⚡ Quick Verdict:
- 価格: Proton VPN starts at $0/month (free plan) vs TorGuard at $10.99/month
- 最適な用途: Proton VPN for privacy-first browsing and streaming, TorGuard for torrenting with port forwarding
- 主な違い： Proton VPN has a free tier and open-source apps; TorGuard has dedicated IP addresses and deeper P2P features
- Our pick: Proton VPN for most users — stronger privacy, lower cost, and a verified no-logs policy
Not every VPN user needs the same thing.
Some people want airtight privacy from a trusted company.
Others need fast torrenting with dedicated IP addresses.
ProtonVPN and TorGuard take very different approaches to both.
This comparison breaks down pricing, features, and real differences.
概要
This ProtonVPN vs TorGuard comparison covers pricing, privacy, speed, and ease of use.
We also break down who each VPN service works best for.
Our sources include published specs, official documentation, and user reviews.
By the end, you’ll know which VPN provider fits your needs.
ProtonVPNとは何ですか？
Proton VPN is a VPN service built by the same team behind Proton Mail.
同社は、世界で最も厳格なプライバシー法が施行されているスイスに拠点を置いている。
The Proton VPN app runs on Windows, マックiOS、Android、Linux、およびAndroid TVに対応しています。
Proton VPN offers a free VPN with unlimited bandwidth and no ads.
The paid plans unlock secure core servers, NetShield ad-blocking, and 8,600+ VPN servers.
プロトンVPN
Swiss-based VPN with open-source apps and a verified no-logs policy. Free plan available with no data caps or ads.
ProtonVPNの料金
2026年のProton VPNの料金は以下の通りです。
| プラン | 価格 | 最適な用途 |
|---|---|---|
| 無料 | 月額0.00ドル | Basic browsing and testing the VPN |
| プラス | 月額2.99ドル | すべての機能を備えた完全なVPNアクセス |
| 無制限 | 月額7.99ドル | VPN + Proton Mail, Drive, and Pass |
Pricing verified May 2026.
無料トライアル: Yes — the free plan has no time limit and no credit card needed.
返金保証: 有料プランはすべて30日間の返金保証付きです。
📌 注記： The Plus plan at $2.99/month is only available on the 2-year billing cycle. Monthly billing costs $9.99/month. The Unlimited plan bundles Proton Mail, Proton Drive, Proton Calendar, and Proton Pass.
⚠️ 警告： After the initial discount period, Proton VPN renews at the standard price of $9.99/month. Turn off auto-renewal in your account settings before the term ends to avoid higher charges.
ProtonVPNの主な利点
Here’s what makes Proton VPN worth considering:
- スイスのプライバシー保護： Based in Switzerland, which is not part of the Five Eyes, Nine Eyes, or Fourteen Eyes surveillance alliances. Your data stays protected by Swiss law.
- 監査済みノーログポリシー: Proton VPN passed a third-party audit verifying its strict no-logs policy. The company publishes a transparency report showing how few legal requests it has received.
- オープンソースアプリ： Every Proton VPN app is open-source. Anyone can inspect the code for security flaws.
- 制限なしの無料プラン： The free version has unlimited bandwidth, no ads, and no data caps. It covers servers in multiple countries.
- セキュアコアサーバー: Routes your internet traffic through privacy-friendly countries before reaching the endpoint server. This adds a second layer of protection to your encrypted VPN tunnel.
- NetShield広告ブロッカー： Blocks ads, trackers, and malware at the DNS level. This speeds up browsing and reduces data usage on your mobile device.
- VPNアクセラレーター： Proton’s proprietary technology that boosts internet speeds by up to 400% on long-distance connections.
What Our Team Noticed
私たちの 作家 signed up for ProtonVPN and spent several days exploring the platform. Here’s what stood out:
ProtonVPNのメリットとデメリット
✅ メリット
- 帯域幅無制限で広告なしの無料プラン
- 監査済みのログなしポリシーを持つスイスの管轄区域
- すべてのプラットフォームで利用できるオープンソースアプリ
- 112か国に8,600台以上のサーバーを設置
- セキュアコアのマルチホップルーティングによるさらなるプライバシー保護
❌ デメリット
- 無料プランはデバイス1台とサーバー設置場所が限られています
- Secure Core servers can reduce connection speeds
- No dedicated IP address option available
- Customer support is slower than some competitors
TorGuardとは何ですか?
TorGuard is a virtual private network and anonymous VPN built around torrenting and P2P file sharing.
