📊 Our Test Results:
- 🔒 Privacy Policy: PIA audited no-logs vs McAfee logs IP addresses — PIA wins
- 🌍 Server Network: PIA 35,000+ servers (91 countries) vs McAfee ~2,000 (47 countries) — PIA wins
- 📱 Device Limit: PIA unlimited vs McAfee 5 devices — PIA wins
- ⚡ Speed Test: McAfee 97Mbps nearby vs PIA slower on average — McAfee wins
- 💰 Value for Money: PIA $2.03/mo vs McAfee $39.99/yr bundled — PIA wins
Picking the right VPN feels overwhelming when two popular names keep popping up.
Private Internet Access is a dedicated VPN built from the ground up for privacy.
McAfee VPN is a VPN bolted onto a famous antivirus suite.
I bought both, tested them for over a month, and tracked every detail.
The gap between these two products is bigger than you might think.
Here is exactly what I found.
Overview
I spent weeks testing Private Internet Access vs McAfee VPN head-to-head.
I ran speed tests, checked privacy policies, tried streaming, and compared every feature.
I also dug into their pricing, device support, and customer service.
This guide shares my honest, firsthand experience to help you choose wisely.
What is Private Internet Access?
Private Internet Access (PIA) is one of the longest-running VPN services on the market.
It launched in 2010 and has grown into one of the most popular VPNs worldwide.
PIA encrypts your internet traffic and masks your real IP address.
It runs a massive network of 35,000+ servers across 91 countries.
Every PIA app is open-source, which means anyone can check the code for security flaws.
PIA also allows unlimited device connections on a single subscription.
Private Internet Access
PIA is a top-rated VPN with 35,000+ servers in 91 countries. It offers unlimited devices, an audited no-logs policy, and starts at just $2.03/month.
Private Internet Access Pricing
PIA keeps its pricing simple with one feature tier and three plan lengths.
| Plan | Price | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| 2 Years + 4 Months | $2.03/month | Best value for long-term users |
| 6 Months | $7.50/month | Mid-term commitment |
| 1 Month | $11.99/month | Quick testing or short trips |
Free trial: 7-day free trial on the iOS and Android apps. No credit card needed to start.
Money-back guarantee: 30-day full refund on all plans. Just contact their 24/7 support team.
📌 Note: Every PIA plan includes every feature. The only difference is how long you commit. Longer plans save you more money per month.
⚠️ Warning: Auto-renewal is turned on by default. Cancel at least 24 hours before your plan ends to avoid charges. Renewals are not covered by the money-back guarantee.
Key Benefits of Private Internet Access
Here is why PIA stands out from other VPN providers:
- Audited No-Logs Policy: Deloitte has independently verified PIA’s no-logs claim multiple times. PIA stores zero activity or connection data.
- Huge Server Network: Over 35,000 servers in 91 countries, including all 50 US states. More servers mean less congestion.
- Unlimited Device Connections: Connect every device you own with one subscription. No caps whatsoever.
- Open-Source Transparency: Every PIA app is open-source. Security researchers can inspect the code anytime.
- MACE Ad & Tracker Blocker: Blocks ads, trackers, and malware at the DNS level. No extra software needed.
- Advanced Split Tunneling: Choose which apps, IP addresses, or DNS requests go through the VPN. Great for power users.
- RAM-Only Servers: PIA’s servers wipe all data on every reboot. Nothing is stored on hard drives.
Private Internet Access Pros & Cons
✅ Pros
- Deloitte-audited no-logs policy proven in court
- 35,000+ servers across 91 countries
- Unlimited device connections on every plan
- 100% open-source apps for full transparency
- Very affordable long-term plans ($2.03/month)
❌ Cons
- Average speed loss of ~49% on distant servers
- Based in the US (Five Eyes Alliance member)
- Streaming unblocking can be hit or miss
- Monthly plan is expensive at $11.99
What is McAfee VPN?
McAfee VPN (also known as McAfee Safe Connect) is a VPN built into McAfee’s antivirus suite.
It comes from one of the biggest names in cybersecurity.
McAfee VPN uses AES-256 encryption to protect your browsing on public Wi-Fi.
The VPN auto-connects whenever it detects an unsecured network.
It covers servers in about 47 countries and allows up to 5 device connections.
You cannot buy the VPN as a standalone product from McAfee’s website.
