⚡ 간단 평가:
- 가격: ProtonVPN starts at $0/month (free plan) vs McAfee VPN at $39.99/year bundled with antivirus
- 다음과 같은 경우에 가장 적합합니다: ProtonVPN for privacy-focused users and free VPN needs, McAfee VPN for all-in-one security bundles
- 주요 차이점: ProtonVPN is a standalone VPN with 8,600+ servers and a strict no-logs policy. McAfee VPN is part of an antivirus package with limited VPN features.
- 저희가 선택한 제품: ProtonVPN for most users — stronger privacy, more servers, and a usable free tier
ProtonVPN and McAfee VPN serve very different users.
One is a privacy-first VPN built by the team behind Proton Mail.
The other is a VPN add-on bundled with antivirus software.
This comparison helps you pick the right VPN service for your needs.
개요
This ProtonVPN vs McAfee VPN comparison covers pricing, privacy, server networks, and ease of use.
또한 각 VPN 제공업체가 어떤 사용자에게 가장 적합한지 분석해 보았습니다.
저희 자료 출처에는 공개된 사양서, 공식 문서 및 사용자 리뷰가 포함됩니다.
By the end, you’ll know which VPN service fits your internet connection needs.
ProtonVPN이란 무엇인가요?
ProtonVPN is a VPN service from Proton Technologies AG.
The same team built Proton Mail, the encrypted email service.
ProtonVPN is based in Switzerland under strong privacy laws.
It offers a free VPN tier with no ads and unlimited bandwidth.
프로톤VPN
Swiss-based VPN with a strict no-logs policy and open-source apps. Free plan available with no ads.
ProtonVPN 가격
ProtonVPN has three plans, including a free tier.
| 계획 | 가격 | 가장 적합한 대상 |
|---|---|---|
| 무료 | 월 0달러 | 기본적인 개인정보 보호를 유지하면서 가볍게 웹서핑을 즐겨보세요. |
| 을 더한 | 월 2.99달러 | 스트리밍 및 전체 서버 접근 권한 |
| 제한 없는 | 월 7.99달러 | Users of Proton Mail, Calendar, and Drive |
Pricing verified May 2026.
무료 체험: No free trial needed — the free plan is permanent with no credit card required.
환불 보장: 모든 유료 플랜에 대해 30일 환불 보장을 제공합니다.
📌 메모: The Unlimited plan bundles Proton Mail, Proton Calendar, and Proton Drive. If you already use Proton services, this plan offers the best value.
⚠️ 경고: The free plan limits you to servers in 3 countries (US, Netherlands, Japan) and only 1 device. Upgrading to Plus unlocks all VPN servers and 10 VPN connections.
ProtonVPN의 주요 이점
Here’s what makes ProtonVPN worth considering:
- 스위스 개인정보보호법: ProtonVPN operates under Switzerland’s strict no-logs policy. Switzerland is not part of Five Eyes, Nine Eyes, or 14 Eyes surveillance alliances.
- 거대한 서버 네트워크: Over 8,600 VPN servers in 112 countries give you plenty of server locations to choose from.
- 보안 코어 서버: Traffic routes through privacy-friendly countries before reaching the endpoint server. This adds a layer of protection for your IP address.
- 오픈 소스 앱: All Proton VPN apps are open-source and independently audited. You can inspect the code yourself.
- 무료 플랜: The free version has no ads and unlimited bandwidth. Most other free VPNs limit data or show ads.
- 넷쉴드 광고 차단기: Blocks ads, trackers, and malware at the DNS level. This speeds up your browsing and protects your online activity.
- VPN 가속기: Uses advanced networking to boost connection speeds. This is especially helpful on long-distance server connections.
우리 팀이 발견한 점
우리의 작가 signed up for ProtonVPN and spent several days exploring the platform. Here’s what stood out:
ProtonVPN의 장점과 단점
✅ 장점
- 광고 없이 무제한 대역폭을 제공하는 무료 플랜
- 감시 동맹 외부에 있는 스위스 관할권
- 112개국에 걸쳐 8,600개 이상의 서버 보유
- 독립적인 감사를 받은 오픈 소스 앱
- Supports 10 simultaneous VPN connections
❌ 단점
- 무료 플랜은 서버 위치 3곳과 기기 1대로 제한됩니다.