The “Tor” in TorGuard stands for “torrent,” not the Tor network.
It is owned by Data Protection Services LLC and based in the United States.
TorGuard offers proxy services, 仕事 VPN plans, and private VPN cloud servers.
The TorGuard app runs on Windows, Mac, Linux, アンドロイド、そしてiOS。
トルガード
Torrent-focused VPN with dedicated IP addresses, Stealth Mode, and port forwarding. Supports up to 12 simultaneous device connections.
TorGuardの価格設定
2026年のTorGuardの価格はこうなります。
| プラン | 価格 | 最適な用途 |
|---|---|---|
| 標準 | 月額10.99ドル | Basic VPN with 8 device connections |
| プロ | 月額14.29ドル | Streaming, dedicated IP, 12 connections |
| ビジネスVPN | 月額32.99ドル | Teams needing shared VPN access |
| 匿名メール | 月額3.58ドル | Encrypted email service only |
Pricing verified May 2026.
無料トライアル: No free plan. TorGuard offers a 7-day money-back guarantee instead.
返金保証: 7 days only. Refunds are not available for cryptocurrency or gift card payments.
📌 注記： TorGuard’s pricing drops on longer billing cycles. The Standard plan on a 3-year term costs roughly $4.28/month. A dedicated streaming IP address costs an extra $7.99/month.
⚠️ 警告： TorGuard’s pricing structure is complex. Many add-ons and billing cycles can make it confusing to find the right plan. Also, the basic Standard plan does not include streaming support — you need the Pro plan or a dedicated streaming IP add-on for that.
TorGuardの主な利点
Here’s what makes TorGuard worth considering:
- トレント特集： TorGuard was built for P2P file sharing. It supports port forwarding and works with BitTorrent and uTorrent on non-US servers.
- 専用IPアドレス: The Pro and Premium plans include a dedicated IP address. This helps with IP-restricted services and stable リモートアクセス.
- デバイスの上限が高い: The Pro plan allows up to 12 simultaneous connections. That covers most households easily.
- ステルスモード: Hides VPN traffic to look like regular internet traffic. Useful on restrictive networks and in censored regions.
- 匿名決済： Accepts Bitcoin and gift cards for extra privacy during signup.
- カスタマイズ可能なアプリ： The TorGuard app lets you set startup preferences, custom scripts, and connection rules.
What Our Team Noticed
Note: We haven’t had extensive hands-on time with TorGuard yet. The information above is based on published documentation and user reviews.
TorGuardの長所と短所
✅ メリット
- トレントのダウンロード速度を向上させるためのポートフォワーディング
- Dedicated IP addresses included in Pro plan
- 最大12台のデバイスを同時に接続可能
- ビットコインなどの匿名決済に対応しています。
❌ デメリット
- 無料プランはありません
- 米国に拠点を置く（ファイブ・アイズ同盟加盟国）
- 独立したセキュリティ監査は実施されていません
- App has been reported as buggy with long connection times
- Torrenting blocked on US servers due to legal settlement
機能比較
Let’s compare ProtonVPN vs TorGuard across 9 key features. Each section highlights how both VPN providers handle a specific area.
| 特徴 | プロトンVPN | トルガード |
|---|---|---|
| 開始価格 | 月額0ドル（無料） | 月額10.99ドル |
| 無料プラン | ✅ | ❌ |
| サーバーネットワーク | 112か国で8,600人以上 | 50カ国以上で3,000人以上 |
| 同時デバイス | 10 (paid) | 最大12台（Pro版） |
| キルスイッチ | ✅ | ✅ |
| スプリットトンネリング | ✅ (all platforms) | ❌ (Android only) |
| ポート転送 | ✅ | ✅ |
| 専用IP | ❌ | ✅（プロプラン） |
| 独立監査 | ✅ | ❌ |
| 最適な用途 | プライバシー重視のユーザー | Torrent-heavy users |
1. プライバシーと管轄
プロトンVPN: Based in Switzerland, which has some of the world’s strongest privacy laws. Switzerland is not part of any intelligence-sharing alliance. Proton VPN passed a third-party audit confirming its strict no-logs policy. All Proton apps are open-source, so anyone can verify the code.
トルガード: Based in the United States, which is part of the Five Eyes surveillance alliance. TorGuard claims a strict no-logging policy. However, TorGuard has not completed any independent security audits to verify these claims. The apps are not open-source.
2. サーバーネットワーク
プロトンVPN: Over 8,600 VPN servers spread across 112 countries. All servers are physical and operated by Proton directly. The server network covers most regions including Africa, Asia, and South America.
