⚡ Quick Verdict:
- Harga: Proton VPN starts at $2.99/mo vs Private Internet Access at $2.03/mo
- Cocok untuk: Proton VPN for privacy-first users, PIA for budget shoppers who want unlimited connections
- Perbedaan utama: Proton VPN is based in Switzerland with Secure Core servers. PIA is US-based but has a court-proven no-logs record.
- Our pick: Proton VPN for most users — stronger privacy protections and a better free plan
Proton VPN and Private Internet Access are two of the most popular VPN companies in 2026.
One is built in Switzerland with open-source apps.
The other costs less and connects unlimited devices.
Picking the right VPN service depends on what matters most to you.
This comparison breaks down pricing, features, and privacy so you can decide.
Tinjau
This ProtonVPN vs Private Internet Access comparison covers pricing, keamanan features, and how each VPN keeps your data private to protect user privacy.
We also look at who each VPN company and VPN provider works best for.
Our sources include published specs, official documentation, and user reviews.
By the end, you’ll know which VPN fits your needs.
Apa itu Proton VPN?
Proton VPN is a privacy-focused VPN service built by the team behind Proton Mail.
It is based in Switzerland, outside the reach of Five Eyes surveillance alliances.
The Proton VPN app is open-source, so anyone can inspect the code.
Proton VPN offers a free plan with unlimited bandwidth and no ads. Does Proton VPN work for streaming? Yes, on paid plans.
Proton VPN
Swiss-based VPN with Secure Core servers and a free tier. All apps are open-source and independently audited.
Harga Proton VPN
Berikut biaya Proton VPN pada tahun 2026.
| Rencana | Harga | Terbaik untuk |
|---|---|---|
| Bebas | $0,00/bulan | Penjelajahan dasar dan privasi |
| Plus | $2,99/bulan | Akses VPN penuh dengan semua fitur. |
| Tak terbatas | $7,99/bulan | VPN plus Proton Mail, Drive, dan Pass |
Pricing verified May 2026.
Uji coba gratis: No free trial, but the free plan lets you test core features with no time limit.
Garansi uang kembali: Garansi pengembalian uang 30 hari untuk semua paket berbayar.
📌 Catatan: The free plan includes unlimited bandwidth but limits you to one device and servers in three countries. Compared to other free VPNs, it stands out because most free VPNs have data caps or show ads. The Plus plan unlocks all servers in 112+ countries and up to 10 device connections.
⚠️ Peringatan: After your initial discounted term ends, Proton VPN renews at the standard rate of $9.99/month. Turn off auto-renewal in your account settings to avoid the price jump.
Manfaat Utama Proton VPN
Here’s what makes Proton VPN worth considering:
- Hukum Privasi Swiss: Proton VPN is based in Switzerland. The country has no mandatory data retention laws and sits outside Five Eyes alliances.
- Free VPN With No Ads: The free version has no data caps, no ads, and no speed throttling. It covers basic privacy needs without spending a cent.
- Server Inti yang Aman: Your internet traffic routes through privacy-friendly countries before reaching the endpoint server. This adds a second layer of encryption to your VPN tunnel.
- Aplikasi Sumber Terbuka: All Proton VPN apps are open-source and independently audited. Anyone can check the code for security flaws.
- Pemblokir Iklan NetShield: Memblokir iklan, pelacak, dan malware di tingkat DNS. Ini mempercepat penjelajahan dan melindungi privasi Anda.
- Akselerator VPN: A built-in speed booster that uses advanced networking to reduce latency and protect your internet speeds on long-distance connections.
- Proton Suite: The Unlimited plan bundles all Proton apps — Proton Mail, Proton Drive, Proton Calendar, and Proton Pass — with the VPN service.
What Our Team Noticed
Kita penulis signed up for Proton VPN and spent several days exploring the platform. Here’s what stood out:
Kelebihan & Kekurangan Proton VPN
✅ Kelebihan
- Paket gratis dengan bandwidth tak terbatas dan tanpa iklan.
