⚡ Краткий вывод:
- Цены: LastPass Premium runs $3.00/mo. Proton Pass starts free, then $2.99/month on Pass Plus.
- Лучше всего подходит для: LastPass suits families and бизнес teams needing access management. Proton Pass suits privacy-first individuals.
- Ключевое отличие: Proton Pass adds hide my email aliases and open source code. LastPass adds emergency access and deeper user management.
- Наш выбор: LastPass, on its 3.8 rating and wider account controls across five paid tiers.
One of these password managers lost customer vault backups in 2022.
The other has never reported a breach at all.
That single fact drives most of this decision.
But it is not the whole story on features or price.
Here is how both tools actually handle your login credentials.
Обзор
This LastPass vs Proton Pass comparison covers pricing, security features, sharing, and daily password management.
Наш писатель spent hands-on time inside LastPass directly.
Notes on Proton Pass come from published documentation, аудит reports, and G2 reviews.
We also break down who each secure password manager really fits.
By the end, you will know which vault deserves all your passwords.
Что такое LastPass?
LastPass is a popular password manager launched in 2008.
One complex master password unlocks the whole LastPass vault.
The LastPass password manager then keeps your passwords safe on every device.
Everything inside is held as encrypted данные on LastPass servers.
Your LastPass account can also securely store secure notes and payment cards.
The LastPass browser extension fills logins on any mobile device or desktop.
Here is a short walkthrough of how the vault behaves day to day.
🏆 Winner: LastPass
Five paid tiers cover one person up to a full company. Emergency access and dark web monitoring come standard on Premium.
Цены LastPass
Here is what the paid plans cost in 2026.
| План | Цена | Лучше всего подходит для |
|---|---|---|
| Премиум | 3,00 долл./мес. | One person wanting unlimited password storage |
| Семьи | 4,00 долл./мес. | Up to six people sharing a secure vault |
| Команды | 4,25 доллара в месяц. | Small groups needing shared folders |
| Бизнес | 7,00 долларов в месяц. | Companies needing access management and SSO |
| Бизнес МАКС | 9,00 долларов в месяц. | Firms wanting advanced отчетность on employee access |
Pricing verified August 2026.
Бесплатная пробная версия: Yes. Premium and Families both offer a 30-day trial with no card charge upfront.
Гарантия возврата денег: 30 days on annual plans if you cancel inside the window.
📌 Примечание: A LastPass free version also exists outside this table. That free plan limits users to one device type, phone or computer, not both.
⚠️ Предупреждение: These are monthly rates billed annually. Renewal happens automatically, so cancel before the anniversary date if you plan to leave.
Key Benefits of LastPass
Here is what keeps LastPass users on this secure password management tool.
- Unlimited password storage: Every paid tier holds unlimited passwords across every device you own. Nothing throttles the vault as it grows.
- LastPass security dashboard: The security dashboard scores your stored passwords and flags weak passwords. It doubles as a set of password reminders for aging entries.
- Мониторинг даркнета: Premium watches breach dumps for your email. Alerts land before criminals finish торговля the data.
- Доступ в экстренных случаях: Nominate someone to inherit vault access after a waiting period. Most password managers skip this entirely.
- Encrypted file storage: Premium adds 1GB of encrypted file storage for passports and licences. Files sit beside the matching login.
- LastPass Authenticator: A separate authenticator app handles push approvals. It works with third-party sites too.
- Passwordless login: Open the vault with a fingerprint or the LastPass mobile app instead of typing.
Что заметила наша команда
Our writer set up a LastPass account and moved a live vault into it over several days. Here is what stood out:
LastPass Pros & Cons
✅ Плюсы
- Five paid tiers from one person to full business
- Emergency access and password sharing built in
- Dark web monitoring and a security dashboard on Premium
- 1GB of encrypted file storage per account
- Passwordless login through the LastPass Authenticator
❌ Минусы
- A 2022 security incident exposed encrypted vault backups
- The free version limits users to a single device type
- Source code is closed, so nobody outside can inspect it
- No email aliasing to shield your personal email address
Что такое протонный пролив?
