⚡ حكم سريع:
- الأسعار: Proton VPN starts at $0.00/month (free plan) vs Mullvad at €5/month flat rate
- الأفضل لـ: Proton VPN for streaming and everyday use, Mullvad for maximum anonymity
- الفرق الرئيسي: Proton VPN offers a free tier and 8,600+ servers; Mullvad requires no personal info to sign up
- اختيارنا: Proton VPN for most users — it covers more use cases at a lower entry price
Privacy-focused VPN users face a tough choice right now.
Proton VPN and Mullvad both promise zero-logs protection.
لكنهم يسلكون طرقاً مختلفة تماماً للوصول إلى هناك.
Proton VPN bundles a free plan, streaming support, and a massive server network.
Mullvad strips everything down to pure anonymity.
تُفصّل هذه المقارنة خدمات VPN المختلفة لمساعدتك في اختيار الخدمة المناسبة.
ملخص
This ProtonVPN vs Mullvad comparison covers pricing, privacy features, and server networks.
We also break down streaming, speed, and ease of use.
تشمل مصادرنا المواصفات المنشورة والوثائق الرسمية ومراجعات المستخدمين.
في النهاية، ستعرف أي مزود خدمة VPN يناسب احتياجاتك.
ما هو ProtonVPN؟
Proton VPN is a Swiss-based VPN service built by Proton AG (formerly Proton Technologies AG).
The same company also runs Proton Mail, Proton Drive, and Proton Calendar.
It protects your internet connection with AES-256 encryption and a strict no-logs policy.
يوفر Proton VPN باقة مجانية مع نطاق ترددي غير محدود وبدون إعلانات.
Paid plans unlock over 8,600 VPN servers in 112 countries.
بروتون في بي إن
Swiss privacy meets a huge server network. Free plan included with no data caps. Paid plans start at $2.99/month.
أسعار ProtonVPN
إليكم تكلفة خدمة Proton VPN في عام 2026.
| يخطط | سعر | الأفضل لـ |
|---|---|---|
| حر | 0.00 دولار شهرياً | التصفح والاختبار الأساسيان |
| زائد | 2.99 دولار شهرياً | إمكانية الوصول الكامل إلى شبكة VPN للأفراد |
| غير محدود | 7.99 دولارًا شهريًا | VPN + بروتون ميل، درايف، كلمة المرور |
Pricing verified May 2026.
تجربة مجانية: The free plan acts as a permanent trial with no credit card needed.
ضمان استرداد الأموال: سياسة استرداد الأموال خلال 30 يومًا على جميع الخطط المدفوعة.
📌 ملحوظة: The Plus plan includes all VPN features. The Unlimited plan adds Proton Mail, Proton Drive, Proton Calendar, and ممر البروتون on top of the VPN service.
⚠️ تحذير: Proton VPN subscriptions auto-renew at the standard rate after your initial discounted term ends. Turn off auto-renewal in your account settings before the billing date to avoid the higher price.
المزايا الرئيسية لـ ProtonVPN
إليك ما يجعل Proton VPN جديرًا بالاهتمام:
- الاختصاص القضائي السويسري: Based in Switzerland, which has strong privacy laws. Switzerland sits outside the 5 Eyes, 9 Eyes, and 14 Eyes surveillance alliances.
- الخطة المجانية: No data caps, no ads, and unlimited bandwidth. The free tier covers servers in multiple countries for basic protection.
- خوادم أساسية آمنة: Routes your internet traffic through privacy-friendly countries before reaching the endpoint server. This adds a second layer of encryption to your VPN tunnel.
- مُسرِّع VPN: Proprietary speed technology that improves connection speeds. It works across all VPN protocols supported by the Proton VPN app.
- مانع الإعلانات NetShield: Blocks ads, trackers, and malware at the DNS level. No extra browser extension needed.
- تطبيقات مفتوحة المصدر: All Proton apps are open-source and have passed independent audits. Anyone can inspect the code for حماية عيوب.
- دعم البث المباشر: Unblocks Netflix, BBC iPlayer, Amazon Prime Video, and other major streaming services from your VPN servers.