- Yurisdiksi Swiss di luar aliansi pengawasan
- All apps are open-source and independently audited
- Secure Core double VPN routing for extra protection
- Includes Tor over VPN on dedicated Tor servers for Tor network access
❌ Kekurangan
- Free plan limited to one device and three server locations
- No dedicated IP address option available
- Slower customer support compared to some VPN providers
- Renewal prices jump significantly after initial term
Apa itu Akses Internet Pribadi?
Private Internet Access VPN is a budget-friendly VPN service owned by Kape Technologies.
PIA covers over 91 countries with more than 35,000 VPN servers. PIA offers both WireGuard and OpenVPN protocol support.
It allows unlimited simultaneous connections on a single account.
PIA has a strict no logs policy that has been verified by Deloitte audits and confirmed in two court cases.
Akses Internet Pribadi
Affordable VPN with 35,000+ servers and unlimited device connections. Court-proven no-logs policy backed by Deloitte audits.
Harga Akses Internet Pribadi
Berikut perkiraan biaya Akses Internet Pribadi pada tahun 2026.
| Rencana | Harga | Terbaik untuk |
|---|---|---|
| 2 Tahun + 4 Bulan | $2,03/bulan | Nilai terbaik untuk pengguna jangka panjang |
| 6 Bulan | $7,50/bulan | Komitmen jangka menengah |
| 1 Bulan | $11,99/bulan | Jangka pendek atau untuk menguji layanan |
Pricing verified May 2026.
Uji coba gratis: Tidak ada paket gratis atau uji coba gratis yang tersedia.
Garansi uang kembali: Garansi uang kembali 30 hari untuk semua paket.
📌 Catatan: PIA does not increase subscription prices upon renewal. This is rare among most VPN providers and other VPN services. All plans include the same features and unlimited device connections.
⚠️ Peringatan: PIA has no free plan. If you want to test a VPN without paying, Proton VPN’s free tier is a better starting point. PIA’s monthly plan at $11.99 is above the industry average.
Manfaat Utama Akses Internet Pribadi
Here’s what makes Private Internet Access worth considering:
- Koneksi Tanpa Batas: Connect every device you own at once. No limits on simultaneous connections, which is rare among VPN services.
- Jaringan Server Besar-besaran: Over 35,000 servers spread across 91 countries. How many servers does PIA have in the US? PIA covers all 50 US states for fast domestic connections.
- Privasi yang Terbukti di Pengadilan: PIA’s no-logs policy has been tested in two real court cases. Both times, PIA had zero user data to hand over.
- Pemblokir Iklan MACE: Blocks ads, trackers, and malware at the DNS level. Private Internet Access makes it work across all your devices without extra software.
- Opsi IP Khusus: You can add a dedicated IP address for an extra fee. This helps with services that block shared VPN IP addresses.
- Penerusan Port: Built-in port forwarding for faster torrenting and incoming connections. This is a must-have for power users.
What Our Team Noticed
Our writer signed up for Private Internet Access and spent time using the PIA app on desktop and mobile. Here’s what stood out:
Keuntungan & Kerugian Akses Internet Pribadi
✅ Kelebihan
- Koneksi simultan tanpa batas di semua paket
- No price increases on renewal unlike most VPN companies
- Jaringan server terbesar dengan lebih dari 35.000 server di 91 negara.
- Built-in port forwarding for torrenting and P2P
- Open-source apps with Deloitte-audited no-logs policy
❌ Kekurangan
- Based in the US, a Five Eyes member country
- Tidak ada paket gratis yang tersedia untuk pengujian.