- 실시간 채팅 지원은 제공하지 않으며, 이메일로만 지원해 드립니다.
- VPN 가속기를 사용하지 않으면 원거리 서버에서 속도가 저하될 수 있습니다.
McAfee VPN이란 무엇인가요?
McAfee VPN (also called McAfee Safe Connect) is a VPN service bundled with McAfee’s antivirus packages.
It is part of McAfee’s All-in-One Protection suite.
The VPN focuses on public Wi-Fi protection and basic online security.
McAfee is based in the United States, which affects its data policies.
McAfee VPN
All-in-one security suite that includes VPN, antivirus, and identity protection. Built for users who want bundled security.
McAfee VPN 가격
McAfee VPN is sold as part of security bundles, not as a standalone product.
| 계획 | 가격 | 가장 적합한 대상 |
|---|---|---|
| 필수적인 | 연간 39.99달러 | 기기 1대용 기본 바이러스 백신 + VPN |
| 고급 개인 | 연간 89.99달러 | 신원 모니터링을 통한 완벽한 보호 |
| 고급 가족 | 연간 119.99달러 | 여러 기기를 사용하는 가정을 위한 서비스 |
Pricing verified May 2026.
무료 체험: McAfee offers a 30-day free trial for new users. Credit card required.
환불 보장: 모든 플랜에 대해 30일 환불 보장을 제공합니다.
📌 메모: The VPN is bundled with antivirus, identity protection, and a password manager. You cannot buy the McAfee VPN separately from the security suite.
⚠️ 경고: Unlimited VPN bandwidth is only available if you enroll in automatic renewal. If auto-renewal is off, your VPN data may be capped.
McAfee VPN의 주요 이점
McAfee VPN을 고려해 볼 만한 이유는 다음과 같습니다.
- 올인원 보안: The VPN comes with antivirus, identity monitoring, and a password manager. You get multiple tools in one subscription.
- 자동 Wi-Fi 보호: McAfee VPN activates when you connect to unsecured public Wi-Fi. This protects your data without manual action.
- 신원 보호: Advanced plans include credit monitoring and identity theft coverage. This goes beyond what most VPN providers offer.
- 간편한 설치: The McAfee Safe Connect interface is simple for beginners. You can connect with one click.
- AES-256 암호화: McAfee VPN uses AES-256 encryption to protect your internet traffic while connected.
- DNS 유출 방지: The VPN includes DNS leak protection to keep your IP address hidden.
우리 팀이 발견한 점
Our writer signed up for McAfee’s security suite and spent several days testing the VPN feature. Here’s what stood out:
McAfee VPN의 장점 및 단점
✅ 장점
- 바이러스 백신 및 신원 보호 기능이 포함되어 있습니다.
- 보안되지 않은 Wi-Fi 네트워크에 자동으로 연결됩니다.
- Simple interface for VPN beginners
- 30일 환불 보장
❌ 단점
- 미국에 본사를 두고 있으며 (파이브 아이즈 동맹 회원국)
- Logs personally identifiable information including IP addresses
- No macOS or Linux app support
- Not suitable for streaming or torrenting
기능 비교
Let’s compare ProtonVPN and McAfee VPN across 10 key areas.
This breakdown covers everything from privacy to pricing.
| 특징 | 프로톤VPN | McAfee VPN |
|---|---|---|
| 시작 가격 | 월 0달러 (무료) | 연간 39.99달러 |
| 무료 플랜 | ✅ | ❌ |
| 서버 수 | 112개국 8,600명 이상 | 47개국 2,000명 이상 |
| 로그 미보관 정책 | ✅ (감사 완료) | ❌ (logs IP addresses) |
| 킬 스위치 | ✅ (all platforms) | ⚠️ (Windows only) |
| 분할 터널링 | ✅ | ⚠️ (기계적 인조 인간 오직) |
| 스트리밍 지원 | ✅ | ❌ |
| Torrenting/P2P | ✅ (dedicated servers) | ❌ |
| 기기 제한 | 10 connections | 5 connections |
| 가장 적합한 대상 | 개인 정보 보호 및 스트리밍 | 올인원 보안 패키지 |
1. 개인정보 보호 및 로그 미보관 정책
프로톤VPN: ProtonVPN has a strict no-logs policy verified by independent audits. The company is based in Switzerland, which is not part of any surveillance alliance. ProtonVPN’s transparency report shows it has complied with very few legal requests because it stores no IP logs.