ما لاحظه فريقنا
ملكنا الكاتب signed up for Proton VPN and spent several days exploring the platform. Here’s what stood out:
مزايا وعيوب ProtonVPN
✅ المزايا
- خطة مجانية مع نطاق ترددي غير محدود وبدون إعلانات
- أكثر من 8600 خادم في 112 دولة
- نظام قضائي سويسري ذو سياسة عدم الاحتفاظ بالسجلات الخاضعة للتدقيق
- Unblocks major streaming services like Netflix and BBC iPlayer
- يتصل بما يصل إلى 10 أجهزة في وقت واحد
❌ سلبيات
- Free plan limits you to a few server locations and one device
- Secure Core servers can slow down your internet speeds
- No live chat support — only email and support tickets via Proton VPN’s website
- Renewal prices increase after the initial discounted term
ما هو مولفاد؟
Mullvad is a Swedish VPN provider built around total anonymity.
لا يتطلب إنشاء حساب عنوان بريد إلكتروني أو أي معلومات شخصية.
Instead, Mullvad generates a random 16-digit account number for each user.
You can even pay with cash mailed in an envelope or with bitcoin cash.
The Mullvad service runs exclusively on the WireGuard protocol as of مبكر 2026. This means Mullvad no longer supports OpenVPN. The vpn kill switch is always enabled to prevent dns leaks of your customer data.
Mullvad VPN
Maximum anonymity with no email signup. Flat €5/month pricing with no long-term commitments. Pay with cash or crypto.
أسعار خدمة Mullvad VPN
Mullvad’s pricing is the simplest in the VPN market.
| يخطط | سعر | الأفضل لـ |
|---|---|---|
| شهر واحد | 5 يورو شهرياً | احتياجات الخصوصية قصيرة الأجل |
| سنة واحدة | 5 يورو شهرياً | Long-term users who want flat pricing |
| عقد واحد | 5 يورو شهرياً | Maximum commitment at the same rate |
Pricing verified May 2026.
تجربة مجانية: لا توجد فترة تجريبية مجانية أو خطة مجانية متاحة.
ضمان استرداد الأموال: Mullvad has a money back guarantee for 30 days on most payment methods. Cash payments are excluded.
📌 ملحوظة: Mullvad has never raised its price since launching in 2009. The flat €5/month rate applies no matter how long you subscribe. No surprise renewal fees.
⚠️ تحذير: Mullvad does not offer long-term subscription discounts. Other VPN providers like Proton VPN and NordVPN charge less per month on annual or multi-year plans.
المزايا الرئيسية لخدمة Mullvad VPN
Here’s what makes Mullvad VPN worth considering:
- التسجيل المجهول: No email, no name, no personal data. Mullvad generates a 16-digit account number that acts as your login.
- المدفوعات المجهولة: Pay with cash, bitcoin cash, or crypto. You can mail physical cash to Mullvad’s address for total anonymity.
- خوادم ذاكرة الوصول العشوائي فقط: All Mullvad’s servers run on RAM. No data is stored on hard disks, and everything is wiped on reboot.
- بروتوكول واير جارد: Mullvad now runs exclusively on WireGuard for fast, secure VPN connections. OpenVPN was retired in January 2026.
- حماية دايتا: تعمل خاصية الحماية من تحليل حركة المرور الموجه بالذكاء الاصطناعي على إخفاء أنماط تصفحك عن المراقبة المتقدمة.
- تطبيقات مفتوحة المصدر: Mullvad’s apps are fully open-source. Independent audits have confirmed the no-logs policy multiple times.
ما لاحظه فريقنا
Our writer signed up for Mullvad VPN and explored the platform for everyday use. Here’s what stood out:
مزايا وعيوب Mullvad VPN
✅ المزايا
- لا يلزم تقديم أي معلومات شخصية للتسجيل
- Flat €5/month pricing with no renewal price increases
- تقوم الخوادم التي تعمل بذاكرة الوصول العشوائي فقط بمسح جميع البيانات عند إعادة التشغيل.
- أكدت عمليات تدقيق مستقلة متعددة سياسة عدم الاحتفاظ بالسجلات
- DAITA and Multi-Hop for advanced privacy
❌ سلبيات
- Smaller server network with around 700 servers in 49 countries
- لا تتوفر خطة مجانية أو فترة تجريبية مجانية
- يواجه صعوبة في فك حظر معظم خدمات البث
- يدعم ما يصل إلى خمسة أجهزة في وقت واحد فقط
مقارنة الميزات
Ready to dive into a detailed comparison of ProtonVPN vs Mullvad?