トルガード: Over 3,000 servers in more than 50 countries. The network is smaller but still covers major server locations. TorGuard also offers virtual servers in some regions, and stealth servers for bypassing censorship.
3. セキュリティ機能
プロトンVPN: Uses AES-256 encryption with Perfect Forward Secrecy. Supports VPN protocols including OpenVPN, IKEv2, and WireGuard. Also includes the proprietary Stealth protocol for bypassing censorship. DNS leak protection and a kill switch are built into every app.
トルガード: Also uses AES-256 encryption. Supports OpenVPN, WireGuard, and IKEv2/IPSec VPN protocols. Includes a kill switch and DNS leak protection. TorGuard also has built-in protections against IPv6 and WebRTC leaks to keep your real IP address hidden.
4. トレントとP2P
プロトンVPN: Allows torrenting on dedicated servers. Port forwarding is available for faster downloads. The free plan does not support P2P file sharing — only paid plans do.
トルガード: Built specifically for torrenting. Supports BitTorrent and uTorrent on non-US servers. Port forwarding is included on all plans. However, torrenting is blocked on all US servers due to a 2022 legal settlement. That means you must connect to international TorGuard servers for P2P.
⚠️ 警告： TorGuard blocks BitTorrent traffic on US-based servers. If you’re in the US, you’ll need to connect to a server in another country to torrent safely.
5. ストリーミングとコンテンツへのアクセス
プロトンVPN: Can unblock Netflix, BBC iPlayer, and Amazon Prime Video. Streaming services work on all paid plans without extra add-ons. According to Proton VPN’s documentation, the Plus plan gives full access to streaming platforms. Is Proton VPN good for streaming? Yes — it handles most popular services reliably.
トルガード: The basic Standard plan struggles to unblock major streaming platforms. You need the Pro plan or a dedicated streaming IP address (extra $7.99/month) to access Netflix and similar services. Streaming performance is inconsistent without this add-on.
6. 使いやすさ
プロトンVPN: The Proton VPN app has a clean, simple design. Connecting to a VPN server takes two clicks. The app works on Windows, Mac, iOS, Android, Linux, and Android TV. It’s easy for beginners to start using right away.
トルガード: The TorGuard app has been updated but is still less intuitive. Settings are disorganized. The app forces you to disconnect before switching servers. Browser extensions are available for Chrome and Firefox, but the overall experience requires more technical knowledge.
7. 分割トンネル工法
プロトンVPN: Full split tunneling on Windows, Android, and other platforms. You can choose which apps use the VPN tunnel and which connect directly to your internet service provider.
トルガード: The split tunneling feature is only available on the Android app. Windows, Mac, iOS, and Linux users do not get this option. This is a notable gap for a premium VPN provider.
8. カスタマーサポート
プロトンVPN: Proton VPN support staff are available via email and a help center. There is no live chat support currently. Response times can vary. The website has detailed setup guides for all platforms.
トルガード: TorGuard customer support is available through live chat and email. However, you must log in before accessing these services. This can delay response times if you’re having account issues.
9. 価格設定とコスト
料金プランを並べて比較してみましょう。
| プラン | プロトンVPN | トルガード |
|---|---|---|
| 無料 | $0/month (yes) | ❌ 無料プランはありません |
| 入場料支払い済み | 月額2.99ドル（プラス） | 月額10.99ドル（スタンダードプラン） |
| 中級 | 月額7.99ドル（無制限） | 月額14.29ドル（プロプラン） |
| 仕事 | 該当なし | 月額32.99ドル |
プロトンVPN: The free plan makes Proton VPN easy to try with zero risk. The Plus plan at $2.99/month (2-year billing) is less than a third of TorGuard’s starting price. Even the Unlimited plan at $7.99/month is cheaper than TorGuard’s Standard plan.
トルガード: TorGuard’s pricing starts higher at $10.99/month. Long-term plans reduce costs — the 3-year Standard plan drops to around $4.28/month. But the Pro plan with a dedicated IP is $14.29/month, and streaming add-ons cost extra. The 7-day refund window is also shorter than Proton VPN’s 30 days.