McAfee VPN: McAfee Safe Connect VPN logs personally identifiable information, including your IP address and browsing history. McAfee is based in the US, a Five Eyes alliance member. The privacy policy is vague about what data is collected and how it is used.
⚠️ 경고: McAfee retains logged data indefinitely. Even after account deletion, data is kept for 30 days. If privacy is your top concern, this is a major difference between these two VPN services.
2. 서버 네트워크
프로톤VPN: ProtonVPN offers over 8,600 VPN servers in 112 countries. This server network is larger than most other VPN providers. You also get dedicated servers for P2P file sharing and Tor over VPN connections.
McAfee VPN: McAfee VPN has around 2,000 servers in 47 countries. The server list is smaller, and there are no specialty servers for torrenting or streaming. For basic browsing, the coverage is adequate.
3. 보안 기능
프로톤VPN: ProtonVPN includes a kill switch on all platforms, DNS leak protection, NetShield ad-blocking, and Secure Core servers. It supports VPN protocols like OpenVPN, IKEv2, and WireGuard. The Stealth protocol helps bypass internet censorship.
McAfee VPN: McAfee VPN uses AES-256 encryption and the Catapult Hydra protocol. The kill switch is only available on the Windows app. DNS leak protection is included, but advanced security features like multi-hop and Secure Core are missing.
4. 분할 터널링
프로톤VPN: Split tunneling is available on Windows, Android, and Linux. You can choose which apps use the VPN tunnel and which connect directly. This helps keep internet speeds fast for apps that don’t need VPN protection.
McAfee VPN: Split tunneling is only available on the Android app. Windows and iOS users cannot choose which apps go through the encrypted tunnel. This is a significant gap for Android users who need fine-grained control.
5. 스트리밍 및 콘텐츠 접근
프로톤VPN: ProtonVPN can unblock Netflix, BBC iPlayer, and Amazon Prime Video. The Proton VPN app works well for accessing streaming services from different countries. Dedicated streaming servers make this reliable.
McAfee VPN: McAfee Safe Connect VPN is not effective for streaming. It fails to unblock popular services like Netflix and Hulu. If you need a VPN for streaming, McAfee is not the right choice.
6. 기기 지원
프로톤VPN: The Proton VPN app is available on Windows, macOS, iOS, Android, Linux, Android TV, and Apple TV. The Linux app has a full GUI. You can connect up to 10 devices at once on a single account.
McAfee VPN: McAfee Safe Connect is available on Windows, iOS, and Android. There is no macOS app or Linux app. You can connect up to 5 simultaneous connections. Apple TV and Android TV are also not supported.
7. 속도 및 성능
프로톤VPN: ProtonVPN uses its VPN Accelerator feature to boost internet speeds. It supports WireGuard, which is faster than older VPN protocols. According to ProtonVPN’s documentation, the Accelerator makes the biggest difference on long-distance connections.
McAfee VPN: McAfee VPN uses the Catapult Hydra protocol for fast connections. Nearby server speeds can reach 97Mbps. However, latency increases of up to 600% have been reported on Windows, making it a poor choice for gaming.
8. 토렌트 및 P2P
프로톤VPN: ProtonVPN has dedicated servers for P2P file sharing. Torrenting is supported on all paid plans. Port forwarding is also available for improved download speeds.
McAfee VPN: McAfee Safe Connect does not support P2P traffic at all. The logging policy and lack of a kill switch on most platforms make it unsuitable for torrenting. If you need a VPN for P2P, McAfee is not an option.
9. 고객 지원
프로톤VPN: ProtonVPN support staff are available through email tickets. There is no live chat support. The help center on Proton VPN’s website has detailed guides. Response times vary but are typically within 24 hours.
