⚡ Quick Verdict:
- Pricing: Total Password Premium is $119 / Year. Proton Pass has a free plan and paid plans from $2.99/month.
- Best for: Total Password suits people who want antivirus software bundled in. Proton Pass suits privacy-first users who want unlimited passwords at no cost.
- Key difference: Proton Pass adds hide my email aliases, dark web monitoring and an integrated 2fa authenticator. Total Password has no password sharing and no desktop app.
- Our pick: Proton Pass, because a free forever tier with unlimited devices beats a single $119 plan for most people.
The cheaper password manager here is also the more capable one.
That is not how these matchups usually go.
Total Password sells one plan and bundles it with antivirus software.
Proton Pass gives away unlimited password storage and charges for privacy extras.
Those two approaches lead to very different bills and very different feature lists.
Overview
This TotalPassword vs Proton Pass comparison covers pricing, security features, and day-to-day password management.
Our writer spent time inside Total Password directly.
Notes on Proton Pass come from Proton’s documentation, published audits, and G2 reviews.
By the end you will know which password manager fits your budget and habits.
What is Total Password?
Total Password is a password manager built by the team behind TotalAV.
It stores all your passwords in an encrypted vault behind one master password.
You get unlimited password storage and sync across all your devices.
The browser extension handles autofill passwords on Chrome, Edge, and Safari.
Most buyers pick it because it bundles with antivirus software from the same company.
Here is a walkthrough of how the vault and browser extension work together.
Total Password
One vault, unlimited devices, and AES 256-bit data encryption. Pairs with TotalAV if you want antivirus software too.
Total Password Pricing
Total Password keeps its price list short. There is one paid tier and no monthly option.
| Plan | Price | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Premium | $119 / Year | One person who wants unlimited passwords on every device |
Pricing verified July 2026.
Free trial: No free tier. Billing is annual only, so there is no monthly plan to test.
Money-back guarantee: A 30 day money back guarantee applies to every subscription.
📌 Note: Total Password can be added to the TotalAV Total Security plan at $49 per year, which also carries antivirus software and a VPN.
⚠️ Pricing conflict: Our CSV lists Premium at $119 / Year and that is the figure used in every table here. Separate research notes a $1.99 per month intro rate billed as $23.80 for year one, then $9.99 per month billed annually at $119.88. Check the Total Password website at checkout before you buy.
Key Benefits of Total Password
Here is what makes Total Password worth a look:
- Zero knowledge vault: A zero-knowledge policy stops staff and developers from reading your secure password vault. Data encryption happens before anything leaves your machine.
- Security Report: Total Password’s security report audits stored passwords and flags weak, old, or duplicate entries.
- Leaked password check: It compares your personal login credentials against known data breaches and warns you about leaked passwords.
- Secure Me: One click triggers a remote logout of your Total Password account on every session.
- Recovery key: Setup hands you a recovery key PDF so you can reset a forgotten master password.
- Beyond passwords: You can safely store credit card details and secure notes next to login details.
- Support channels: Email, live chat, phone support, and a knowledge base are all available.
What Our Team Noticed
Our writer created a Total Password account and moved a real vault across. Here is what stood out during that hands-on time:
Total Password Pros & Cons
✅ Pros
- Unlimited password storage with sync across unlimited devices
- AES 256-bit encryption paired with a zero-knowledge policy
- Security Report flags weak, old, or duplicate credentials
- Secure Me logs you out of every device remotely
- Phone support is offered in Europe and other regions
❌ Cons
- No password sharing feature at all
- No web dashboard and no desktop app
- Import struggles with data from other password managers
- Live chat is slow and buried behind knowledge base articles
What is Proton Pass?
Proton Pass is an open source password manager from the makers of Proton Mail.
Proton AG owns Proton Pass and runs it from Switzerland under strong privacy laws.
Proton Pass launched in 2023 and now sits beside Proton VPN, Proton Drive, and Proton Calendar.
Every field is end to end encrypted before it reaches Proton’s servers.
Only you hold the key, so Proton cannot read your vault.
One Proton account unlocks the password manager plus other Proton services.
🏆 Winner: Proton Pass
A free password manager with unlimited logins on unlimited devices. Open code, independent audits, and email aliases built in.
Proton Pass Pricing
Proton Pass free is the entry point. Paid plans add privacy tools rather than extra storage.
| Plan | Price | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0/month | Unlimited passwords, unlimited devices, 10 email aliases |
| Pass Plus | $2.99/month | Dark web monitoring and vault sharing with 10 people |
| Pass Family | $4.99/month | Up to 6 users with Plus features each |
| Proton Unlimited | $9.99/month | Full suite including Proton Mail and Proton VPN |
Pricing verified July 2026.