We’ll explore 9 key features to help you pick the right VPN provider.
| ميزة | بروتون في بي إن | مولفاد |
|---|---|---|
| السعر المبدئي | 0.00 دولار أمريكي شهرياً (مجاناً) | 5 يورو شهرياً |
| خطة مجانية | ✅ | ❌ |
| شبكة الخوادم | أكثر من 8600 في 112 دولة | حوالي 700 في 49 دولة |
| الأجهزة المتزامنة | 10 | 5 |
| دعم البث | ✅ | ❌ (محدود) |
| التسجيل المجهول | ❌ (email required) | ✅ (no email needed) |
| مفتاح الإيقاف | ✅ | ✅ (متصل دائمًا) |
| النفق المنفصل | ✅ | ✅ |
| تطبيقات مفتوحة المصدر | ✅ | ✅ |
| الأفضل لـ | مستخدمو VPN العاديون | مستخدمون يضعون الخصوصية في المقام الأول |
1. سياسة الخصوصية وعدم الاحتفاظ بالسجلات
بروتون في بي إن: Based in Switzerland under some of the world’s strongest privacy laws. Proton VPN has a strict no-logs policy verified by independent audits. All Proton apps are open-source. The company also publishes a transparency report showing how it handles legal requests for customer data.
مولفاد: Based in Sweden, which is part of the 14 Eyes alliance. However, Mullvad’s no-logs policy has been confirmed by multiple independent audits. No user activity data was found during any مراجعة. Mullvad’s servers are RAM-only, so all data is wiped on every reboot. The VPN kill switch is always enabled and cannot be turned off.
2. شبكة الخادم
بروتون في بي إن: Offers over 8,600 VPN servers across 112 countries. This is a much larger server network than most VPN providers. All servers are physical (no virtual server locations). Proton VPN also offers dedicated servers for P2P file sharing and Tor over VPN connections.
مولفاد: Runs a smaller server network of around 700 servers in 49 countries. The network focuses on quality over quantity. Many servers are physically owned by Mullvad rather than rented. Server coverage is concentrated in Europe and North America, with limited presence in Asia and other regions.
⚠️ تحذير: If you need VPN servers in Africa, South America, or parts of Asia, Mullvad’s smaller server network may not have a nearby server. Proton VPN covers more server locations globally.
3. بروتوكولات VPN
بروتون في بي إن: Supports multiple VPN protocols including WireGuard, OpenVPN and WireGuard, and IKEv2. It also offers a proprietary Stealth protocol designed to bypass internet censorship. This makes the Proton VPN app more flexible for different network conditions. The windows app and أندرويد app both support all wireguard protocols.
مولفاد: Switched to WireGuard-only in January 2026. OpenVPN support was dropped. WireGuard is fast and secure, but the lack of protocol options means less flexibility. If WireGuard is blocked on a network, Mullvad may not connect at all.
4. البث المباشر والوصول إلى المحتوى
بروتون في بي إن: Reliably unblocks Netflix, BBC iPlayer, Amazon Prime Video, and other major streaming services. Proton VPN works well for accessing geo-restricted content from different countries. The VPN Accelerator helps maintain fast internet speeds while streaming.
مولفاد: Streaming is not Mullvad’s strength. According to multiple reviews, it struggles to unblock most streaming services. Netflix may work on some Mullvad servers, but BBC iPlayer, Disney+, and هولو are hit-or-miss. Mullvad focuses on privacy, not entertainment access.
5. ميزات الأمان
بروتون في بي إن: Includes Secure Core architecture that routes your encrypted vpn tunnel through privacy-friendly countries first. NetShield blocks ads, trackers, and malware. DNS leak protection and a kill switch are both included. Port forwarding is available for better torrent speeds. You can also connect to tor servers through the tor network for added anonymity. Proton VPN offers dedicated servers for P2P and a double vpn option via Secure Core routing.
مولفاد: Offers Multi-Hop routing, DAITA (Defense Against AI-guided Traffic Analysis), and a Lockdown mode that blocks all internet traffic outside the VPN tunnel. The VPN kill switch is enabled by default and cannot be disabled. DNS leak protection routes all DNS requests through Mullvad’s encrypted DNS servers.