Proton Pass is an open source password manager from Switzerland.
Proton AG owns Proton Pass, along with Proton Mail and Proton Drive.
Its code is public, and Cure53 has audited it independently.
Every item is end to end encrypted before it ever leaves your machine.
One Proton account also opens Proton Calendar and the other Proton services.
Signup takes about a minute, and Proton Pass free needs no payment details.
Протонный перевал
A privacy-first vault with email aliases and an integrated 2FA authenticator. Free forever across unlimited devices.
Proton Pass Pricing
Proton Pass offers a free tier plus three paid plans.
| План | Цена | Лучше всего подходит для |
|---|---|---|
| Бесплатно | $0 | Individuals storing unlimited logins |
| Pass Plus | 2,99 доллара в месяц | Dark web monitoring and vault sharing |
| Семья Пасс | 4,99 доллара в месяц | Up to six users on one plan |
| Протон Безлимитный | 9,99 долларов в месяц | Mail, Drive, and a virtual private network |
Pricing verified August 2026.
Бесплатная пробная версия: Not needed. The free version is free forever with no card required.
Гарантия возврата денег: 30 days on paid plans if you cancel inside that window.
📌 Примечание: Business tiers sell separately as Pass Essentials and Pass Professional. Those quotes come from Proton sales rather than the public page.
⚠️ Pricing conflict: Proton Pass has no row in our pricing sheet, so these figures come from Proton documentation. An earlier version of our page listed the same tiers in euros (€2.99, €4.99, €9.99). Check the checkout page for your region before you buy.
Key Benefits of Proton Pass
Here is what pulls people toward this free password manager.
- Free plan with no caps: Store unlimited passwords across unlimited devices. Many password managers throttle their free tier instead.
- Hide my email aliases: Generate a random address per site. Your personal email address stays off every breach list.
- Мониторинг даркнета: Pass Monitor flags reused entries and scans for exposed login details. It sits on Pass Plus and above.
- Integrated 2FA authenticator: TOTP codes live beside each login. No separate authenticator app is needed.
- Протонный Страж: These advanced security features watch for suspicious sign-ins on your Proton Pass account.
- Wide platform reach: Desktop apps cover Windows, Мак, and Linux. A browser extension and mobile builds handle the rest.
- Easy imports: Bring existing passwords in as JSON, CSV, ZIP, or XML from other password managers.
Что заметила наша команда
Note: We have not had extended hands-on time with Proton Pass yet. Everything above comes from Proton documentation, the Cure53 audit reports, and G2 reviews.
Proton Pass Pros & Cons
✅ Плюсы
- Free plan covers unlimited devices with no storage cap
- Open source code audited by Cure53
- Hide my email aliases cut spam at the source
- Built-in 2FA authenticator and Proton Sentinel alerts
- Apps for Windows, Mac, Linux, iOSи Android
❌ Минусы
- Paid tiers cost more than НордПасс or Bitwarden
- Support lacks live chat support
- Team admin controls are thinner than business rivals
- No emergency access handover for a nominated contact
Сравнение характеристик
Both tools guard the same thing. They just build very different walls around it.
We compared ten areas that decide which vault fits your work. Start with the summary, then read the detail below.
| Особенность | LastPass | Протонный перевал |
|---|---|---|
| Начальная цена | 3,00 долл./мес. | Free, then $2.99/month |
| Бесплатный план | ✅ (one device type) | ✅ Бесплатно навсегда |
| Zero Knowledge Encryption | ✅ | ✅ |
| Open Source Code | ❌ | ✅ |
| Hide My Email Aliases | ❌ | ✅ |
| Мониторинг даркнета | ✅ (Премиум) | ✅ (Pass Plus) |
| Аварийный доступ | ✅ | ❌ |
| Integrated 2FA Authenticator | ❌ (отдельное приложение) | ✅ |
| Encrypted File Storage | ✅ (1GB) | ✅ (attachments) |
| Reported Breach History | 2022 incident | None reported |
| Лучше всего подходит для | Families and business teams | Privacy-first individuals |
1. Архитектура безопасности и шифрование
LastPass: Encryption happens on your device, so LastPass never sees your master password. That model held up in 2022, when attackers copied encrypted vault backups from LastPass servers. Weak master passwords were the exposure, which is why LastPass security now enforces a longer minimum.
