Choosing the right tool can make or break your cold email campaigns.
But with so many options out there, how do you decide which one is best for you?
In this post, we’ll take a deep dive into two popular choices: Mailshake vs Warmbox.
We’ll compare their features, pricing, and ease of use to help you determine which is the best fit for your needs.
Let’s get started!
Mailshake vs Warmbox: Overview
To give you the most accurate comparison, we’ve rigorously tested both Mailshake and Warmbox.
We’ve used both platforms to send cold emails, track results, and analyze their key features.
This hands-on experience allows us to provide an insightful look at how each tool performs in real-world scenarios.
Need a simple way to manage your sales outreach? Mailshake offers an intuitive platform to streamline your workflow and track your progress!
Pricing: It has a free plan. The premium plan starts at $49/month.
Key Features:
- Sales engagement platform
- Email automation
- Lead catcher
Ready to give Warmbox a try? Sign up for a free trial and see how it can improve your email deliverability and acceptance!
Pricing: 30% discount for 1 year on any plan. Pricing Plan Starts at $19/month.
Key Features:
- Automated Warm-up
- Email Content Analysis
- Deliverability Reports
What is Mailshake?
Want to warm up your cold emails? Mailshake is your go-to tool. It helps you create highly personalized email outreach campaigns.
Think of it as your friendly automated assistant. It helps you connect with prospects without sounding like a robot.
Mailshake focuses on building relationships and increasing engagement.
It’s known for its simple interface and powerful features.
You can easily create email sequences, track your results, and even A/B test different messages to see what works best.
Also, explore our favourite Mailshake alternatives…
Our Take
Mailshake is a good option for businesses looking to simplify their cold email outreach. However, some users may be concerned about its limited features and potential for spam flagging.
Key Benefits
- Create and send personalized email campaigns.
- Automate follow-up emails to increase engagement.
- Track your performance with detailed analytics.
- Integrates with popular CRM and sales automation tools.
- Offers a free trial to test the platform.
Pricing
Mailshake offers three paid plans:
- Starter: $25 per month per user.
- Email Outreach: $45 per month for 2 users.
- Sales Engagement: $85 per month for 5 users.
Pros
Cons
What is Warmbox?
Have you ever heard of warming up your email? It’s like stretching before you run.
Warmbox helps you slowly increase the number of emails you send.
This way, email providers like Gmail don’t think you’re a spammer. Pretty cool, right?
It’s all about getting your emails into inboxes, not spam folders.
Also, explore our favourite Warmbox alternatives…
Our Take
Warmbox is a valuable tool for improving email deliverability, but its limited features and potential performance issues may be drawbacks for some users.
Key Benefits
- Warm up the email accounts to improve deliverability.
- Automate the process of sending & receiving emails.
- Monitor your sender’s reputation and identify potential issues.
- Integrates with popular email providers.
- Offers a free trial to test the platform.
Pricing
Warmbox offers four paid plans:
- Solo: $15 per month for one inbox warm-up.
- Start-up: $69 per month for three inbox warm-up.
- Growth: $139 per month for six inbox warm-up.
- Team: Custom pricing.
Pros
Cons
Feature Comparison
Both Mailshake and Warmbox are powerful tools in the sales tech stack, but they serve different primary functions.
This comparison will help you understand their core strengths and which one is the best fit for your cold email campaigns.
1. Primary Function
- Mailshake: Mailshake is a comprehensive sales engagement platform. It is a provider automated email sequences for sending personalized cold emails across multiple channels, including email, phone, and social media. Its goal is to help sales teams manage their entire cold outreach process.
- Warmbox: Warmbox is a specialized email warm up service. Its sole purpose is to improve your inbox reputation so that your cold email campaigns land in the primary inbox and not in spam anymore. It does not send your main email campaigns, but rather prepares your cold email inbox for them.
2. Email Deliverability and Warm Up
- Mailshake: Mailshake includes an email warm up service as part of its platform. It provides an email domain setup assistant to guide you through the process, but the feature is integrated into its broader sales engagement tool.