6. سهولة الاستخدام
بروتون في بي إن: تطبيق Proton VPN متوفر على نظام التشغيل Windows. ماك, iOS, Android, Linux, and Android TV. The user-friendly interface makes it easy to connect to VPN servers with one click. A server map helps you pick locations visually. Split tunneling lets you choose which apps use the VPN connection.
مولفاد: Available on Windows, Mac, iOS, Android, and Linux. Linux apps are available for major distributions. The VPN apps are functional but more utilitarian in design. Mullvad also offers a dedicated Mullvad Browser built on Firefox for extra privacy. The settings menu has more advanced VPN settings that may confuse beginners. You can تصفح the server list and pick a nearby server or nearest server manually. The user friendly interface is clean but offers fewer visual cues than Proton VPN.
7. توصيلات الأجهزة
بروتون في بي إن: Allows up to 10 simultaneous device connections on a single account. This covers your laptop, phone, tablet, and more. You can also set up Proton VPN on a VPN compatible router to protect every mobile device on your network.
مولفاد: Supports up to five devices simultaneously. That’s enough for most individuals but tight for families. If you need more simultaneous device connections, you’d need a second account number.
8. دعم العملاء
بروتون في بي إن: Offers email-based customer support and a detailed knowledge base on Proton VPN’s website. There is no live chat support available. Proton VPN support staff typically respond within a few hours during عمل أيام.
مولفاد: Support is email-only. There is no live chat or phone support. You can contact Mullvad through their website. The support team is knowledgeable but response times can be slower than other VPN providers.
9. التسعير والتكلفة
لنقارن خطط الأسعار جنبًا إلى جنب.
| يخطط | بروتون في بي إن | مولفاد |
|---|---|---|
| حر | 0.00 دولار شهرياً | ❌ |
| شهريا | 9.99 دولارًا أمريكيًا شهريًا (بالإضافة إلى ذلك) | 5 يورو شهرياً |
| سنوي | 2.99 دولار شهرياً (بالإضافة إلى سنتين) | 5 يورو شهرياً |
| باقة | 7.99 دولار شهرياً (غير محدود) | ❌ |
بروتون في بي إن: The free VPN plan makes it easy to try before buying. On long-term plans, Proton VPN is actually cheaper than Mullvad at $2.99/month for a 2-year commitment. The Unlimited plan bundles Proton Mail, Drive, Calendar, and Pass for $7.99/month.
مولفاد: The flat €5/month pricing is dead simple. No discounts, no upsells, no surprise renewal fees. You pay the same rate whether you subscribe for one month or ten years. This is an expensive VPN month-to-month compared to long-term competitors, but cheaper than most monthly VPN plans.
سيناريوهات مختلفة
| إذا كنت بحاجة إلى | يختار | لماذا |
|---|---|---|
| شبكة افتراضية خاصة مجانية | بروتون في بي إن | الوحيد الذي يمتلك مستوى مجاني حقيقي |
| أقصى درجات إخفاء الهوية | مولفاد | لا حاجة للبريد الإلكتروني، الدفع نقداً |
| الوصول إلى البث | بروتون في بي إن | يفتح نتفليكس، وبي بي سي آي بلاير |
| تسعير ثابت وبسيط | مولفاد | €5/month, no renewal surprises |
| شبكة خوادم كبيرة | بروتون في بي إن | أكثر من 8600 خادم في 112 دولة |
| مناسب للمبتدئين | بروتون في بي إن | Easier app with more guidance |
💰 ميزانيتك
Proton VPN offers a free plan and long-term plans as low as $2.99/month. Mullvad charges a flat €5/month with no discounts, making it pricier if you commit long-term.
🔌 مجموعة أدواتك التقنية
Proton VPN connects up to 10 devices and works on Windows, Mac, iOS, Android, Linux, and Android TV. Mullvad supports up to five devices on the same operating systems but also includes a dedicated Mullvad Browser.
🔒 احتياجاتك المتعلقة بالخصوصية
If you want zero personal data tied to your VPN account, Mullvad wins. Proton VPN requires an email but offers Swiss legal protection and Secure Core servers for strong user privacy.
🎓 مستوى خبرتك
Proton VPN is easier for beginners. The Proton VPN app has a clean interface and simple server selection. Mullvad’s VPN settings are more advanced and may overwhelm first-time VPN users.