Free trial: Not needed. The free plan is free forever and covers just your passwords.
Money-back guarantee: Paid tiers carry a 30 day money back guarantee.
📌 Note: Business buyers get two extra tiers. Pass Essentials covers small teams and Pass Professional adds admin controls for larger ones.
⚠️ Currency conflict: Our earlier FahimAI pricing snapshot listed these same tiers in euros at €2.99, €4.99, and €9.99. The dollar figures above match Proton’s current US rate card. Confirm your local currency at checkout.
Key Benefits of Proton Pass
Here is what Proton Pass offers that most rivals do not:
- Free tier with no caps: You can store unlimited passwords and unlimited logins across unlimited devices without paying.
- Hide my email aliases: Generate throwaway addresses so your personal email address never touches a signup form.
- Dark web monitoring: Pass Monitor warns you when your login credentials surface in a data breach.
- Open code, audited: The source is public and the German firm Cure53 has run independent security audits.
- Proton Sentinel: This program watches for suspicious sign-ins and alerts you fast.
- Integrated 2fa authenticator: TOTP codes live in the same vault, so you enable two factor authentication without a separate app.
- Easy migration: Import accepts CSV and JSON files plus ZIP and XML exports.
What Our Team Noticed
Note: We have not logged extensive hands-on time with Proton Pass yet. The points above come from Proton’s published documentation, the Cure53 audit summary, and G2 reviews. Our full Proton Pass review will be updated once our writers finish a longer trial.
Proton Pass Pros & Cons
✅ Pros
- Free plan stores unlimited passwords on unlimited devices
- Hide my email aliases keep your real address private
- Open source code audited by Cure53
- Integrated 2fa authenticator removes the need for a second app
- Secure sharing of login credentials through encrypted links
❌ Cons
- Paid plans cost more than NordPass or Bitwarden
- Proton Pass lacks live chat support
- No emergency access for a trusted contact
- Autofill can need configuration in some browsers
Feature Comparison
Both tools handle the basics of password management well. The gaps show up once you look past the vault itself, so we lined up ten areas that decide most purchases.
| Feature | Total Password | Proton Pass |
|---|---|---|
| Starting Price | $119 / Year | $0/month |
| Free Plan | ❌ | ✅ |
| Unlimited Password Storage | ✅ | ✅ |
| Password Sharing | ❌ | ✅ |
| Dark Web Monitoring | ✅ | ✅ |
| Integrated 2FA Authenticator | ❌ | ✅ |
| Email Aliases | ❌ | ✅ |
| Desktop App | ❌ | ✅ |
| Web Dashboard | ❌ | ✅ |
| Open Source Code | ❌ | ✅ |
| Best For | TotalAV customers | Privacy-first individuals |
1. Security and Encryption
Total Password: Total Password uses 256-bit AES encryption and a zero knowledge architecture. Nobody at the company, including its developers, can read the contents of your secure password vault. Total Password secure notes and saved card records get the same treatment as login details.
Proton Pass: Proton Pass applies AES-256 with end to end encryption on every field, not just the password box. Zero knowledge means encryption and decryption happen on your device. The same strong encryption underpins Proton’s secure communication products.
⚠️ Warning: Both vendors claim zero knowledge, but only Proton Pass publishes its code and audit reports. Cure53 has reviewed it independently. Sensitive data is stored securely in both, yet only one can be checked by outsiders.
2. Password Generator
Total Password: Total Password’s password generator builds strings up to 32 characters. That is long enough to shrug off brute force attacks on the accounts online that matter most. It cannot build passphrases, which 1Password and several rivals do offer.
Proton Pass: The password generator switches between random strings and memorable word chains. Both modes produce strong passwords and unique passwords for every site. Password generation happens locally, so nothing travels before it is encrypted.
3. Breach Alerts and Password Audits
Total Password: The Security Report grades every entry and flags weak, old, or duplicate credentials. A separate leaked password check runs your logins against known data breaches. It keeps passwords safe by nudging you to rotate anything exposed.
Proton Pass: Pass Monitor pairs reuse warnings with dark web monitoring. Data breach monitoring runs continuously on Pass Plus and alerts you when your address appears in a leak. Paid vaults also keep password history so you can roll an entry back.
4. Two-Factor Authentication
Total Password: You can enable two factor authentication on the vault itself through any standard authenticator app. Google Authenticator and Microsoft Authenticator both work. Codes for your other sites still live wherever you already keep them.
Proton Pass: An integrated 2fa authenticator stores TOTP codes inside each login entry. Your Proton Pass account fills the password and the code in one step. That removes the phone juggling that two factor authentication usually adds.