- Warmbox: This is Warmbox’s core competency. It provides an advanced warm up process that uses AI to generate positive interactions and mimic human behavior. It offers a customizable warm up schedule and ensures your emails are ready for serious cold email outreach.
3. Data Finder and Lead Generation
- Mailshake: Mailshake has a data finder feature that helps you find prospects. mailshake’s data finder allows sales reps to search for contacts by various filters, helping them build lists of qualified leads directly within the platform.
- Warmbox: Warmbox does not have a data finder. It is not a lead generation tool. The platform focuses exclusively on the deliverability of your email marketing efforts after you have already sourced your list of contacts.
4. Cold Outreach and Automation
- Mailshake: As a full sales engagement platform, Mailshake is built for cold email outreach. It is a provider automated email sequences with conditional logic, A/B testing, and unlimited free dialer minutes to manage a complete cold outreach strategy.
- Warmbox: Warmbox is not an outreach tool. It does not send your cold email campaigns. Its automation is focused on the warm up process itself, sending warm up emails and generate positive interactions in the background to build inbox reputation.
5. Personalization
- Mailshake: Mailshake is designed to help sales reps send personalized cold emails at scale. It offers custom fields, templates, and AI-powered writing tools to craft personalized cold emails that increase engagement.
- Warmbox: Warmbox is not an outreach tool, so it doesn’t offer personalization features for your cold email campaigns. The warm up emails it sends are designed to be generic and natural-looking to generate positive interactions.
6. Multichannel Capabilities
- Mailshake: Mailshake is a multi-channel platform. It supports email, phone with unlimited free dialer minutes, and even linkedin automation with a Chrome extension. This allows sales teams to engage with prospects on multiple fronts.
- Warmbox: Warmbox is a single-channel tool. Its focus is entirely on email. It does not have linkedin automation or a dialer, as it is not a sales engagement platform.
7. User Experience and Ease of Use
- Mailshake: Mailshake has a user-friendly interface that helps sales teams quickly set up email campaigns. The process is straightforward, but some users can have trouble uploading leads correctly or managing the technical setup.
- Warmbox: Warmbox is also very easy to use, with a simple setup process. Its dashboard provides detailed analytics on your inbox reputation, but its workflow is entirely separate from cold email outreach.
8. Integrations
- Mailshake: Mailshake integrates with all major CRMs and other email service providers. This allows it to work with your existing tools, making it a flexible sales engagement platform for sales teams.
- Warmbox: Warmbox can be connected to multiple email providers like Gmail and Outlook. It’s designed to be used in conjunction with other cold email software, not as a standalone sales engagement tool.
9. Analytics and Reporting
- Mailshake: Mailshake provides detailed analytics on cold email campaigns, including open rates, click-through rates, and reply rates, helping sales teams optimize their cold outreach.
- Warmbox: Warmbox’s detailed analytics are focused on inbox reputation and deliverability. It shows you how your warm up process is performing, providing an inbox health score and a breakdown of where your warm up emails are landing.
10. Pricing Model
- Mailshake: Mailshake offers different tiers based on the number of users and features, with plans specifically for cold email campaigns and sales engagement.
- Warmbox: Warmbox’s pricing is based on the number of mailboxes you want to warm up. Its plans are focused solely on the email warm up service, making it a more affordable solution if that’s your only need.
11. Customer Support
- Mailshake: Mailshake provides dedicated customer support and resources to help sales teams with their cold email outreach and platform usage.
- Warmbox: The Warmbox team is known for its excellent support, especially with technical issues related to the warm up process and email deliverability, helping users ensure their emails don’t land in spam anymore.
What to Look For When Choosing a Cold Email Tool?
- Deliverability: This is non-negotiable. Your tool should prioritize getting your emails into the inbox. Look for features like email warm-up, sender reputation management, and spam testing.
