⚡ Kesimpulan Singkat:
- Harga: Tailscale starts free (Personal Plus is $5/month). McAfee VPN starts at $39.99/yr.
- Cocok untuk: Tailscale for linking your own devices. McAfee VPN for basic public Wi-Fi protection.
- Perbedaan utama: Tailscale connects devices directly. McAfee routes traffic through its own servers.
- Pilihan kami: Tailscale for most readers. It’s free, fast, and keeps traffic off its servers.
McAfee VPN and Tailscale both call themselves VPNs.
Namun, mereka memecahkan masalah yang sangat berbeda.
McAfee Safe Connect VPN hides your browsing on public Wi-Fi.
Tailscale links your own devices into one private network.
Pick the wrong one, and you pay for features you’ll never use.
Here’s how they compare on privacy, speed, price, and daily use.
Tinjau
This McAfee VPN vs Tailscale comparison covers pricing, privacy, speed, keamanan features, and device support.
Kita penulis spent hands-on time with Tailscale directly.
Observations on McAfee come from its documentation, published speed tests, and independent reviews.
By the end, you’ll know which tool fits your online security needs.
Apa itu Tailscale?
Tailscale adalah VPN mesh zero-trust yang dibangun di atas protokol WireGuard.
It’s made for secure networking between computers, phones, and servers you control.
Those devices join one private network called a tailnet.
Each device gets a unique 100.x.y.z IP address for stable connections.
Your network traffic flows directly between devices, not through Tailscale’s servers.
It’s basically a private LAN that follows you everywhere.
This tutorial walks through the full setup process.
Skala ekor
Connect all your own devices into one encrypted network. No port forwarding or firewall rules needed. The free plan covers up to 100 devices.
Penentuan Harga Skala Ekor
Tailscale keeps personal pricing simple. Here’s what each plan costs.
| Rencana | Harga | Terbaik untuk |
|---|---|---|
| Pribadi | Gratis Selamanya $0 | Individual users, home labs, and hobby projects |
| Personal Plus | $5/per bulan | Households or small groups that need more users |
Pricing verified September 2026.
Uji coba gratis: The Personal plan is free forever, so you can test everything first. Sign up with a custom company domain, and you get a 14-day Enterprise trial.
Garansi uang kembali: None is advertised. The free plan makes one mostly unnecessary.
📌 Catatan: The free plan caps you at three users. It still allows up to 100 devices. It even lets you block individual users from specific resources, which Starter lacks.
⚠️ Price check: Tailscale’s bisnis pages also list a Starter tier at $6 per user monthly. Each Starter user adds 10 devices. Premium runs $18 per user with 20 devices each and priority support. Confirm current rates on the pricing page.
Manfaat Utama Tailscale
Here’s what makes Tailscale worth a look:
- Koneksi Langsung: Devices talk through end-to-end WireGuard tunnels. Nothing passes through a central VPN server.
- Zero-Trust Access: Permissions follow user identity, not IP addresses. You decide who reaches which resources.
- Easy Sign-In: Log in with single sign-on through 100+ identity providers. No new passwords to manage.
- MagicDNS: Reach devices by name instead of numbers. Every device sees other clients on the tailnet by name.
- Router Subnet: Reach printers and gear that can’t run the Tailscale client.
- Node Keluar: Route internet traffic through a trusted device. It then works like a traditional VPN.
Apa yang Tim Kami Amati
Our writer used Tailscale for everyday akses jarak jauh across several personal devices. Here’s what stood out from that hands-on time:
Kelebihan & Kekurangan Tailscale
✅ Kelebihan
- Free Personal plan covers 3 users and up to 100 devices
- Direct WireGuard connections skip central VPN servers
- Access rules follow user identity, not IP addresses
- Apps for Linux, macOS, Windows, iOS, Android, and Apple TV
❌ Kekurangan
- No public server network for streaming or geo-unblocking
- Support is mostly email during bisnis jam
- Access control policies take time to learn
Apa itu McAfee VPN?
McAfee VPN, also sold as McAfee Safe Connect, is a consumer VPN service.
It comes bundled with McAfee’s antivirus and identity protection plans.