McAfee VPN
McAfee VPN bundles a VPN with antivirus, identity monitoring, and scam detection. A good pick if you want all-in-one security in a single app.
McAfee VPN Pricing
McAfee VPN is only available as part of their security plans. Here is the breakdown.
| Plan | Price | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Essential | $39.99/yr | Basic antivirus + VPN for 5 devices |
| Advanced Individual | $89.99/yr | Identity protection for one person |
| Advanced Family | $119.99/yr | Family security with multiple accounts |
Free trial: McAfee offers a free VPN tier with only 250MB of data per month. That is barely enough to stream a single short video.
Money-back guarantee: 30-day money-back guarantee on all paid plans.
📌 Note: The VPN is bundled with antivirus and identity tools. You cannot buy the VPN separately from the McAfee website. Auto-renewal must be enabled to access the VPN.
⚠️ Warning: These prices are first-year introductory rates. Renewal prices jump significantly. The Essential plan renews at a much higher rate after year one.
Key Benefits of McAfee VPN
Here is why some users prefer McAfee VPN:
- All-in-One Security: One subscription covers antivirus, VPN, firewall, and identity protection. No need for multiple apps.
- Smart Wi-Fi Protection: The VPN turns on automatically when you connect to public Wi-Fi. Zero manual effort required.
- Identity Theft Coverage: Advanced plans include up to $1M in identity theft insurance plus personal data cleanup tools.
- Beginner-Friendly Design: McAfee’s app is dead simple. One tap to connect. No confusing settings.
- Trusted Brand: McAfee has been a household name in cybersecurity for over 30 years.
- Decent Nearby Speeds: McAfee hit 97Mbps on nearby servers during testing. Fine for everyday browsing and email.
McAfee VPN Pros & Cons
✅ Pros
- Bundles antivirus, VPN, and identity protection together
- Auto-connects on unsecured public Wi-Fi networks
- Uses industry-standard AES-256 encryption
- Very simple interface for non-technical users
❌ Cons
- Logs your IP address and browsing activity
- Limited to just 5 simultaneous device connections
- Small server network (~2,000 servers in 47 countries)
- No macOS or Linux VPN app available
- Kill switch only works on Windows
Feature Comparison
Now let’s dig into a detailed feature-by-feature breakdown.
We will compare 9 key areas to help you pick the right VPN.
| Feature | Private Internet Access | McAfee VPN |
|---|---|---|
| Starting Price | $2.03/month | $39.99/year (~$3.33/mo) |
| Servers | 35,000+ in 91 countries | ~2,000 in 47 countries |
| Device Limit | Unlimited | 5 devices |
| No-Logs Audit | ✅ Verified by Deloitte | ❌ Logs IP addresses |
| Kill Switch | ✅ All platforms | ⚠️ Windows only |
| Split Tunneling | ✅ Advanced (app + IP) | ⚠️ Android only |
| Open-Source | ✅ | ❌ |
| Antivirus Bundled | ❌ (optional add-on) | ✅ |
| Best For | Privacy-first users | All-in-one security buyers |
1. Privacy & No-Logs Policy
Private Internet Access: PIA runs a strict no-logs policy that Deloitte has verified in multiple independent audits. PIA does not store browsing history, IP addresses, timestamps, or DNS queries. The apps are fully open-source so the code is public.
McAfee VPN: McAfee Safe Connect logs personally identifiable data including your IP address and the websites you visit. Their privacy policy is vague about what exactly gets stored. McAfee will also hand over data to legal authorities if requested.
⚠️ Warning: McAfee keeps logged data indefinitely. They only delete it when you close your account, and even then retain it for 30 extra days.
2. Server Network
Private Internet Access: PIA operates over 35,000 servers spread across 91 countries. That includes coverage in all 50 US states. A bigger network means less crowding and faster connections during peak hours.
McAfee VPN: McAfee has about 2,000 servers in roughly 47 countries. That is a fraction of what PIA offers. Fewer servers mean more users per server and less flexibility when choosing a location.
3. Speed & Performance
Private Internet Access: PIA’s average download speed loss sits around 49%. It works better on nearby servers and with the WireGuard protocol. Performance is solid for browsing, casual streaming, and everyday use.
McAfee VPN: McAfee recorded 97Mbps download speeds on nearby servers using its Catapult Hydra protocol. International speeds stayed above 75Mbps. However, latency on Windows can spike dramatically — up to 600% in some tests.