Протонный перевал: AES-256 strong encryption protects every entry of sensitive data, and items stay end to end encrypted on Proton’s servers. The zero knowledge design means only you hold the keys. Cure53 audited the code, and anyone can read it.
⚠️ Предупреждение: No vendor can rescue a weak master password. Pick a long passphrase before you move a single entry.
2. Vault and Password Management
LastPass: The vault holds logins, secure notes, cards, and addresses in named folders. LastPass features also include 1GB of encrypted file storage for documents. Password management stays organised even past a thousand records.
Протонный перевал: It stores more than just your passwords, covering cards, aliases, and secure notes. Recent builds added file attachments, so sensitive information can be stored securely beside a login. Existing passwords import as JSON, CSV, ZIP, or XML.
3. Plans, Devices and Free Version Limits
LastPass: Five paid tiers run from Premium up to Business MAX. LastPass Teams, LastPass Families, and LastPass Business each add seats and admin tooling. The catch sits on the free tier, where the free version limits users to one device type.
Протонный перевал: Free users store unlimited passwords on unlimited devices with no seat cap. That free plan is the strongest in this category. Paid plans then layer on aliases, sharing, and monitoring.
4. Генератор паролей
LastPass: Пароль генератор builds a secure password of any length from the extension or the app. Every new entry saves straight into the vault. It is the fastest route to unique credentials on every site.
Протонный перевал: Password generation offers random strings or memorable phrases, depending on what you have to type by hand. Both formats meet the same strength targets. Proton Pass offers the choice at signup time, not buried in settings.
5. Multi Factor Authentication
LastPass: Multifactor authentication covers hardware keys, biometrics, and the LastPass Authenticator with push approval. Business tiers extend multi factor authentication policies across staff accounts. The codes live in a separate app rather than the vault.
Протонный перевал: An integrated 2FA authenticator sits inside the vault itself. Two factor authentication codes appear next to the matching login, so you copy nothing between apps. Proton Sentinel adds sign-in monitoring on top.
6. Dark Web Monitoring and Email Aliases
LastPass: Dark web monitoring watches breach dumps for addresses tied to your account. Alerts arrive in the security dashboard when a match surfaces. There is no aliasing layer, so your real address still lands on every signup form.
Протонный перевал: Hide my email aliases generate a throwaway address per site, which is why reviewers recommend Proton Pass for personal privacy. Ten aliases come free, and Pass Plus removes the cap. Pass Monitor then flags exposures on the dark web.
7. Passwordless Login and Vault Access
LastPass: Passwordless login opens the хранилище паролей with a fingerprint or a push from the LastPass mobile app. You still keep a master password for recovery. Emergency access lets a nominated contact reach the vault after a waiting period.
Протонный перевал: Biometrics unlock the desktop apps and mobile builds, and passkey support is built in. There is no handover feature for a trusted contact. That gap matters more than most buyers expect.
8. Save, Autofill and Browser Extensions
LastPass: The LastPass extension saves and autofills across Chrome, Firefox, Edge, and Safari. Support for Internet Explorer was retired years ago. Browser extensions carry most of the daily workload here.
Протонный перевал: A browser extension handles autofill so you can securely log in anywhere. Since Proton Pass launched, the Proton Pass apps have spread to Windows, Mac, Linux, iOS, and Android. Nothing is browser-only.
9. Password Sharing and User Management
LastPass: Password sharing runs through shared folders with per-person permissions. Admin access management on Business tiers covers provisioning, revocation, and reporting on employee access. User management is the clearest advantage LastPass holds.
Протонный перевал: Sharing works through secure links or vault invites, and Pass Plus covers up to ten recipients. Everything stays encrypted in transit. Admin layers are lighter than a business buyer usually expects, which keeps managing passwords simple but limits control.