One tap starts a VPN connection that encrypts traffic with AES-256.
It hides your IP address and geo location information from the sites you visit.
It also switches on by itself when you join unsecured public Wi-Fi.
McAfee is based in the United States, which shapes its data disclosure rules.
It targets casual VPN users who want simple online activity protection.
This video review shows the app in action.
VPN McAfee
Basic VPN protection bundled with antivirus. It turns on automatically on risky Wi-Fi. Test it with a 30-day refund window.
Harga VPN McAfee
McAfee sells its VPN inside security bundles. Here are the plans.
| Rencana | Harga | Terbaik untuk |
|---|---|---|
| Penting | $39,99/tahun | Basic antivirus plus VPN coverage |
| Individu Tingkat Lanjut | $89,99/tahun | Single users who want identity tools |
| Keluarga Tingkat Lanjut | $119,99/tahun | Households covering several people |
Pricing verified September 2026.
Uji coba gratis: No free plan is listed. The refund window works as your trial.
Garansi uang kembali: Yes, a 30-day money back guarantee. Contact McAfee support inside that window for a full refund.
📌 Catatan: Every plan bundles the VPN with antivirus. You don’t pay extra for the VPN itself. The pricing structure is also easy to follow.
⚠️ Price check: Some review sites list a standalone VPN at $7.99 monthly. Others show $19.99 for year one (about $1.66/month), renewing at $47.99. Unlimited bandwidth usually requires automatic renewal. Confirm the price at checkout.
Manfaat Utama McAfee VPN
Here’s where McAfee VPN earns its place:
- Perlindungan Wi-Fi Otomatis: The VPN turns on when you join unsecured networks. You don’t have to remember.
- Enkripsi AES-256: Traffic is scrambled before it leaves your device. Snoopers on shared Wi-Fi see nothing useful.
- Throttling Defense: Encryption hides heavy streaming or downloads from your ISP or mobile carrier. That makes throttling harder.
- Five Devices: One plan covers up to five simultaneous connections.
- Perlindungan Kebocoran DNS: Your lookups stay inside the encrypted tunnel.
- Pengeboran Terowongan Terpisah pada Android: Android users can pick which apps use the VPN.
- Keamanan Terpadu: Antivirus, identity protection, and VPN share one app and one bill.
Our full McAfee VPN review covers the antivirus side in more depth.
Apa yang Tim Kami Amati
Note: We haven’t had extensive hands-on time with McAfee VPN for this comparison. The details above come from McAfee’s documentation, published speed tests, and independent reviews.
Kelebihan & Kekurangan McAfee VPN
✅ Kelebihan
- AES-256 encryption on every connection
- Turns on automatically on unsecured public Wi-Fi
- Dilengkapi dengan antivirus dan perlindungan identitas.
- Beginner-friendly app with one-tap connect
❌ Kekurangan
- Logs IP addresses and visited websites
- No macOS app and no Linux client
- Kill switch only on the Windows app
- Fails to unblock Netflix and Hulu
Perbandingan Fitur
Here’s how McAfee VPN vs Tailscale stacks up across ten areas. Each section shows how both tools handle the same job.
| Fitur | Skala ekor | VPN McAfee |
|---|---|---|
| Harga Mulai | $0 (Personal Plus $5/month) | $39,99/tahun |
| Paket Gratis | ✅ | ❌ |
| Enkripsi | Pelindung Kawat | AES-256, Catapult Hydra |
| Public Server Network | ❌ | ✅ |
| Exit Nodes | ✅ | ❌ |
| Bundled Antivirus | ❌ | ✅ |
| macOS & Linux Apps | ✅ | ❌ |
| Identity-Based Access Rules | ✅ | ❌ |
| Membuka Blokir Streaming | ❌ | ❌ |
| Terbaik untuk | Remote access to your own devices | Casual public Wi-Fi protection |
1. Fungsi Sebenarnya dari Setiap Alat
Skala ekor: Tailscale is a mesh network for devices you own. Your laptop, phone, and home server join one private network. It’s built for remote access, not for hiding you from websites.
VPN McAfee: McAfee is a traditional virtual private network. Your traffic passes through McAfee servers before reaching the internet. That hides your IP address from the sites you visit.