McAfee VPN: You can contact McAfee through live chat support and phone. Customer support is available 24/7. For a VPN bundled with a larger product, the support experience is more accessible than most standalone VPN companies.
10. 가격 및 비용
| 계획 | 프로톤VPN | McAfee VPN |
|---|---|---|
| 무료 | 월 0달러 | ❌ |
| 입장료 지불됨 | 월 2.99달러(플러스) | $39.99/year (Essential) |
| 중위권 | 월 7.99달러 (무제한) | 연간 89.99달러 (고급 개인 플랜) |
| 최상위 | — | 연간 119.99달러 (고급 가족 플랜) |
프로톤VPN: The free plan is the standout here. No other VPN provider matches it for a no-cost option. The Plus plan at $2.99/month (billed annually) is cheaper than most premium VPN services. You pay only for the VPN — no antivirus bundling.
McAfee VPN: At $39.99/year for the Essential plan, the per-month cost works out to about $3.33. That’s cheap for a VPN + antivirus bundle. However, you cannot buy the VPN alone. The annual plan renewal price jumps after the first year.
다양한 시나리오
| 필요하시면 | 선택하다 | 왜 |
|---|---|---|
| 무료 VPN | 프로톤VPN | Only real free plan with no ads |
| 스트리밍 액세스 | 프로톤VPN | 넷플릭스, BBC iPlayer 차단 해제 |
| 올인원 보안 | McAfee VPN | Bundled antivirus + identity protection |
| 최대한의 개인 정보 보호 | 프로톤VPN | Swiss no-logs, open-source |
| 초보자에게 친숙한 설정 | McAfee VPN | One-click connect, auto Wi-Fi protection |
| 토렌트 | 프로톤VPN | 전용 P2P 서버 |
💰 예산
ProtonVPN has a free tier that works for basic browsing. McAfee VPN starts at $39.99/year but includes antivirus and identity protection in the bundle.
🔌 사용 중인 기술 스택
ProtonVPN supports Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, Android, Apple TV, and Android TV. McAfee VPN only works on Windows, iOS, and Android — no macOS app or Linux app support.
📝 사용 사례
If you need a secure VPN for streaming or torrenting, ProtonVPN is the clear pick. If you want basic Wi-Fi protection bundled with antivirus, McAfee VPN covers the basics.
🎓 귀하의 경험 수준
McAfee VPN is simpler for complete beginners who want plug-and-play security. ProtonVPN is easy to use but offers more advanced features like split tunneling and Secure Core for power users.
🆓 무료 체험 및 데모
ProtonVPN’s free plan is permanent — no trial period. McAfee offers a 30-day free trial but requires a credit card. Both have a 30-day money-back guarantee on paid plans.
🛟 지원 옵션
McAfee wins on customer support with 24/7 live chat and phone options. ProtonVPN relies on email tickets, which is slower but still helpful for most issues.
전환 가이드
이미 이러한 도구 중 하나를 사용하고 계신가요? 전환 시 예상되는 사항은 다음과 같습니다.
🔄 ProtonVPN에서 McAfee VPN으로 바꾸시나요?
✅ 얻게 될 이점:
- 바이러스 백신 및 개인정보 도용 방지 기능이 함께 제공됩니다.
- 24/7 live chat support and phone support
- Auto-connect on unsecured Wi-Fi networks
❌ 잃게 될 것:
- 스위스 개인정보 보호 관할권 및 감사 완료된 로그 미보존 정책
- 8,600+ servers, streaming access, and P2P support
- macOS, Linux, and Apple TV app support
📋 전환 방법:
- Cancel your ProtonVPN subscription (keep your Proton account for email)
- Sign up for a McAfee protection plan at mcafee.com
- Download the McAfee app and enable VPN from the dashboard
🔄 McAfee VPN에서 ProtonVPN으로 바꾸시나요?
✅ 얻게 될 이점:
- Strict no-logs policy with Swiss privacy protection
- Access to 8,600+ servers with streaming and P2P support
- Support for macOS, Linux, Apple TV, and Android TV
❌ 잃게 될 것:
- Built-in antivirus and identity theft coverage
- 연중무휴 24시간 실시간 채팅 및 전화 고객 지원
- Automatic Wi-Fi protection triggers
📋 전환 방법:
- Cancel auto-renewal on your McAfee subscription
- protonvpn.com에서 무료 ProtonVPN 계정을 만드세요.