10. Password Hygiene and Reminders
LastPass: The LastPass security dashboard scores every entry and surfaces reused or weak passwords. Password reminders nudge you when an entry ages past a safe window. That feedback loop builds good password hygiene faster than any lecture.
Протонный перевал: Pass Monitor scores stored passwords and warns on reuse. It also checks whether login credentials have appeared in a data breach. Reporting stops at the individual, with nothing for staff auditing.
💡 Полезный совет: Fix every reused entry before you migrate. Carrying weak credentials into a different password manager solves nothing.
11. Ценообразование и стоимость
Here are the paid plans side by side.
| Уровень | LastPass | Протонный перевал |
|---|---|---|
| Бесплатно | One device type only | $0, free forever |
| Вход платный | Premium, $3.00/mo. | Pass Plus, $2.99/month |
| Семья | Families, $4.00/mo. | Pass Family, $4.99/month |
| Команда | Teams, $4.25/mo. | Pass Essentials, contact sales |
| Бизнес | Business, $7.00/mo. · Business MAX, $9.00/mo. | Pass Professional, contact sales |
LastPass: Premium sits a cent above Pass Plus, but the ladder above it is far deeper. Business MAX at $9.00/mo. buys reporting no Proton tier matches. For teams, that ladder is the whole argument.
Протонный перевал: The free tier costs nothing and caps nothing, which is rare. Proton Unlimited at $9.99/month bundles Proton Mail, Proton Drive, and Proton VPN for secure communication in one bill. Per seat, though, its premium plans run above NordPass and Битварден.
Различные сценарии
| Если вам это необходимо… | Выбирать | Почему |
|---|---|---|
| A free vault forever | Протонный перевал | No cap on logins or devices |
| Staff access controls | LastPass | Provisioning and reporting built in |
| Email privacy | Протонный перевал | Hide my email aliases |
| Emergency access handover | LastPass | Nominate a trusted contact |
| Code you can inspect | Протонный перевал | Open source and Cure53 audited |
| One vault for six people | LastPass | Families at $4.00/mo. |
💰 Ваш бюджет
Solo users pay nothing with Proton Pass. At family size, LastPass Families undercuts Pass Family by a dollar a month.
🔌 Ваш технологический стек
Already paying for Proton Mail or Proton VPN? Proton Unlimited folds password storage into that same bill.
🛡️ Your Risk Tolerance
Past security breaches matter to some buyers more than any feature list. Proton Pass has no comparable incident on record.
🎓 Ваш уровень опыта
Both tools walk beginners through setup in minutes. LastPass asks more questions about recovery before you finish.
🆓 Бесплатные пробные версии и демо-версии
Test LastPass on the 30-day Premium trial with real accounts online. Run Proton Pass free alongside it and compare autofill.
🛟 Варианты поддержки
LastPass business tiers include phone support. Proton answers by email and lacks live chat support on every plan.
Руководство по переключению
Already using one of these? Here is what changes if you move.
🔄 Switching from LastPass to Proton Pass?
✅ Что вы получите:
- Hide my email aliases on every signup form
- Open code, plus a clean breach record
- A free tier you can keep on unlimited devices
❌ Что вы потеряете:
- Emergency access for a nominated contact
- Deep admin reporting on employee accounts
- 1GB of encrypted file storage per seat
📋 Как переключиться:
- Export the LastPass vault to CSV from the web console
- Create a Proton account and open Pass
- Import the CSV, then delete the export file
🔄 Switching from Proton Pass to LastPass?
✅ Что вы получите:
- Shared folders with per-person permissions
- Emergency access and encrypted file storage
- Five paid tiers as headcount grows
❌ Что вы потеряете:
- Email aliases and the free forever plan
- The integrated 2FA authenticator inside the vault
- Public source code and Swiss jurisdiction
📋 Как переключиться:
- Export your Proton Pass vault as CSV or JSON
- Start the LastPass trial and set a complex master password
- Import, then build shared folders before inviting anyone
Что не было рассмотрено в нашем обзоре
This comparison focused on individuals, families, and small teams. We did not evaluate the Pass Essentials or Pass Professional business tiers, and we did not stress-test either vault past a few hundred entries. Our notes reflect the August 2026 builds. If you run 100 seats or need SCIM provisioning, your priorities will differ from what we covered here.