🆓 تجارب وعروض توضيحية مجانية
Proton VPN’s free plan lets you test the VPN service with no time limit. Mullvad has no free trial but offers a money-back guarantee within the first 30 days.
🛟 خيارات الدعم
Neither VPN offers live chat support. Both use email-only customer support. Proton VPN has a larger knowledge base on its website.
دليل التبديل
هل تستخدم إحدى هذه الأدوات بالفعل؟ إليك ما يمكن توقعه إذا قمت بالتبديل.
🔄 هل تفكر في الانتقال من ProtonVPN إلى Mullvad؟
✅ ما ستجنيه:
- No personal info tied to your VPN account
- Flat pricing with no renewal rate increases
- خوادم تعمل بذاكرة الوصول العشوائي فقط، تقوم بمسح البيانات عند إعادة التشغيل.
❌ ما ستخسره:
- Access to 8,600+ servers and the free VPN plan
- Reliable streaming support for Netflix and BBC iPlayer
- 10 simultaneous device connections (drops to 5)
📋 كيفية التبديل:
- Cancel your Proton VPN subscription from your Proton account dashboard
- انتقل إلى موقع mullvad.net وقم بإنشاء رقم حساب جديد
- Download the Mullvad VPN app and log in with your account number
🔄 هل تفكر في الانتقال من Mullvad إلى ProtonVPN؟
✅ ما ستجنيه:
- Massive server network with 8,600+ servers worldwide
- Streaming support for Netflix, BBC iPlayer, and more
- 10 simultaneous VPN connections per account
❌ ما ستخسره:
- Anonymous signup without any email or personal data
- سعر ثابت 5 يورو شهريًا بدون أي رسوم تجديد مفاجئة
- DAITA protection against AI traffic analysis
📋 كيفية التبديل:
- Stop adding time to your Mullvad account (it expires when your paid time runs out)
- Create a free Proton VPN account at protonvpn.com
- Download the Proton VPN app and upgrade to Plus if needed
ما لم تتناوله مراجعتنا
This comparison focused on individual users and small teams. We didn’t test enterprise VPN deployments or evaluate how either tool handles large-scale corporate networks. Our observations are based on the May 2026 versions of both VPN apps — features and pricing may have changed since then. If you need a VPN for a عمل with 50+ employees, your priorities may differ from what we’ve covered here.
💡 نصيحة احترافية: Before committing to either VPN, run a dns leak test on both. Connect to a nearby server on each VPN, then visit ipleak.net. Both Proton VPN and Mullvad should hide your true ip address and prevent dns leaks. If you’re a linux user, both VPN providers offer a linux app — Proton VPN also has a windows app and android app. On a windows laptop, the setup takes about two minutes. Check the server list for the nearest server to get the best upload speed and upload speeds.
الحكم النهائي
| فئة | الفائز |
|---|---|
| 💰 الأسعار | بروتون في بي إن |
| 🔒 الخصوصية | مولفاد |
| 🌐 شبكة الخوادم | بروتون في بي إن |
| 📺 البث المباشر | بروتون في بي إن |
| ⚡ Security Features | رَابِطَة |
| 👶 سهولة الاستخدام | بروتون في بي إن |
| 📱 توصيلات الأجهزة | بروتون في بي إن |
| 🏆 الفائز الإجمالي | بروتون في بي إن |
🏆 الفائز: ProtonVPN
فاز برنامج Proton VPN بخمسة من أصل سبعة فئات.
الأفضل لـ: Everyday VPN users, streamers, and anyone who wants a free VPN to start with
Proton VPN and Mullvad VPN are two very different products. Proton VPN is a full-featured VPN service with a free plan, huge server network, and strong streaming support. Mullvad is a privacy-only VPN built for users who want zero personal data tied to their account. Both vpn companies create an encrypted tunnel between your device and their servers.
Mullvad is excellent for VPN veterans who value anonymity above all else. Its anonymous signup and flat pricing model are hard to beat for pure privacy.
However, if you need a VPN that covers streaming, يسافر, and everyday browsing, Proton VPN is the better choice. It gives you more servers, more devices, and a free tier to try first.