- Download speeds inconsistent on distant servers
- Streaming only works on dedicated streaming optimized servers
Perbandingan Fitur
Let’s compare Proton VPN and Private Internet Access across the features that matter most for your internet connection and privacy.
| Fitur | Proton VPN | Akses Internet Pribadi |
|---|---|---|
| Harga Mulai | $2,99/bulan | $2,03/bulan |
| Paket Gratis | ✅ | ❌ |
| Jumlah Server | Lebih dari 8.600 orang di 112 negara | Lebih dari 35.000 orang di 91 negara |
| Koneksi Serentak | 10 perangkat | Tak terbatas |
| Matikan Switch | ✅ | ✅ |
| Pecah Tunneling | ✅ | ✅ |
| VPN Ganda / Multi-Hop | ✅ (Secure Core) | ✅ (Multi-Hop) |
| IP yang telah ditentukan | ❌ | ✅ (tambahan) |
| Ad Blocker | ✅ (NetShield) | ✅ (MACE) |
| Terbaik untuk | Pengguna yang mengutamakan privasi | Budget and torrent users |
1. Privasi dan Yurisdiksi
Proton VPN: Based in Switzerland, which has strict privacy laws and no mandatory data retention. Switzerland is not part of the Five Eyes, Nine Eyes, or Fourteen Eyes surveillance alliances. Proton VPN passed an independent third-party audit confirming its strict no-logs policy. All Proton apps are open-source for full transparency.
Internet Swasta Akses: Based in the United States, a founding Five Eyes member. However, PIA’s no-logs policy has been court-tested twice. In both cases, PIA had no user data to provide. Deloitte has also independently audited PIA’s claims. PIA’s apps are open-source as well.
2. Jaringan Server
Proton VPN: Proton VPN servers number over 8,600 spread across 112 countries. Proton VPN covers more countries than PIA, which helps if you need server locations in less common regions. All servers run on RAM only, meaning data is wiped on every reboot.
Internet Swasta Akses: PIA’s servers number over 35,000 in 91 countries. That’s a much larger fleet, including some virtual servers, which can mean less crowding during peak hours. PIA also has servers in all 50 US states, making it a strong pick for US-based VPN users who want nearby connections.
3. Encryption and VPN Protocols
Proton VPN: Creates an encrypted VPN tunnel using AES-256 encryption with Perfect Forward Secrecy. Every encrypted tunnel is protected by forward secrecy. Supports OpenVPN, IKEv2, WireGuard, and a proprietary Stealth protocol. The Stealth protocol helps bypass VPN blocks and ISP throttling in restrictive countries by disguising VPN traffic as normal internet traffic.
Internet Swasta Akses: Offers AES-256 encryption via the OpenVPN protocol and ChaCha20 with WireGuard. PIA lets you toggle between AES-128 and AES-256, which is useful if you want faster download speeds and better connection speeds with slightly lighter encryption. PIA also supports the SHA2 hashing algorithm and RSA-4096 handshake.
4. Kill Switch and DNS Leak Protection
Proton VPN: Includes a kill switch that blocks all internet traffic if your VPN connection drops. Proton VPN also provides DNS leak protection to stop your internet service provider from seeing your DNS requests. A dns leak test confirms no leaks on any platform.
Internet Swasta Akses: PIA offers two types of kill switches on Windows and macOS: a regular kill switch and an advanced version. The advanced version blocks internet traffic even when PIA is turned off. PIA also prevents DNS leaks and IPv6 leaks. PIA’s split tunneling lets you exclude specific apps, browser traffic, and IP addresses from the VPN tunnel.
5. Secure Core vs Multi-Hop
Proton VPN: Secure Core routes your internet traffic through servers in privacy-friendly countries like Switzerland, Iceland, or Sweden before reaching the endpoint server. This double VPN approach means even if someone compromises the exit server, they still cannot trace your actual IP address or real IP address back to you.
Internet Swasta Akses: PIA supports multi-hop connections that route traffic through two VPN servers. This provides a similar double VPN effect. However, PIA does not guarantee that one hop goes through a privacy-friendly jurisdiction like Proton VPN’s Secure Core does.