💡 Pro Tip: Tailscale isn’t like typical free VPNs with shared public servers. Want your own files from anywhere? Pick Tailscale. Want private browsing on café Wi-Fi? McAfee covers that.
2. Encryption & Protocols
Skala ekor: Tailscale uses WireGuard to build end-to-end encrypted tunnels between devices. Its control plane only handles key exchange and device discovery. The data plane stays direct, and the client code is open source.
VPN McAfee: McAfee encrypts traffic with AES-256. It runs on the Catapult Hydra protocol, the same one Perisai Hotspot uses. Hydra is designed for speed on everyday connections.
3. Privacy, Logging & Jurisdiction
Skala ekor: Tailscale doesn’t route your browsing through its servers, so it sees less. It holds SOC 2 Type 2 certification. Identity-based access rules add another privacy layer for teams.
VPN McAfee: This is McAfee’s weakest area. Its policy allows logging your IP address and browsing history. McAfee claims a no-logs approach. But the wording is vague and shared with its antivirus products.
On the plus side, McAfee plans include a data broker cleanup tool.
⚠️ Peringatan: McAfee keeps logs until you delete your account, then 30 more days. It’s US-based, inside the Five Eyes alliance, and will share data with authorities on request. So should you trust McAfee Safe Connect with sensitive browsing? Not for serious online privacy.
McAfee also doesn’t block browser cookies. Third party advertisers can still track your online activities when you’re logged in.
4. Remote Access & Secure Networking
Skala ekor: This is where Tailscale shines. Reach a home NAS from your MacBook Pro on hotel Wi-Fi. Subnet routers expose printers and other devices that can’t install software. It links Google Cloud, AWS, and office servers into one network.
It also handles multi-cloud setups without dedicated hardware or complex routing.
VPN McAfee: McAfee has no remote access or device networking tools. It protects one device’s connection to the internet. For most home users, that’s all they need.
5. Fitur Keamanan
Skala ekor: Tailscale focuses on network security. Access control policies (ACLs) let you build custom groups and roles. Its decentralized design eliminates single points of failure, so traffic reroutes if one path drops.
It can also lock down access to internal Alat AI dan layanan.
VPN McAfee: McAfee pairs the VPN with antivirus and DNS leak protection. But advanced security features are thin. The kill switch works on Windows only, and there’s no multi hop or Smart DNS. iOS users and Android users get no kill switch at all.
The Scam Detektor adds another layer by flagging risky texts and fake shopping pages.
6. Perlindungan Identitas & Fitur Tambahan
Skala ekor: Tailscale has no identity protection tools. It sticks to connecting infrastructure and securing access.
VPN McAfee: McAfee wins this round easily. Plans include identity monitoring, a manajer sandi, a security freeze, and credit monitoring. Most VPN companies don’t bundle any of that.
Higher tiers also add identity theft coverage and restoration help.
7. Speed, Streaming & Torrenting
Skala ekor: Direct connections avoid the lag of hub-and-spoke VPNs. Tailscale uses UDP hole punching and NAT traversal to link devices. Unblocking streaming services isn’t part of its job.
VPN McAfee: Independent speed tests recorded 97Mbps on a nearby server. International download speeds never dropped below 75Mbps. But one speed test showed latency jumping 600 percent on Windows, which hurts gaming.
⚠️ Peringatan: McAfee’s VPN fails to unblock Netflix and Hulu. It also doesn’t support P2P traffic, so skip it for torrenting. It can still bypass basic geo-restrictions on news and shopping sites.
8. Device Support & Server Locations
Skala ekor: Tailscale works on Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, Android, Apple TV, and Android TV. It covers the major operating systems and platforms your team already uses. Once installed, devices can join from any network.
VPN McAfee: McAfee Safe Connect runs on Windows, iOS, and Android. There’s no macOS app and no Linux client. For Windows-only homes, that’s no big deal.
McAfee’s server list covers roughly 2,000 servers. Published country counts vary, from 23 to 47 server locations. That’s small next to dedicated VPN services.