Окончательный вердикт
| Категория | Победитель |
|---|---|
| 💰 Цены | Протонный перевал |
| 🔐 Шифрование | Галстук |
| 👥 Управление пользователями | LastPass |
| 🕵️ Privacy Features | Протонный перевал |
| 📱 Приложения и доступ | Протонный перевал |
| 🚨 Emergency Access | LastPass |
| 🗂️ Plan Range | LastPass |
| 🛡️ Security Track Record | Протонный перевал |
| 🏆 Общий победитель | LastPass |
🏆 WINNER: LASTPASS
LastPass takes the overall spot on its 3.8 rating, though it wins only 3 of 8 categories.
Лучше всего подходит для: families sharing one vault, малый бизнес managing staff logins, and anyone who needs emergency access.
That scorecard deserves an honest note. LastPass carries the higher rating and the deeper plan ladder, but Proton Pass wins more individual categories.
If you manage other people, LastPass is the practical pick. Provisioning, revocation, and password sharing across a team are things Proton has not matched yet.
If you are protecting one person’s accounts, the answer flips. Proton Pass is free, open source, and has never lost customer data.
Either choice beats reusing the same password everywhere. Pick one this week and start moving entries across.
More of LastPass Compared
Here is how LastPass lines up against the closest rivals people shortlist beside it. Our full LastPass review covers the 2022 fallout in more detail.
LastPass vs 1Пароль
LastPass wins on: a usable free tier, emergency access handover, cheaper entry price at $3.00/mo.
1Password wins on: a secret key layered over the master password, Путешествовать Mode for border crossings, a cleaner breach record
LastPass wins on: polished autofill on mobile, dark web monitoring on Premium, guided onboarding for non-technical staff
Bitwarden wins on: a free tier with no device-type limit, public source code, self-hosting for teams wanting their own server
LastPass vs Дашлейн
LastPass wins on: lower per-seat cost across every tier, encrypted file storage on Premium, a wider set of business plans
Dashlane wins on: a bundled virtual private network, phishing alerts on paid tiers, faster credential-change автоматизация
This video walks through several Альтернативы LastPass if neither tool here fits.
More of Proton Pass Compared
And here is where Proton Pass sits against the other privacy-minded vaults. Our Proton Pass review goes deeper on each one.
Proton Pass wins on: email aliasing built into the vault, Swiss jurisdiction, one login shared across Mail and Drive
Bitwarden wins on: a $10 yearly premium tier, self-hosted deployment, deeper organisation features for developers
Proton Pass wins on: an uncapped free plan, open code anyone can audit, aliases and a 2FA authenticator in one place
NordPass wins on: XChaCha20 encryption, cheaper multi-year pricing, a lighter interface on older machines
Proton Pass wins on: a genuinely free tier, alias generation per site, bundled mail and VPN on the top plan
1Password wins on: a mature admin console, secrets management for engineering teams, faster desktop autofill
Часто задаваемые вопросы
Остаётся ли LastPass хорошим менеджером паролей?
Yes, for families and teams. The 2022 incident hurt trust, but encryption held and the admin tooling remains stronger than most rivals offer.
Сколько стоит LastPass в месяц?
Premium is $3.00/mo. and Families is $4.00/mo. Business tiers run $4.25, $7.00, and $9.00 per month.
Can I use Proton Pass for free?
Yes. The free tier stores unlimited logins on unlimited devices and includes ten email aliases. No card is required to start.
Proton Pass лучше, чем LastPass?
For one person, yes. It costs nothing, the code is public, and no breach has been reported. For staff management, LastPass still leads.
Who owns Proton Pass?
Proton AG, the Swiss company behind Proton Mail and Proton VPN. Swiss privacy law covers everything held on its infrastructure.
English 
Spanish 
Chinese 
German 
French 
Arabic 
Russian 
Portuguese 
Japanese 
Korean 
Italian 
Turkish 
Dutch 
Polish 
Indonesian 
Thai 
Vietnamese 