6. Streaming dan Akses Konten
Proton VPN: Proton VPN supports streaming from Netflix, BBC iPlayer, Amazon Prime Video, and other services. Streaming access is guaranteed on paid plans only. The free plan does not block streaming sites, but it can’t guarantee access either.
Internet Swasta Akses: PIA has streaming optimized servers in 11 countries that can unblock Netflix, Disney+, BBC iPlayer, and more. However, regular PIA servers usually get blocked. Streaming platforms keep blocking access from shared VPN IP addresses. You need to use the dedicated streaming servers for consistent access to unblocking streaming content.
7. Torrenting dan P2P
Proton VPN: Allows torrenting on dedicated servers designed for P2P file sharing. Proton VPN also offers port forwarding on paid plans, which improves download speeds for torrenting. The free plan does not support P2P.
Internet Swasta Akses: PIA allows torrenting on all servers, not just dedicated ones. Port forwarding is built-in and easy to activate. For power users who torrent regularly, PIA’s wider server compatibility and built-in port forwarding give it an edge for P2P file sharing.
8. Koneksi Perangkat
Proton VPN: Allows up to 10 simultaneous VPN connections on paid plans. This covers most households. The free plan is limited to one device. Proton VPN works on Windows, Mac, iOS, Android, Linux, Android TV, and Apple TV. The Android app and Windows app are available from the Apple App Store and Google Play.
Internet Swasta Akses: PIA offers unlimited simultaneous connections. You can protect all your devices, all the mobile devices in your household, and your router without worrying about limits. PIA also has VPN apps for Windows, Mac, iOS, Android, and Linux. Any Linux user can install the Linux app or command line app. PIA also offers browser extensions for Chrome, Firefox, and Opera.
9. Ad and Tracker Blocking
Proton VPN: NetShield blocks ads, trackers, and malware at the DNS level. It runs on the VPN server side, so it works on all your devices. NetShield is only available on paid plans.
Internet Swasta Akses: MACE is PIA’s built-in ad and tracker blocker. It works through PIA’s own DNS servers at the DNS level and blocks malware domains. MACE is available on all plans and works across all your devices without extra setup.
10. Penetapan Harga dan Biaya
| Rencana | Proton VPN | Akses Internet Pribadi |
|---|---|---|
| Bebas | $0,00/bulan | ❌ Tidak ada paket gratis |
| Pembayaran Termurah | $2,99/bulan (2 tahun) | $2,03/bulan (2 tahun + 4 bulan) |
| Tingkat Menengah | $7,99/bulan (Tidak terbatas) | $7,50/bulan (6 bulan) |
| Monthly | $9,99/bulan (Plus) | $11,99/bulan |
Proton VPN: Slightly more expensive on long-term plans than PIA. However, Proton VPN’s free tier is a major advantage. The Unlimited plan at $7.99/month adds Proton Mail, Drive, Calendar, and Pass. After the initial term, Proton VPN renews at the standard $9.99/month rate.
Internet Swasta Akses: PIA’s 2-year plan at $2.03/month makes it a cheap VPN compared to any premium VPN on the market. It is far from an expensive VPN. PIA does not increase prices on renewal. Check Private Internet Access deals for the latest discounts. However, the monthly plan at $11.99 is pricier than Proton VPN’s $9.99 monthly option. No free tier means you pay from day one.
Skenario yang Berbeda
| Jika Anda Membutuhkan… | Memilih | Mengapa |
|---|---|---|
| Anggaran ketat | PIA | $2.03/mo on long-term plan |
| Opsi VPN gratis | Proton VPN | Paket gratis tanpa batasan data |
| Privasi maksimal | Proton VPN | Yurisdiksi Swiss, Secure Core |
| Perangkat tak terbatas | PIA | No limit on connections |
| Torrenting focus | PIA | Semua server mendukung P2P |
| Akses streaming | Proton VPN | Pembukaan blokir yang lebih andal |
💰 Anggaran Anda
PIA costs less on long-term plans at $2.03/month. But if you want to try a VPN without paying anything, Proton VPN’s free version is the better starting point.
