
Hotspot Shield побеждает в: Raw speed with Hydra protocol, free plan availability, Family plan for multiple users
ExpressVPN побеждает по следующим параметрам: Better privacy jurisdiction (British Virgin Islands), wider device support, stronger streaming record
Hotspot Shield против SurfsharkVPN
Hotspot Shield побеждает в: Faster peak speeds, dedicated streaming and gaming servers, 7-day free trial
SurfsharkVPN побеждает в следующих областях: Unlimited devices, much lower pricing on 2-year plans, CleanWeb ad-blocking
Часто задаваемые вопросы
Безопасно ли использовать ProtonVPN?
Yes. ProtonVPN is based in Switzerland and has a strict no-logs policy verified by a third-party audit. All apps are open-source, so security researchers can inspect the code directly.
Действительно ли Hotspot Shield бесплатен?
Yes, but the free version has limits. You get 500 MB of data per day, one US server location, and ads. The Premium plan removes all limits and gives full internet access.
Можно ли доверять Hotspot Shield?
It depends on your threat model. The privacy Hotspot Shield provides is limited since it’s based in the US and logs some session data in anonymized form. For casual browsing, it’s fine. A Swiss-based VPN provider like ProtonVPN is the safer choice for high-risk needs.
Работает ли ProtonVPN с Netflix?
Yes. The Plus and Unlimited plans can unblock Netflix libraries in several countries. The free plan does not support streaming.
Which is better for speed — ProtonVPN or Hotspot Shield?
Hotspot Shield is generally faster due to its Hydra protocol. ProtonVPN’s VPN Accelerator closes the gap on long-distance connections, but Hydra still has the edge in raw speed tests.
Does Proton VPN work in restricted countries?
Yes. The Stealth protocol helps bypass VPN blocks. Proton VPN easy setup works even on restricted networks. The Proton VPN support staff can help if you run into issues.
Is Hotspot Shield an expensive VPN compared to others?
Compared to other VPN companies, Hotspot Shield Premium at $7.99/month is on the higher end. Many premium VPN providers charge $3-5/month on annual plans. We recommend Hotspot Shield mainly for users who value speed over cost.
How much data does Hotspot Shield free give you?
The free plan gives 500 MB per day. That’s enough for basic browsing but not streaming. Hotspot Shield subscription options start at $7.99/month for unlimited data. Hotspot Shield deals may appear during holiday sales.
Does Hotspot Shield have a dedicated IP address option?
No, a dedicated IP address is not available. Both VPN services use shared IP addresses. If you need a dedicated IP, check other VPN services like NordVPN. You can connect to a local server for the fastest connection.
Can you read a Proton VPN review or Hotspot Shield review on FahimAI?
Yes. We have a full Proton VPN review and a separate Hotspot Shield VPN review available. Each covers testing Hotspot Shield and ProtonVPN individually. Check our Hotspot Shield review for details on the Hotspot Shield process of connecting and the app’s performance.
English 
Spanish 
Chinese 
German 
French 
Arabic 
Russian 
Portuguese 
Japanese 
Korean 
Italian 
Turkish 
Dutch 
Polish 
Indonesian 
Thai 
Vietnamese 