- Download the Proton VPN app on your devices and connect
저희 리뷰에서 다루지 않은 내용
This comparison focused on individual users and small households. We didn’t test enterprise VPN deployments or evaluate McAfee’s corporate licensing options. Our observations are based on the May 2026 versions of both products — features and pricing may have changed since then. Proton VPN passed every privacy check we reviewed. Proton VPN support staff respond via email within 24 hours. McAfee’s interface is user friendly but limited in features. If you manage a large network or need site-to-site VPN, your requirements will differ from what we’ve covered.
최종 판결
| 범주 | 우승자 |
|---|---|
| 💰 가격 | 프로톤VPN |
| 🔒 개인정보 보호 | 프로톤VPN |
| 🌐 서버 네트워크 | 프로톤VPN |
| 🔐 보안 기능 | 프로톤VPN |
| 📺 스트리밍 | 프로톤VPN |
| 👶 사용 편의성 | McAfee VPN |
| 📞 고객 지원 | McAfee VPN |
| 🏆 종합 우승 | 프로톤VPN |
🏆 우승: ProtonVPN
ProtonVPN이 7개 부문 중 5개 부문에서 수상했습니다.
다음과 같은 경우에 가장 적합합니다: Privacy-conscious users, streaming fans, free VPN seekers, and Linux users
ProtonVPN and McAfee VPN target very different audiences. ProtonVPN is a dedicated VPN service built for privacy and performance. McAfee VPN is a VPN feature inside a larger online security package.
McAfee VPN makes sense if you already want antivirus and identity protection in one bundle. The VPN is a bonus, not the main product.
However, if you need a real VPN provider with strong privacy, global server coverage, and streaming access, ProtonVPN is the better choice by a wide margin.
ProtonVPN 비교 시 더 많은 정보 제공
Here’s how ProtonVPN stacks up against other VPN providers:
ProtonVPN vs NordVPN
ProtonVPN이 다음 항목에서 우위를 차지했습니다: 무료 플랜 이용 가능 여부, 스위스 관할권, 오픈 소스 앱
NordVPN이 다음 항목에서 우위를 차지했습니다: Faster overall speeds, larger server count, more polished apps
ProtonVPN vs ExpressVPN
ProtonVPN이 다음 항목에서 우위를 차지했습니다: Free VPN tier, lower paid pricing, transparent audits
ExpressVPN이 다음 항목에서 우위를 점합니다: Faster connection speeds, broader streaming support, simpler interface
ProtonVPN vs 서프샤크 VPN
ProtonVPN이 다음 항목에서 우위를 차지했습니다: Privacy credentials, Secure Core architecture, free tier
Surfshark VPN이 다음 항목에서 우위를 차지했습니다: Unlimited simultaneous connections, cheaper annual plans, CleanWeb ad-blocker
ProtonVPN vs CyberGhost
ProtonVPN이 다음 항목에서 우위를 차지했습니다: Free plan, Swiss privacy, open-source transparency
CyberGhost가 다음 항목에서 승리했습니다: Dedicated streaming servers with labels, 45-day money-back guarantee, lower long-term pricing
McAfee VPN 비교에서 더 많은 정보 확인
Here’s how McAfee VPN stacks up against other VPN companies:
McAfee VPN vs NordVPN
McAfee VPN이 다음 항목에서 우위를 차지했습니다: Bundled antivirus and identity protection, simpler setup for non-tech users
NordVPN이 다음 항목에서 우위를 차지했습니다: Audited no-logs policy, 6,000+ servers, streaming and torrenting support
McAfee VPN vs 핫스팟 쉴드
McAfee VPN이 다음 항목에서 우위를 차지했습니다: Identity theft coverage, antivirus bundling, multi-device security
Hotspot Shield는 다음에서 승리합니다: Faster VPN speeds, standalone VPN pricing, better streaming access
McAfee VPN vs 개인 인터넷 접속
McAfee VPN이 다음 항목에서 우위를 차지했습니다: All-in-one security bundle, identity monitoring, easier for beginners
개인 인터넷 접속이 우위를 점하는 이유는 다음과 같습니다. True no-logs policy, 35,000+ servers, full P2P support, Linux app
자주 묻는 질문
Proton VPN은 안전한가요?