🔌 Susunan Teknologi Anda
Both VPN services work on Windows, Mac, iOS, Android, and Linux. PIA adds browser extensions for Chrome, Firefox, and Opera. Proton VPN connects to the broader Proton suite with Mail, Drive, and Calendar.
🛡️ Kebutuhan Privasi Anda
If privacy is your top concern, Proton VPN’s Swiss jurisdiction and Secure Core servers are hard to beat. PIA’s US location is a drawback, but its court-tested no-logs record is solid proof that it keeps no identifying data.
🎓 Tingkat Pengalaman Anda
Proton VPN easy setup makes it great for beginners. The interface is clean and connections are simple. PIA offers more customization, which is better for users who want to tweak encryption levels and VPN protocols.
🆓 Uji Coba dan Demo Gratis
Proton VPN has a free plan you can use forever. PIA offers a 30-day money-back guarantee instead. Both let you test the service, but Proton VPN’s free version has no deadline.
🛟 Opsi Dukungan
PIA offers 24/7 live chat support for paying customers. Proton VPN relies mainly on email support, which is slower than most other VPN providers. If fast customer support matters to you, PIA has the advantage.
Panduan Pengalihan
Sudah menggunakan salah satu alat ini? Berikut yang dapat Anda harapkan jika Anda beralih.
🔄 Switching from Proton VPN to Private Internet Access?
✅ Apa yang akan Anda peroleh:
- Koneksi perangkat tak terbatas, bukan 10.
- Lower long-term pricing at $2.03/month
- Dedicated IP address option for static needs
❌ Apa yang akan Anda rugikan:
- Swiss privacy jurisdiction and Secure Core servers
- Paket VPN gratis dengan bandwidth tak terbatas
- Access to the Proton suite (Mail, Drive, Pass)
📋 Cara beralih:
- Cancel your Proton VPN subscription from your account settings
- Sign up for PIA and download the PIA app on your devices
- Uninstall Proton VPN and connect through PIA
🔄 Switching from Private Internet Access to Proton VPN?
✅ Apa yang akan Anda peroleh:
- Swiss-based privacy with Secure Core double VPN
- Free plan available if you want to downgrade later
- Access to Proton Mail, Drive, and Calendar on the Unlimited plan
❌ Apa yang akan Anda rugikan:
- Unlimited device connections (capped at 10 on Proton VPN)
- Dedicated IP address option
- Stable renewal pricing (Proton VPN renewal price increases)
📋 Cara beralih:
- Batalkan langganan PIA Anda dan minta pengembalian dana jika dalam waktu 30 hari
- Create a Proton account and choose your plan
- Download the Proton VPN app and uninstall PIA
What Our Review Didn’t Cover
This comparison focused on individual users and small households. We didn’t test enterprise features, team management, or VPN router configurations. Detailed speed tests and online gaming performance were not included. If you’re in a country with heavy internet censorship, your experience may differ from what we’ve described here. Our observations are based on the May 2026 versions of both apps.
Keputusan Akhir
| Kategori | Pemenang |
|---|---|
| 💰 Harga | Akses Internet Pribadi |
| 🛡️ Privasi & Yurisdiksi | Proton VPN |
| 🌐 Jaringan Server | Akses Internet Pribadi |
| 🔒 Fitur Keamanan | Proton VPN |
| 📺 Streaming | Proton VPN |
| 📥 Torrenting | Akses Internet Pribadi |
| 👶 Kemudahan Penggunaan | Proton VPN |
| 🏆 Pemenang Keseluruhan | Proton VPN |
🏆 PEMENANG: Proton VPN
Proton VPN wins 4 out of 7 categories.
Cocok untuk: Privacy-conscious users, free VPN seekers, streaming, and beginners who want a simple secure VPN.