9. Ease of Use & Support
Skala ekor: New users can be running in minutes. Sign up with SSO, install the Tailscale app, and share a link to add devices. You don’t need to configure port forwarding. The web dashboard handles users, devices, and permissions.
Support is mostly email during business hours. Free users can file bugs on GitHub and lean on detailed docs. Creating a tailnet needs no special configuration, but ACLs have a learning curve.
VPN McAfee: McAfee’s app is user friendly and suits beginners. One tap connects you. Advanced settings are limited, and several reviews describe the experience as basic. Paying customers get live chat support.
10. Harga & Biaya
Here are both price lists side by side.
| Rencana | Skala ekor | VPN McAfee |
|---|---|---|
| Bebas | Personal: $0 Free Forever | ❌ |
| Pintu masuk | Personal Plus: $5/bulan | Essential: $39.99/tahun |
| Tingkat Menengah | — | Keanggotaan Individu Tingkat Lanjut: $89,99/tahun |
| Tingkat Teratas | — | Paket Keluarga Lanjutan: $119,99/tahun |
Skala ekor: The free plan is generous for individual users. Most home labs never need to upgrade. Personal Plus adds room for more people at a low monthly price.
VPN McAfee: The Essential annual plan bundles antivirus and VPN in one bill. It makes sense if you need antivirus anyway. Buying it just for the VPN is weak value.
Skenario yang Berbeda
| Jika Anda Membutuhkan… | Memilih | Mengapa |
|---|---|---|
| Anggaran ketat | Skala ekor | Free plan covers 100 devices |
| Perlindungan Wi-Fi publik | VPN McAfee | Auto-connects on unsecured networks |
| Akses jarak jauh ke perangkat rumah. | Skala ekor | Direct encrypted device links |
| Antivirus plus VPN in one | VPN McAfee | Bundled security plans |
| Mac or Linux user | Skala ekor | Native apps for both |
| Ramah untuk pemula | VPN McAfee | One-tap connect |
💰 Anggaran Anda
Tailscale costs nothing for most personal setups. McAfee only makes financial sense if you also want antivirus.
🔌 Susunan Teknologi Anda
Tailscale plugs into cloud servers, NAS boxes, and routers. McAfee ignores your other gear and protects single connections.
🔒 Kebutuhan Privasi Anda
Neither tool gives full anonymity for browsing. McAfee logs more, while Tailscale simply isn’t built to hide you from websites.
🎓 Tingkat Pengalaman Anda
McAfee suits people who just want protection with zero setup. Tailscale rewards a little networking knowledge with far more power.
🆓 Uji Coba dan Demo Gratis
Start with Tailscale’s free plan on two devices. For McAfee, use the 30-day refund window to test your daily routine.
🛟 Opsi Dukungan
McAfee offers live chat for paying customers. Tailscale relies on email, docs, and community forums.
Panduan Pengalihan
Sudah menggunakan salah satu alat ini? Berikut perubahan yang akan terjadi jika Anda beralih.
🔄 Switching from Tailscale to McAfee VPN?
✅ Apa yang akan Anda peroleh:
- Antivirus and identity protection in one app
- Automatic protection on public Wi-Fi
- Public servers for changing your location
❌ Apa yang akan Anda rugikan:
- Akses langsung antar perangkat
- A free plan for up to 100 devices
- Dukungan macOS dan Linux
📋 Cara beralih:
- List which devices act as exit nodes or subnet routers
- Buy a McAfee plan and install it on Windows, iOS, or Android
- Turn on auto-connect, then remove the Tailscale client
🔄 Switching from McAfee VPN to Tailscale?
✅ Apa yang akan Anda peroleh:
- Private access to your own devices from anywhere
- Identity-based access rules
- Apps for Linux, macOS, and Apple TV
❌ Apa yang akan Anda rugikan:
- Bundled antivirus and scam protection
- A public server list for geo-restricted content
- Automatic Wi-Fi protection
📋 Cara beralih:
- Cancel McAfee auto-renewal in your account
- Create a Tailscale account with SSO
- Install Tailscale on each device and set an exit node if needed
Apa yang Tidak Kami Bahas dalam Ulasan Kami
This comparison focused on individual users and small teams. We didn’t test Tailscale’s paid business tiers or large ACL setups. McAfee on gaming consoles and smart TVs wasn’t evaluated. Our notes reflect September 2026 versions, and features may change.