Yes, ProtonVPN is safe. It uses AES-256 encryption and has a strict no-logs policy verified by independent audits. The company is based in Switzerland, which has strong data protection laws.
McAfee VPN은 좋은 선택일까요?
McAfee VPN is fine for basic Wi-Fi protection. However, it logs personally identifiable information and lacks support for streaming or torrenting. For dedicated VPN use, a standalone VPN service is a better choice.
Proton VPN은 정말 무료인가요?
Yes, ProtonVPN offers a permanent free plan with no ads and unlimited bandwidth. The free version limits you to servers in 3 countries and 1 device. No credit card is required to sign up.
McAfee VPN은 데이터를 수집합니까?
According to McAfee’s privacy policy, the VPN logs personally identifiable information including IP addresses. McAfee retains this data indefinitely and will share it with authorities if requested. This is a major privacy concern compared to no-logs VPN providers.
Which is better, ProtonVPN or McAfee VPN for privacy?
ProtonVPN is far better for privacy. It has an audited no-logs policy, open-source apps, and Swiss legal protection. McAfee VPN is based in the US and logs user data, making it a weaker choice for anyone who values online privacy.
Does Proton VPN work with streaming services?
Yes, Proton VPN work with Netflix, BBC iPlayer, and Amazon Prime Video. The Proton VPN app connects to Proton VPN servers in over 112 countries. This makes it easy to access geo-restricted streaming services from your mobile device or browser.
Is ProtonVPN good for everyday use?
Proton VPN good for daily browsing, streaming, and even occasional use on public Wi-Fi. Proton VPN easy to set up — download the app and connect in seconds. Proton VPN offers a free tier and a premium VPN option. VPN users who need a virtual private network for basic protection will find it more than enough. The Proton VPN review scores reflect strong performance across speed tests.
Can you trust McAfee Safe Connect for privacy?
It depends on your needs. McAfee claims to protect your browsing history and online activities, but the privacy policy allows sharing data with third party advertisers. If you trust McAfee Safe Connect for bare minimum Wi-Fi protection, it works. But for serious online privacy, a dedicated VPN provider is a better pick. The McAfee VPN review highlights that the VPN fails to match what other VPN services deliver on privacy.
Does Proton VPN support the Tor network?
Yes, ProtonVPN includes Tor over VPN through dedicated Tor servers. This sends your internet traffic through an encrypted VPN tunnel and then into the Tor network. ProtonVPN passed independent audits confirming its strict no logs policy and no IP logs. The ProtonVPN support staff can help you configure Tor access. ProtonVPN also supports a double VPN-like feature called Secure Core, which routes your connection through multiple core servers before reaching the endpoint server.
How does McAfee VPN compare for speed?
McAfee VPN speed test results show decent nearby server performance but poor long-distance speeds. Speed tests reveal high latency on Windows. McAfee VPN lacks smart DNS for faster streaming. For Android users and iOS users, speeds are acceptable for light browsing. The internet service provider throttling protection works at the bare minimum level. For a VPN company focused on antivirus first, the annual plan does include money back guarantee coverage. McAfee does not offer multi hop routing, which limits options for users blocking access to geo-restricted content. ProtonVPN is not an expensive VPN, and the dns leak test results confirm dns leaks are not a concern. It operates under the world’s strongest privacy laws in Switzerland. The Proton apps like the Windows app, Linux app, and Android app all connect reliably. The server list is smaller with McAfee. On a mobile carrier connection, McAfee’s geo location information routing can cause slowdowns. Whether you download files or just browse, the McAfee Safe Connect VPN is a big deal only if you already pay for the antivirus.
English 
Spanish 
Chinese 
German 
French 
Arabic 
Russian 
Portuguese 
Japanese 
Korean 
Italian 
Turkish 
Dutch 
Polish 
Indonesian 
Thai 
Vietnamese 