المزيد من المعلومات حول ProtonVPN
Here’s how Proton VPN stacks up against other VPN providers:
مقارنة بين ProtonVPN و NordVPN
يتفوق ProtonVPN في: Free tier availability, Swiss jurisdiction, and open-source apps verified by audits
يتفوق NordVPN في: Larger server network with 6,000+ servers, faster connection speeds on nearby servers, and 24/7 live chat support
مقارنة بين ProtonVPN و ExpressVPN
يتفوق ProtonVPN في: Free plan with no data caps, lower long-term pricing at $2.99/month, and Secure Core double-hop routing
يتفوق ExpressVPN في: Wider device compatibility including routers, faster customer support response times, and stronger geo-unblocking across more regions
مقارنة بين ProtonVPN و SurfsharkVPN
يتفوق ProtonVPN في: Swiss privacy jurisdiction, Secure Core servers, and a genuinely unlimited free VPN plan
يفوز SurfsharkVPN في: Lower starting price at $1.99/month on long-term plans, unlimited device connections, and CleanWeb ad blocker
مقارنة بين ProtonVPN سايبرجوست
يتفوق ProtonVPN في: Open-source codebase, free plan option, and stronger no-logs audit record
فاز فريق CyberGhost في: Larger server fleet with 9,000+ servers, dedicated streaming and gaming servers, and 45-day money-back guarantee
مقارنة شاملة لخدمات Mullvad VPN
إليكم كيف يقارن Mullvad VPN بمزودي خدمة VPN الآخرين:
مولفاد ضد نورد في بي إن
فاز مولفاد في: Anonymous signup with no email, flat pricing with no renewal increases, and RAM-only server infrastructure
يتفوق NordVPN في: Thousands more servers worldwide, reliable streaming support for Netflix and BBC iPlayer, and 24/7 live chat customer support
مولفاد مقابل الوصول الخاص إلى الإنترنت
فاز مولفاد في: No personal data required at signup, cash payment option for full anonymity, and DAITA protection against traffic analysis
الوصول الخاص إلى الإنترنت يفوز في: Lower annual pricing, larger server network, and better streaming unblocking performance
Mullvad vs SurfsharkVPN
فاز مولفاد في: Zero personal info at signup, RAM-only servers, and transparent flat-rate pricing
يفوز SurfsharkVPN في: Unlimited device connections, much lower long-term pricing, and strong streaming unblocking across platforms
الأسئلة الشائعة
هل استخدام Proton VPN آمن؟
Yes. Proton VPN is based in Switzerland and has a strict no logs policy verified by independent audits. All Proton apps are open-source, meaning anyone can inspect the code. This premium vpn uses AES-256 encryption and offers DNS leak protection. Proton VPN passed every dns leak test in our proton vpn review. The vpn company keeps no ip logs and hides your internet traffic from your internet service provider.
هل مولفاد مجهول الهوية حقاً؟
Mullvad comes closer to true anonymity than most secure vpns. It does not require an email address or any personal info. You can pay with cash or crypto. Multiple independent audits confirmed that Mullvad stores no user activity data. In this mullvad vpn review, we found that Mullvad passed every privacy check. The mullvad vpn server infrastructure runs on RAM-only hardware. Other vpns and other vpn services require personal details that Mullvad skips entirely.
هل يمكنني استخدام بروتون VPN مجاناً؟
Yes. Proton VPN offers a free plan with unlimited bandwidth and no ads. The free version limits you to Proton VPN servers in a few countries and one device. No credit card is needed. Among other free vpns and free vpns in the market, the Proton VPN free tier stands out because it has no data caps. Proton services like Proton Mail also have free tiers.
هل تعمل شركة Mullvad مع Netflix؟
Netflix may work on some Mullvad servers, but results vary. Mullvad does not prioritize streaming. If accessing geo-restricted content is important, Proton VPN is a better fit for that use case.
Which is better for everyday use — Proton VPN or Mullvad?
Proton VPN is better for everyday use. It has a larger server network, supports streaming services, and connects up to 10 mobile devices. Mullvad has a relatively small server network and a smaller number of servers. Mullvad is better for vpn users who want maximum anonymity. If you need to pick from the mullvad server or use a vpn compatible router, both work. But Proton VPN gives you more server locations and better connection speeds for browsing.
English 
Spanish 
Chinese 
German 
French 
Arabic 
Russian 
Portuguese 
Japanese 
Korean 
Italian 
Turkish 
Dutch 
Polish 
Indonesian 
Thai 
Vietnamese 