4. Device Support & Connections
Private Internet Access: PIA allows unlimited simultaneous connections on every plan. It supports Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, Android, and browser extensions for Chrome, Firefox, and Opera. You can set it up on routers too.
McAfee VPN: McAfee caps you at 5 devices per subscription. It works on Windows, iOS, and Android. There is no macOS or Linux VPN app available. That is a dealbreaker for many Apple and Linux users.
5. Security Features
Private Internet Access: PIA packs AES-256 encryption, WireGuard and OpenVPN protocols, a kill switch on every platform, advanced split tunneling by app and IP, multi-hop routing through two servers, and the MACE DNS-level ad blocker. PIA also runs RAM-only servers.
McAfee VPN: McAfee uses AES-256 encryption and the Catapult Hydra protocol. It has a kill switch but only on Windows. Split tunneling is Android-only. There is no multi-hop, no DNS-level ad blocking, and no open-source code.
⚠️ Warning: McAfee VPN has no kill switch on iOS or Android. If the VPN drops, your real IP address and traffic are instantly exposed to your ISP.
6. Streaming & Torrenting
Private Internet Access: PIA has streaming-optimized servers that work with Netflix, Disney Plus, and other services. It fully supports P2P traffic on most servers. Port forwarding is also available for faster download speeds.
McAfee VPN: McAfee struggles to unblock popular streaming services like Netflix and Hulu. It does not support P2P or torrent traffic at all. If you care about streaming or downloading, McAfee VPN is not the right tool.
7. Split Tunneling
Private Internet Access: PIA offers one of the most advanced split tunneling features available. You can choose specific apps, IP addresses, and DNS requests to route through the VPN while keeping everything else on your regular connection.
McAfee VPN: McAfee only offers split tunneling on its Android app. Windows, iOS, and other platforms do not have this feature. This gives you almost no control over which traffic goes through the VPN.
8. Customer Support
Private Internet Access: PIA provides 24/7 live chat support in English, French, German, and Romanian. They also have a large knowledge base full of troubleshooting articles and setup guides.
McAfee VPN: McAfee offers live chat, phone support, and email for its full product suite. However, VPN-specific help can be hard to find since the VPN is a small piece of their overall product.
9. Pricing & Cost
Here is a side-by-side look at pricing.
| Plan Type | Private Internet Access | McAfee VPN |
|---|---|---|
| Free Tier | 7-day mobile trial | 250MB/month free |
| Cheapest Paid | $2.03/month (2yr+4mo) | $39.99/year (~$3.33/mo) |
| Mid-Tier | $7.50/month (6 months) | $89.99/yr (Advanced Individual) |
| Top Tier | $11.99/month (monthly) | $119.99/yr (Advanced Family) |
Private Internet Access: PIA’s long-term plan at $2.03/month is one of the cheapest quality VPNs you can find. Every feature is included on all plans. No tiers, no feature gatekeeping.
McAfee VPN: The Essential plan at $39.99/year seems affordable. But that is a first-year introductory rate that jumps at renewal. The VPN by itself is not worth it — the value comes from the bundled antivirus and identity tools.
Different Scenarios
| If You Need… | Choose | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Maximum privacy | PIA | Audited no-logs, open-source |
| All-in-one security suite | McAfee VPN | Antivirus + VPN + identity tools |
| Unlimited devices | PIA | No device limit at all |
| Streaming & torrenting | PIA | Better unblocking + P2P support |
| Public Wi-Fi auto-protection | McAfee VPN | Auto-connects on open networks |
| Best price for VPN-only | PIA | $2.03/month on long-term plan |
💰 Your Budget
PIA costs $2.03/month for a standalone VPN on the longest plan. McAfee starts at $39.99/year but bundles antivirus and identity tools. If you only need a VPN, PIA delivers more for less.
🔌 Your Tech Stack
PIA supports Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, Android, and routers. McAfee VPN skips macOS and Linux entirely. If you own a Mac, PIA is your only real option between these two.
📝 Your Privacy Needs
PIA’s no-logs policy is audited and proven. McAfee logs your IP address and web activity. If protecting your identity online is your main goal, PIA wins hands down.
🎓 Your Experience Level
McAfee’s one-tap connect makes it ideal for total beginners. PIA has more settings and customization for people who want full control. Both are easy to install.