さまざまなシナリオ
| 必要な場合は | 選ぶ | なぜ |
|---|---|---|
| 予算が限られている | プロトンVPN | Free plan available, Plus at $2.99/mo |
| ポートフォワーディングを使用したトレント | トルガード | Built for P2P with dedicated servers |
| 全プラットフォームで配信中 | プロトンVPN | Works without extra add-ons |
| 専用IPアドレス | トルガード | プロプランに含まれる |
| プライバシーを最優先する法域 | プロトンVPN | Swiss-based with audited no-logs |
| 初心者向けのアプリ | プロトンVPN | よりクリーンでシンプルなインターフェース |
💰 あなたの予算
Proton VPN has a free tier with no data caps. If you need a premium VPN, the Plus plan starts at $2.99/month — less than a third of TorGuard’s entry price.
🔌 あなたの技術スタック
Proton VPN works with Proton Mail, Proton Drive, and Proton Calendar on the Unlimited plan. TorGuard offers separate proxy services and anonymous email for users who want VPN connections plus email encryption.
📝 あなたの主な使用例
If you mainly browse and stream, Proton VPN is the better fit. If you download torrents daily and need port forwarding, TorGuard is purpose-built for that workflow.
🎓 あなたの経験レベル
Proton VPN is easier for beginners. TorGuard’s advanced features like custom scripts and VPN routers appeal more to experienced Linux users and power users.
🆓 無料トライアルとデモ
Proton VPN’s free version lets you test the service forever with no credit card. TorGuard only offers a 7-day money-back guarantee — and refunds have many exceptions.
🛟 サポートオプション
TorGuard has live chat support, which Proton VPN lacks. But TorGuard requires you to log in first, which can slow things down if you’re locked out of your account.
切り替えガイド
既にこれらのVPNサービスのいずれかをご利用ですか？切り替える場合に何が起こるか、以下にご説明します。
🔄 ProtonVPNからTorGuardに切り替えますか？
✅ 得られるもの：
- Dedicated IP address for stable remote access
- Up to 12 simultaneous connections on the Pro plan
- ライブチャットによるカスタマーサポート
❌ 失うもの：
- 帯域幅無制限の無料プラン
- スイスのプライバシー管轄権と監査済みのログなしポリシー
- Secure Core multi-hop routing and NetShield ad-blocker
📋切り替え方法：
- Cancel your Proton VPN subscription and request a refund within 30 days if eligible
- Sign up at TorGuard and choose your plan and billing cycle
- Download the TorGuard app on your devices and connect to a server
🔄 TorGuardからProtonVPNに切り替えますか？
✅ 得られるもの：
- Free plan to test before committing any money
- スイスを拠点とする、監査済みのログなしポリシーに基づくプライバシー保護企業
- Open-source apps and Secure Core multi-hop VPN tunnel
❌ 失うもの：
- Dedicated IP addresses for streaming or remote work
- TorGuard’s advanced app customization and scripting
- Live chat support access
📋切り替え方法：
- Request a refund from TorGuard within 7 days of your last payment
- Create a free Proton VPN account — no credit card needed
- Download the Proton VPN app and upgrade to Plus when ready
What Our Review Didn’t Cover
This comparison focused on individual users and small teams. We didn’t test enterprise features, business VPN plans, or VPN router configurations. Speed benchmarks across dozens of server locations weren’t part of this review. If you’re managing a large team or need private VPN cloud setups, your priorities may differ from what we’ve covered here.
最終評決
| カテゴリ | 勝者 |
|---|---|
| 💰価格 | プロトンVPN |
| 🔒 プライバシーと管轄権 | プロトンVPN |
| 🌐 サーバーネットワーク | プロトンVPN |
| 📥 トレントとP2P | トルガード |
| 📺 ストリーミング配信 | プロトンVPN |
| 👶 使いやすさ | プロトンVPN |
| 🔌 高度な機能 | トルガード |
| 🏆総合優勝 | プロトンVPN |
🏆 優勝：ProtonVPN
ProtonVPNは7つのカテゴリーのうち5つで優勝しました。
最適な用途: Privacy-focused browsing, streaming, budget-friendly VPN access, and users who want a free VPN option
ProtonVPN and TorGuard serve very different audiences.
Proton VPN is a privacy-first VPN service with Swiss legal protection and open-source code.
TorGuard is a torrent-focused VPN provider with dedicated IP addresses and port forwarding.
TorGuard is a solid choice if you download torrents daily and need a dedicated streaming IP address.
However, for most users who want a secure VPN with better pricing and stronger privacy, ProtonVPN is the better pick.