Proton VPN and Private Internet Access take different approaches to online privacy. Both are solid VPN choices, though neither qualifies as a top tier VPN in every category. Proton VPN’s Swiss jurisdiction, Secure Core servers, and free plan make it the stronger choice for most VPN users. PIA fights back with cheaper long-term pricing, unlimited connections, and a larger server network.
If you need an affordable VPN for a large household, PIA is the smart pick. But if privacy is your top concern, Proton VPN earns the win.
Perbandingan Lebih Lanjut tentang Proton VPN
Here’s how Proton VPN stacks up against other VPN providers:
Proton VPN vs NordVPN
Proton VPN unggul dalam hal: Swiss privacy laws, open-source code, free plan with no data caps
NordVPN unggul dalam hal: Faster download speeds, more specialty servers, Threat Protection malware scanner
Proton VPN vs ExpressVPN
Proton VPN unggul dalam hal: Lower price on 2-year plans, free tier available, Secure Core double VPN routing
ExpressVPN unggul dalam hal: Faster speeds on distant servers, easier router setup, better live chat support
Proton VPN vs Surfshark
Proton VPN unggul dalam hal: Stronger jurisdiction for privacy, audited open-source apps, Tor over VPN support
Surfshark menang dalam hal: Cheaper long-term pricing, unlimited device connections, CleanWeb ad blocker
Proton VPN vs CyberGhost
Proton VPN unggul dalam hal: Privacy jurisdiction, open-source transparency, no-logs verified by independent audit
CyberGhost menang dalam hal: Larger server count, dedicated streaming profiles, longer 45-day refund policy
Lebih Banyak Tentang Akses Internet Pribadi Dibandingkan
Here’s how Private Internet Access stacks up against other VPN providers:
Private Internet Access vs NordVPN
PIA menang dalam hal: Cheaper long-term pricing, unlimited device connections, no price increases on renewal
NordVPN unggul dalam hal: Faster overall speeds, better streaming support, Dark Web Monitor feature
Private Internet Access vs Surfshark
PIA menang dalam hal: Court-proven no-logs record, servers in all 50 US states, dedicated IP option
Surfshark menang dalam hal: Slightly cheaper on the longest plan, better streaming unblocking, GPS spoofing on Android
Private Internet Access vs CyberGhost
PIA menang dalam hal: Open-source apps, lower monthly cost on long-term deals, stable renewal pricing
CyberGhost menang dalam hal: Dedicated streaming and gaming servers, 45-day money-back guarantee, NoSpy servers in Romania
Pertanyaan Yang Sering Muncul
Apakah Proton VPN aman digunakan?
Yes. The service is based in Switzerland and follows a strict no-logs policy verified by independent audits. All apps are open-source, meaning anyone can inspect the code for vulnerabilities.
Apakah Private Internet Access merupakan VPN yang sah?
Yes. PIA has proven its no-logs policy in two court cases where it had zero user data to provide. Deloitte has also audited its privacy practices. It is a legitimate VPN provider with a long track record.
Apakah Proton VPN benar-benar gratis?
Yes, there is a free version with unlimited bandwidth and no ads. The free tier limits you to one device and servers in three countries. You can use it forever without paying.
Bisakah saya menggunakan PIA VPN secara gratis?
No. PIA does not offer a free plan. However, it has a 30-day money-back guarantee. You can test the full service and request a refund if you’re not satisfied.
Which is better for privacy, Proton VPN or PIA?
Proton VPN has the edge on privacy. Its Swiss jurisdiction keeps it outside surveillance alliances. PIA is based in the US, but its court-tested no-logs record makes it a quality VPN. Both are good choices, but Proton VPN’s location gives it a structural advantage.
English 
Spanish 
Chinese 
German 
French 
Arabic 
Russian 
Portuguese 
Japanese 
Korean 
Italian 
Turkish 
Dutch 
Polish 
Indonesian 
Thai 
Vietnamese 