5. Sharing and Emergency Access
Total Password: There is no password sharing feature here, which puts it behind 1Password, Dashlane, and other top password managers. Emergency access for a trusted relative is missing too. Secure Me is the closest thing, letting you force a remote logout everywhere.
Proton Pass: Secure password sharing works through encrypted links, and Pass Plus extends vault access to ten recipients. These are advanced security features aimed at households and small teams. Emergency access is still absent, which reviewers regularly note.
6. Autofill, Extensions and Mobile
Total Password: The browser extension covers the Chrome browser, Edge, and Safari, and autofill lands reliably. Total Password’s mobile apps run on iOS and Android devices. Once you install Total Password on your phone, the same vault follows you across mobile devices.
Proton Pass: Proton Pass works through its own browser extension plus apps for Android devices and iPhone. G2 reviews note autofill sometimes needs a settings tweak before it behaves. Once set, you securely log in with a single tap.
7. Email Aliases and Privacy Extras
Total Password: There is no alias tool. Your personal email address goes straight into every signup form, so spam and breach exposure both stay high. You can still securely store card numbers and other sensitive information in the vault.
Proton Pass: Hide my email aliases generate a random address per site and forward mail to your real inbox. The free plan includes ten. This is the clearest privacy gap between the two, and it keeps your private data out of marketing lists.
8. Platform Coverage
Total Password: There is no web dashboard and no desktop app, which is unusual at this price. Everything happens in the extension or the mobile app. If your browser profile breaks, you lose your quickest route in.
Proton Pass: Proton Pass apps cover Windows, Mac, and Linux, alongside a browser web dashboard. Those desktop apps mean your vault opens even when extensions misbehave. Coverage is one of the reasons it ranks with the best password managers on our list.
9. Bundled Extras
Total Password: This is where Total Password’s features pull ahead. The TotalAV Total Security bundle folds in antivirus software and a VPN for $49 per year.
The same bundle adds an ad blocker on top of the antivirus engine.
Proton Pass: Proton Unlimited bundles Proton Mail, Proton VPN, Proton Drive, and Proton Calendar with the password manager. It is a privacy suite rather than a security suite. No antivirus, but far more coverage for email and files.
10. Pricing & Cost
Here are the paid plans side by side, using the figures from our data sheet.
| Tier | Total Password | Proton Pass |
|---|---|---|
| Free | ❌ | $0/month |
| Individual paid | Premium: $119 / Year | Pass Plus: $2.99/month |
| Family | ❌ | Pass Family: $4.99/month |
| Full suite | Total Security: $49/year add-on | Proton Unlimited: $9.99/month |
Total Password: One tier at $119 / Year with no free version and no monthly billing. That is a lot to commit up front for a tool with no sharing and no desktop app. The bundle price is where the value sits.
Proton Pass: The free plan already handles managing passwords for one person. Paid plans do cost more than NordPass or Bitwarden, so the upgrade is worth it mainly for aliases and breach alerts.
Different Scenarios
| If You Need… | Choose | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Zero spend | Proton Pass | Free plan, unlimited devices |
| Antivirus in the same bill | Total Password | TotalAV bundle at $49/year |
| Password sharing | Proton Pass | Encrypted share links |
| Email aliases | Proton Pass | Ten aliases on the free tier |
| Phone support | Total Password | In-country numbers offered |
| Open, audited code | Proton Pass | Cure53 reviewed the source |
💰 Your Budget
Proton Pass costs nothing to start and never expires. Total Password asks for $119 / Year before you have stored a single entry.
🔌 Your Tech Stack
Already paying for TotalAV? The bundle makes Total Password cheap to bolt on. Already using Proton Mail or Proton VPN? Proton Unlimited covers everything at once.
👨👩👧 Your Household
Families need sharing, and only one of these has it. Pass Family covers six people for $4.99/month, while Total Password has no family tier.
🎓 Your Experience Level
Total Password keeps things simple with one plan and few settings. Proton Pass has more switches, though the defaults are sensible for beginners.
🆓 Free Trials and Demos
Proton Pass free needs no card at all. The refund window is the only way to try Total Password risk free, so diarise day 29.
🛟 Support Options
Total Password wins on customer support channels, with email, phone, and chat. Reaching the chat queue is slow, and Proton Pass lacks live chat support entirely.
Switching Guide
Already committed to one of these? Here is what changes when you move.
🔄 Switching from Total Password to Proton Pass?
✅ What you’ll gain:
- A free tier plus sharing, aliases, and desktop apps
- Codes and logins in one place via the built-in authenticator
- Public source code and published audit results
❌ What you’ll lose:
- The bundled antivirus and VPN discount
- Phone and live chat support lines
- The Secure Me one-click device wipe
📋 How to switch:
- Export your existing passwords from the extension as a CSV file
- Create a free Proton account and open Pass
- Use the import tool, which accepts CSV and JSON files, then delete the export
🔄 Switching from Proton Pass to Total Password?