🆓 Free Trials and Demos
PIA offers a 7-day free trial on mobile and a 30-day money-back guarantee. McAfee has a free plan with 250MB/month — barely usable. Try both before you commit.
🛟 Support Options
Both offer 24/7 live chat and email. McAfee adds phone support. PIA has a bigger VPN-specific knowledge base for solving problems on your own.
Switching Guide
Already using one of these tools? Here is what to expect if you switch.
🔄 Switching from Private Internet Access to McAfee VPN?
✅ What you’ll gain:
- Bundled antivirus and identity theft protection in one app
- Auto-connect VPN on unsafe Wi-Fi networks
- Faster nearby server speeds via the Catapult Hydra protocol
❌ What you’ll lose:
- Verified no-logs privacy (McAfee logs IP addresses and sites)
- Unlimited device connections (McAfee caps at 5)
- macOS/Linux support and advanced split tunneling
📋 How to switch:
- Cancel your PIA subscription and request a refund within 30 days
- Go to mcafee.com and choose a McAfee security plan
- Enable the VPN inside the McAfee dashboard and connect
🔄 Switching from McAfee VPN to Private Internet Access?
✅ What you’ll gain:
- Audited no-logs privacy with open-source apps you can verify
- 35,000+ servers in 91 countries vs McAfee’s ~2,000 in 47
- Unlimited devices, macOS/Linux support, and power-user features
❌ What you’ll lose:
- Bundled antivirus protection (you will need a separate antivirus)
- Identity theft coverage and monitoring features
- Automatic VPN activation on public Wi-Fi
📋 How to switch:
- Turn off auto-renewal on McAfee and request a refund within 30 days
- Sign up at privateinternetaccess.com and pick your plan length
- Download the PIA app on every device you own and connect
Final Verdict
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| 💰 Pricing | Private Internet Access |
| 🔒 Privacy & Logging | Private Internet Access |
| 🌍 Server Network | Private Internet Access |
| ⚡ Speed | McAfee VPN |
| 📱 Device Support | Private Internet Access |
| 🔐 Security Features | Private Internet Access |
| 📺 Streaming & Torrenting | Private Internet Access |
| 🛡️ Bundled Security | McAfee VPN |
| 🏆 Overall Winner | Private Internet Access |
🏆 WINNER: Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access wins 7 out of 9 categories.
Best for: Privacy-focused users, streamers, torrenters, and anyone who wants a dedicated VPN at a great price.
Private Internet Access and McAfee VPN target very different users.
PIA is a dedicated VPN built for people who care about privacy and freedom.
McAfee VPN is a basic add-on inside a bigger security package.
If you want antivirus, identity protection, and a basic VPN in one place, McAfee makes sense.
But if you want real privacy, 35,000+ servers, and unlimited devices, PIA is the clear winner.
Now go lock down your online privacy with the VPN that fits your life!
More of Private Internet Access Compared
Here’s how Private Internet Access stacks up against other competitors:
Private Internet Access vs NordVPN
PIA wins on: Price, unlimited devices, open-source code
NordVPN wins on: Faster speeds, streaming, Threat Protection
Private Internet Access vs ExpressVPN
PIA wins on: Price, server count, device connections
ExpressVPN wins on: Speed, streaming, user experience
Private Internet Access vs PureVPN
PIA wins on: Audited privacy, server network, transparency
PureVPN wins on: Dedicated IP options, port forwarding
Private Internet Access vs Surfshark VPN
PIA wins on: Server count, open-source apps, US coverage
Surfshark wins on: Speed, CleanWeb blocker, multi-hop
Private Internet Access vs Proton VPN
PIA wins on: Server count, price, device connections
Proton VPN wins on: Swiss privacy laws, free tier, Secure Core
Private Internet Access vs PrivadoVPN
PIA wins on: Server network, audit history, features
PrivadoVPN wins on: Free 10GB tier, Swiss jurisdiction
Private Internet Access vs AdGuard VPN
PIA wins on: Server count, unlimited devices, split tunneling
AdGuard VPN wins on: Built-in ad blocking suite, lightweight apps
Private Internet Access vs Virtual Shield
PIA wins on: Server network, price, advanced features
Virtual Shield wins on: US-focused simplicity, identity tools
Private Internet Access vs StrongVPN