ProtonVPNの比較をもっと見る
Here’s how ProtonVPN stacks up against other VPN providers:
ProtonVPN vs NordVPN
ProtonVPNが優れている点： Free plan with no data caps, Swiss jurisdiction outside surveillance alliances, fully open-source apps
NordVPNが優れている点： Faster download speeds on most servers, larger server network with 6,800+ servers, more polished mobile apps
ProtonVPN vs エクスプレスVPN
ProtonVPNが優れている点： Lower starting price at $2.99/month vs ExpressVPN’s $3.59/month, free tier available, audited open-source code
ExpressVPNが優れている点： Simpler app experience for beginners, wider router compatibility, stronger streaming unblocking track record
ProtonVPN vs Surfshark
ProtonVPNが優れている点： Swiss privacy protections and third-party audited no-logs policy, Secure Core double-hop servers, free version available
Surfsharkが勝利した点： Lower long-term pricing starting at $1.99/month, unlimited simultaneous device connections, CleanWeb ad-blocker
ProtonVPN vs サイバーゴースト
ProtonVPNが優れている点： Better privacy jurisdiction (Switzerland vs Romania), open-source code, free plan with unlimited bandwidth
CyberGhostが勝利した点： Larger server count with 9,000+ servers, longer 45-day money-back guarantee, dedicated streaming servers by platform
TorGuardの比較をもっと詳しく
Here’s how TorGuard stacks up against other VPN services:
TorGuard vs NordVPN
TorGuardが優れている点： Port forwarding for torrent optimization, dedicated IP included in Pro plan, higher device limit (12 vs 10)
NordVPNが優れている点： Independent security audits verified, much simpler pricing structure, faster and more reliable apps
TorGuard vs ExpressVPN
TorGuardが優れている点： Lower long-term pricing on 3-year plan, built-in port forwarding, dedicated IP option without extra cost on Pro
ExpressVPNが優れている点： Faster connection speeds across all servers, better streaming access without add-ons, cleaner app design
TorGuardとPrivate Internet Accessの比較
TorGuardが優れている点： More server locations outside the US, Stealth Mode for censorship bypassing, dedicated streaming IP option
ぴあ 勝利したタイトル： Lower monthly pricing, open-source apps with verified code, unlimited simultaneous connections
よくある質問
Proton VPNは安全に使用できますか？
Yes. The Proton VPN review from our team confirms it is a secure VPN built on solid security principles. It has a verified no-logs policy confirmed by an independent audit. All apps — including the Windows app, Linux app, iOS app, and Android app — are open-source. You can visit Proton VPN’s website for full details on their dns leak test results and encrypted tunnel technology.
Proton VPNは本当に無料ですか？
Yes. The free version has no data caps, no ads, and no time limits. It is a good option compared to other free VPNs. Some users find it an expensive VPN when upgrading to Plus, but the free tier does work well. Does Proton VPN work for everyday browsing? Absolutely — Proton VPN is good for basic privacy needs on any mobile device.
TorGuardは信頼できるのか？
TorGuard claims a no-logging policy. However, the service is based in the US (a Five Eyes country) and has not completed independent security audits. The TorGuard review community has mixed opinions. A TorGuard subscription gives you access to TorGuard apps on multiple platforms, and you can connect TorGuard on up to eight simultaneous connections with the Anonymous VPN plan. TorGuard’s servers use AES-256 encryption and handle DNS requests securely.
Is TorGuard VPN good for streaming?
The basic VPN plan struggles with major streaming platforms. You need the Pro plan or a streaming bundle with a dedicated streaming IP address to reliably access Netflix. TorGuard speed test results vary by server location. The TorGuard apps include browser extensions for Microsoft Edge, Chrome, and Firefox. Note that TorGuard does not offer a free dedicated IP address — it comes with the Pro plan or as a paid add-on. The private cloud option is available through their private VPN cloud server product for online services that need more control.
Which is better for torrenting — ProtonVPN or TorGuard?
TorGuard was purpose-built for torrenting and includes port forwarding on all plans. Among other VPN services, it stands out for P2P. Proton VPN also supports P2P on paid plans. TorGuard has an edge as it can block BitTorrent traffic only on US servers — blocking access to torrents there due to legal reasons. Proton VPN’s Proton apps cover other VPN providers’ features like tor servers access and double VPN-style routing through Secure Core. Both are viable depending on whether you value Proton VPN’s Swiss-based privacy or TorGuard’s advanced features like VPN routers and a free router option on Premium plans. Proton Technologies AG created Proton services to give users an alternative to other VPN companies.
English 
Spanish 
Chinese 
German 
French 
Arabic 
Russian 
Portuguese 
Japanese 
Korean 
Italian 
Turkish 
Dutch 
Polish 
Indonesian 
Thai 
Vietnamese 