✅ What you’ll gain:
- Antivirus software and a VPN through the TotalAV bundle
- Live chat and phone lines when something breaks
- Remote sign-out of every session with Secure Me
❌ What you’ll lose:
- The free plan and every email alias
- Sharing, desktop apps, and the web vault
- Your stored TOTP codes, which need a separate app again
📋 How to switch:
- Export your vault from Proton Pass (paid plans only)
- Buy Premium, then install Total Password on browser and phone
- Run the importer, then check the result line by line
⚠️ Warning: Importing passwords into Total Password is the rough edge. In our writer’s migration, Total Password failed to bring across a handful of accounts and saved credit cards. Verify every entry before you delete the source vault.
What Our Review Didn’t Cover
Gaps worth knowing about
We looked at individual and family use, not business rollouts. Pass Essentials and Pass Professional deployments, SSO, and admin reporting were outside this comparison. We also did not test passkey handling or long-term sync reliability. Our Total Password review notes come from one writer’s migration in 2026, so your import results may differ.
Final Verdict
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| 💰 Pricing | Proton Pass |
| 🔐 Security & Transparency | Proton Pass |
| 🔑 Password Generator | Proton Pass |
| 🚨 Breach Alerts | Tie |
| 🤝 Sharing | Proton Pass |
| 💻 Platform Coverage | Proton Pass |
| 🛟 Customer Support | Total Password |
| 🧰 Bundled Extras | Total Password |
| 🏆 Overall Winner | Proton Pass |
🏆 WINNER: PROTON PASS
Proton Pass wins 5 of 8 categories.
Best for: privacy-first individuals, families who share logins, anyone who wants a free password manager that does not cap storage
These two tools are chasing different buyers. Total Password is a companion product for TotalAV customers, and it does the core job with solid data encryption and a useful Security Report.
Proton Pass is a privacy tool first. Aliases, open code, and audits matter more to its audience than antivirus bundles do.
If you already pay TotalAV, adding the vault for $49 per year is reasonable. For everyone else we recommend Proton Pass, since the free tier covers what most people need and the paid step-up is small.
More of Total Password Compared
Here is how Total Password lines up against three closer rivals:
Total Password wins on: lower entry cost when bundled with TotalAV, phone support in several regions, one-click remote logout
1Password wins on: the extra Secret Key layer beyond the master password, passphrase generation, sharing and travel features
Total Password vs Dashlane
Total Password wins on: simpler single-plan pricing, antivirus bundling, no upsell maze inside the app
Dashlane wins on: credential sharing, a full web vault, a deeper feature set overall
Total Password wins on: bundled antivirus, live phone lines, unlimited device sync on its single tier
NordPass wins on: a usable free tier, email masking, a much lower paid entry price
This video runs through more alternatives if neither fits.
More of Proton Pass Compared
And here is where Proton Pass sits against its nearest competition:
Proton Pass wins on: built-in email aliases, tighter integration with Proton Mail and Drive, Proton Sentinel login monitoring
Bitwarden wins on: cheaper paid tiers, self-hosting, a longer audit history
Proton Pass wins on: a genuine free plan, Swiss jurisdiction, alias generation at signup
1Password wins on: travel mode, richer item templates, wider business tooling
Proton Pass vs LastPass
Proton Pass wins on: a cleaner breach record, open code, unlimited devices on the free tier
LastPass wins on: emergency access for a trusted contact, longer track record, wider legacy integrations
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does Total Password cost?
Premium is $119 / Year, billed annually with no monthly option. A 30 day money back guarantee applies. Bundling with TotalAV Total Security costs $49 per year instead.
Is Proton Pass safe?
Yes. It uses AES-256 with zero knowledge encryption, the code is public, and Cure53 has audited it. Proton is based in Switzerland under strict privacy law.
Can I use Proton Pass for free?
Yes. The free tier stores unlimited logins on unlimited devices and includes ten email aliases. Dark web monitoring and vault sharing need Pass Plus at $2.99/month.
Does Total Password support password sharing?
No. Sharing is missing, unlike 1Password and Dashlane. Secure Me handles remote sign-out instead, and the vault is built for one person rather than a household.
Which one should most people pick?
Proton Pass, for the free tier, sharing, aliases, and desktop apps. Choose Total Password only if the TotalAV antivirus bundle is something you already want.
English 
Spanish 
Chinese 
German 
French 
Arabic 
Russian 
Portuguese 
Japanese 
Korean 
Italian 
Turkish 
Dutch 
Polish 
Indonesian 
Thai 
Vietnamese 