Keputusan Akhir
| Kategori | Pemenang |
|---|---|
| 💰 Harga | Skala ekor |
| 🔒 Privasi & Pencatatan | Skala ekor |
| ⚡ Kecepatan / Performa | Skala ekor |
| 🌐 Remote Access | Skala ekor |
| 💻 Dukungan Perangkat | Skala ekor |
| 👶 Kemudahan Penggunaan untuk Pemula | VPN McAfee |
| 🛡️ Bundled Security Extras | VPN McAfee |
| 🏆 Pemenang Keseluruhan | Skala ekor |
🏆 WINNER: TAILSCALE
Tailscale wins 5 out of 7 categories.
Cocok untuk: Remote access, home labs, developers, and small teams
McAfee VPN and Tailscale are two very different products. McAfee is a basic consumer VPN tucked inside a security suite. Tailscale is a private network for devices you control.
McAfee is fine for occasional use on hotel or café Wi-Fi. It covers the bare minimum, and the antivirus bundle adds real value. Its logging policy and weak streaming support are the trade-offs.
For most readers, Tailscale is the better pick. It’s free, fast, and keeps your traffic off its servers. Just don’t expect it to unblock Netflix.
Lebih lanjut tentang Tailscale dibandingkan
Here’s how Tailscale holds up against other popular picks:
Tailscale menang dalam hal: direct device-to-device links, a free plan for 100 devices, and identity-based access rules
NordVPN menang pada: a large public server network, reliable streaming access, and malware and ad blocking
Skala ekor vs ProtonVPN
Tailscale menang dalam hal: reaching home servers remotely, subnet routers for printers, and SSO sign-in for teams
ProtonVPN unggul dalam hal: Swiss privacy law, multi-hop Secure Core routing, and a free plan with public servers
Tailscale menang dalam hal: stable 100.x addresses, an admin dashboard, and simple per-user pricing
Misteri menang pada: residential IP addresses, sign-up without personal details, and a decentralized node network
Perbandingan Lebih Lanjut tentang McAfee VPN
Here’s how McAfee VPN stacks up against other VPN services:
McAfee VPN unggul dalam hal: antivirus in the same plan, identity monitoring, and auto-connect on unsafe Wi-Fi
NordVPN unggul dalam hal: an audited no-logs policy, a kill switch on every platform, and dependable streaming
McAfee VPN vs ExpressVPN
McAfee VPN unggul dalam hal: antivirus bundled at no extra cost, credit monitoring, and a simpler interface
ExpressVPN unggul dalam hal: native macOS and Linux apps, broad streaming support, and a router app
McAfee VPN vs CyberGhost
McAfee VPN unggul dalam hal: a security freeze tool, a bundled password manager, and a scam detector
CyberGhost menang dalam hal: dedicated streaming servers, P2P-friendly servers, and more simultaneous connections
Pertanyaan Yang Sering Muncul
Apakah McAfee VPN aman?
Yes, for basic protection. AES-256 encryption stops snoopers on public Wi-Fi. But its policy allows logging IP addresses and visited sites, so it isn’t truly private.
Apakah Tailscale sebenarnya adalah VPN?
Yes, it’s a mesh VPN. Instead of routing traffic through public servers, it links your devices directly with WireGuard tunnels.
Apakah Tailscale menyembunyikan alamat IP Anda?
Not by default. Traffic goes straight between your devices. Set up an exit node, and websites see that device’s IP address instead.
Apakah Netflix memblokir McAfee VPN?
Mostly, yes. Independent reviews found it fails to unblock Netflix and Hulu libraries. Pick a streaming-focused VPN if that’s your main goal.
Apakah Tailscale gratis untuk penggunaan pribadi?
Yes. The Personal plan costs $0 forever. It covers three users and up to 100 devices, so most home setups never pay.
English 
Spanish 
Chinese 
German 
French 
Arabic 
Russian 
Portuguese 
Japanese 
Korean 
Italian 
Turkish 
Dutch 
Polish 
Indonesian 
Thai 
Vietnamese 