PIA wins on: Price, server network, device limit
StrongVPN wins on: China bypass, SugarSync cloud bundle
Private Internet Access vs FastestVPN
PIA wins on: Server count, audited privacy, features
FastestVPN wins on: Lifetime plan, Cayman Islands base
Private Internet Access vs Aura VPN
PIA wins on: Dedicated VPN features, transparency, servers
Aura VPN wins on: Identity protection bundle, credit monitoring
Private Internet Access vs CyberGhost
PIA wins on: Open-source code, unlimited devices, US servers
CyberGhost wins on: Streaming servers, 45-day refund, NoSpy servers
Private Internet Access vs Mysterium VPN
PIA wins on: Speed, reliability, customer support
Mysterium wins on: Decentralized network, pay-per-use pricing
Private Internet Access vs SafeShell VPN
PIA wins on: Server network, audited privacy, brand trust
SafeShell VPN wins on: Newer protocol options, niche features
Private Internet Access vs Oyster VPN
PIA wins on: Server count, features, long track record
Oyster VPN wins on: Simple pricing, Ireland jurisdiction
More of McAfee VPN Compared
Here’s how McAfee VPN stacks up against other competitors:
McAfee wins on: Bundled antivirus, identity protection
NordVPN wins on: Speed, privacy, servers, VPN features
McAfee wins on: Security suite bundle, identity theft coverage
ExpressVPN wins on: Speed, streaming, privacy, platform support
McAfee wins on: Brand recognition, antivirus bundle
PureVPN wins on: Server network, dedicated IPs, VPN features
McAfee wins on: Identity theft insurance, antivirus combo
Surfshark wins on: Unlimited devices, speed, privacy, streaming
McAfee wins on: All-in-one security, ease of use
Proton VPN wins on: Privacy, Swiss base, free tier, audits
McAfee VPN vs PrivadoVPN
McAfee wins on: Brand trust, bundled identity tools
PrivadoVPN wins on: Free 10GB/mo tier, Swiss privacy, VPN features
McAfee VPN vs AdGuard VPN
McAfee wins on: Antivirus bundle, identity protection
AdGuard VPN wins on: Ad blocking, lighter apps, better privacy
McAfee VPN vs Virtual Shield
McAfee wins on: Antivirus combo, scam detection
Virtual Shield wins on: Simpler interface, US-focused protection
McAfee VPN vs StrongVPN
McAfee wins on: Brand recognition, security suite
StrongVPN wins on: Better VPN features, China access, WireGuard
McAfee VPN vs FastestVPN
McAfee wins on: Antivirus bundle, identity theft tools
FastestVPN wins on: Lifetime plan, more VPN features, privacy
McAfee VPN vs Aura VPN
McAfee wins on: Antivirus strength, scam detection
Aura VPN wins on: Deeper identity protection, credit monitoring
McAfee VPN vs CyberGhost
McAfee wins on: All-in-one security approach
CyberGhost wins on: Server network, streaming, 45-day refund
McAfee wins on: Brand trust, ease of use
Mysterium wins on: Decentralized network, pay-per-use model
McAfee VPN vs SafeShell VPN
McAfee wins on: Established brand, security suite
SafeShell VPN wins on: Dedicated VPN features, newer technology
McAfee VPN vs Oyster VPN
McAfee wins on: Antivirus bundle, brand recognition
Oyster VPN wins on: Ireland jurisdiction, better VPN privacy
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Private Internet Access better than McAfee VPN?
Yes. PIA wins on privacy, server network, device support, and core VPN features. McAfee is only better if you want a bundled antivirus with your VPN.
Is McAfee VPN safe to use?
McAfee VPN uses AES-256 encryption, which is a strong standard. But it logs IP addresses and browsing data. If true privacy matters to you, PIA is the safer pick.
Can PIA VPN be tracked?
PIA has a strict no-logs policy verified by Deloitte in multiple audits. It does not store any data that could identify you or your activity online.
Does McAfee VPN work with Netflix?
McAfee VPN has trouble unblocking Netflix and other major streaming services. PIA has streaming-optimized servers that perform better for this purpose.
How much does Private Internet Access cost per month?
PIA costs $2.03/month on the 2-year plan, $7.50/month on the 6-month plan, or $11.99 for a single month. Every plan includes all features.
English 
Spanish 
Chinese 
German 
French 
Arabic 
Russian 
Portuguese 
Japanese 
Korean 
Italian 
Turkish 
Dutch 
Polish 
Indonesian 
Thai 
Vietnamese 