- Ease of Use: You don’t want to spend hours figuring out how to use the software. Choose a tool with an intuitive interface & straightforward navigation.
- Integrations: Does the tool integrate with the existing CRM, email provider, or other essential business tools? Seamless integrations can save you time and streamline your workflow.
- Support: Problems happen. Ensure the tool offers reliable customer support via email, chat, or phone.
- Pricing: Consider your budget and the number of emails you must send. Look for a tool that offers flexible pricing to match your needs.
- Unique Features: Some tools offer unique features, such as AI personalization, advanced analytics, or multi-channel outreach. Consider which features are most important to your cold email strategy.
- Trial Period: Most reputable tools offer a free trial or demo. Take advantage of this to test the software and see if it suits you.
Final Verdict (Our Pick)
For a dedicated email warm-up tool in 2025, Warmbox emerges as the winner.
Its advanced features, like real email conversations and a focus on building trust with email providers, give it an edge in warming up your inbox and ensuring your emails land safely.
While Mailshake offers a solid platform with many features, Warmbox excels specifically at improving deliverability and preventing your messages from landing in spam.
We’ve spent countless hours testing and analyzing both platforms, sending emails and scrutinizing results.
With this hands-on experience, we’re confident in recommending Warmbox as the superior choice for maximizing your email warm-up and ensuring your messages reach the intended recipients.
Whether you’re managing many emails or just starting with a new account, Warmbox can significantly improve your email warmup process and overall deliverability.
More of Mailshake
Here’s a comparison of Mailshake with its alternatives:
- Mailshake vs Snov IO: Mailshake focuses on streamlined email outreach and AI-powered writing. Snov IO is stronger in email finding, verification, and a broader sales suite.
- Mailshake vs Instantly: Mailshake offers more customization and comprehensive analytics for email campaigns. Instantly excels in automation, engagement, and rapid campaign setup.
- Mailshake vs Apollo: Mailshake provides user-friendly personalized email outreach. Apollo offers a vast B2B contact database and comprehensive sales intelligence.
- Mailshake vs Hunter IO: Mailshake specializes in email campaign automation and follow-ups. Hunter IO is primarily an email finder and verifier, with basic sending.
- Mailshake vs Reply IO: Mailshake focuses on efficient email automation and A/B testing. Reply IO provides robust multi-channel outreach, including LinkedIn and calls.
- Mailshake vs UpLead: Mailshake optimizes email outreach automation and deliverability. UpLead is a powerful source for high-quality, verified B2B lead data.
- Mailshake vs Lemlist: Mailshake offers straightforward, affordable email campaigns. Lemlist excels in hyper-personalization with rich media and advanced multi-channel features.
- Mailshake vs Woodpecker: Mailshake leads with AI-driven email and personalization. Woodpecker focuses on human-like sending patterns and strong email deliverability.
- Mailshake vs Smartlead: Mailshake simplifies personalized email campaigns. Smartlead offers unlimited mailboxes, advanced AI warm-ups, and multi-channel scaling.
- Mailshake vs Saleshandy: Mailshake handles varied outreach channels with automation. Saleshandy specializes in cold emailing with deliverability features and a lead finder.
- Mailshake vs Klenty: Mailshake is user-friendly for email automation beginners. Klenty provides a comprehensive sales engagement platform with deeper CRM integration.
- Mailshake vs Warmbox: Mailshake includes email warm-up within its outreach platform. Warmbox is a dedicated, specialized tool for robust email warm-up and deliverability.
- Mailshake vs Maildoso: Mailshake provides integrated email warm-up and campaign management, while Maildoso offers a robust multi-channel experience and email hosting services.
- Mailshake vs Manyreach: Mailshake focuses on personalized cold email automation. Manyreach offers cost-effective scalability with unlimited prospects and a unified inbox.
- Mailshake vs Warmy: Mailshake includes email warm-up as part of its outreach. Warmy is a dedicated email deliverability tool, specializing in advanced warm-up processes.
More of Warmbox
Here’s a comparison of Warmbox with its alternatives, highlighting their unique strengths:
- Warmbox vs Snov IO: Warmbox ensures email deliverability and sender reputation. Snov IO offers a broader suite for lead generation, verification, and multi-channel campaigns.
- Warmbox vs Instantly: Warmbox is a specialized email warm-up tool. Instantly is an all-in-one cold email outreach platform, including its warm-up feature.
- Warmbox vs Apollo: Warmbox solely focuses on improving email deliverability through warming. Apollo is a comprehensive sales intelligence and engagement platform with lead finding.
- Warmbox vs Hunter IO: Warmbox is an email warm-up tool for inbox placement. Hunter IO primarily finds and verifies email addresses and offers basic campaigns.
- Warmbox vs Reply IO: Warmbox is a dedicated email warm-up solution. Reply IO is a multi-channel sales engagement platform with broader automation features.
- Warmbox vs UpLead: Warmbox enhances email deliverability for outbound efforts. UpLead is a lead generation platform that provides high-quality, verified B2B contact data.
- Warmbox vs Mailshake: Warmbox is a specialized email warm-up service. Mailshake provides an email outreach platform with campaign management and some warm-up capabilities.
- Warmbox vs Lemlist: Warmbox is a standalone email warm-up tool. Lemlist offers a more comprehensive outreach platform with advanced personalization and its warm-up (Lemwarm).
- Warmbox vs Woodpecker: Warmbox focuses on automated email warm-up for deliverability. Woodpecker is a cold email automation platform that prioritizes human-like sending and deliverability.
- Warmbox vs Smartlead: Warmbox ensures email deliverability through dedicated warming. Smartlead is a comprehensive cold email outreach platform, including its warm-up.
- Warmbox vs Saleshandy: Warmbox specializes in email warm-up to boost inbox placement. Saleshandy offers a sales engagement platform with email tracking and warm-up features.
- Warmbox vs Klenty: Warmbox is a dedicated email warm-up service. Klenty is a sales engagement platform that automates outreach sequences and integrates with CRMs.
- Warmbox vs Maildoso: Warmbox is a dedicated email warm-up tool with detailed monitoring. Maildoso also offers warm-up, along with a master inbox and custom domains.
- Warmbox vs Manyreach: Warmbox ensures email deliverability through warming. Manyreach is a comprehensive cold outreach platform with unlimited prospects and diverse features.
- Warmbox vs Warmy: Both Warmbox and Warmy are dedicated email warm-up services. They primarily differ in network size, pricing structures, and specific advanced features for deliverability.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best email warm-up tool for a new email account?
For a new email account, Warmbox is a great choice. Its focus on simulating real email conversations and building trust with email providers helps establish a positive sender reputation from the start. This is crucial for a new email account to avoid landing in spam and achieve good deliverability.
Can I use Mailshake and Warmbox together?
Yes, you can! While Mailshake offers its own warm-up features, you can also integrate Warmbox to further boost your deliverability. Mailshake can help you craft effective email content and manage your campaigns, while Warmbox focuses on warming up your inbox and improving your sender reputation.
How can I improve my email deliverability with these tools?
Both Mailshake and Warmbox offer features to improve your email deliverability. Mailshake provides tools to monitor your sender reputation and offers best practices for email content. Warmbox focuses on warming up your inbox and establishing a positive email reputation through simulated conversations and gradual sending volume increases.
Do I need an email warm-up tool if I’m only sending a few emails?
Even with low sending volumes, an email warm-up tool can be beneficial. It helps establish your sender reputation and ensures your emails land in the inbox, even if you’re not sending many emails. This is especially important for new email accounts or those with a history of low engagement.
What’s the difference between an email warm-up tool and an email marketing platform?
An email warm-up tool like Warmbox focuses specifically on improving deliverability by warming up your inbox and building your sender reputation. Email marketing platforms like Mailshake offer broader features like campaign management, automation, and analytics, often including warm-up features as part of their service.
English 
Spanish