Reply IO vs Mailshake: Boost Email Deliverability in 2025

Are you tired of your sales emails landing in spam?

Frustrated with low open rates? You’re not alone.

Getting your emails delivered is crucial in today’s competitive world.

That’s where powerful tools like Reply.io and Mailshake come in.

They help you create effective email campaigns that reach your prospects’ inboxes. 

In this article, we’ll compare Reply IO vs Mailshake.

We’ll examine their features and help you choose the right one to improve your email deliverability in 2025.

Reply IO vs Mailshake Overview

We’ve spent weeks testing both Reply.io and Mailshake to give you the most accurate comparison. 

We dove deep into their features, analyzed their pricing, and even sent test email campaigns to see which platform performed best. 

Now, we’re sharing our findings to help you make an informed decision.

What is Reply IO?

Have you ever wished you could automate your email outreach? That’s precisely what Reply.io does!

It’s a sales engagement platform. It helps you connect with more prospects.

You can build automated email sequences. It also offers a bunch of other cool features.

Think of it as your assistant for sales outreach. Pretty neat, right?

Also, explore our favourite Reply IO alternatives…

What is Mailshake?

Need to send a bunch of emails? Mailshake makes it easy!

It’s a sales engagement tool built for cold outreach. You can personalize emails at scale.

It helps you automate follow-ups. Mailshake even has tools to warm up your email.

This helps improve your deliverability. Sounds pretty handy, right?

Also, explore our favourite Mailshake alternatives…

Comparación de funciones

Reply and Mailshake are both popular sales engagement tools for modern sales and marketing teams.

This comparison will highlight the strengths of each platform, helping you understand their different approaches to the sales process and cold email campaigns.

1. Core Purpose

• Reply: Reply is a comprehensive sales engagement tools platform for automating outbound sales funnels across multiple communication channels. It is designed to assist sales reps with every stage of the sales process, from prospecting to closing deals.
• Mailshake: Mailshake is a specialized cold email outreach platform. Its core purpose is to help sales teams with their cold email campaigns by providing provider automated email sequences and a robust suite of tools to manage outreach campaigns.

2. Multi-Channel Outreach

• Reply: Reply is a leader in multi-channel engagement. You can easily integrate email, linkedin automation, calls, and SMS into a single, multi-step sequence, which helps you reach potential clients wherever they are.
• Mailshake: Mailshake is primarily an cold email outreach platform, but it has expanded its features to include linkedin automation and a built-in phone dialer. It allows you to combine email with other channels in your sequence, making it a great tool for a modern sales team.

3. Email Automation and Sequencing

• Reply: Reply excels at email automation. It allows you to build sophisticated sequences with conditional logic that can assign tasks based on a prospect’s behavior, which helps you manage your sales process more efficiently.
• Mailshake: Mailshake is a powerful provider automated email sequences platform. It provides an intuitive interface that makes it easy for sales reps to create multi-step sequences, manage their cold email campaigns, and set up automated follow-ups without manual effort.

4. AI Features and Personalization

• Reply: Reply is heavily invested in ai powered sales. Its AI assistant, Jason, can not only generate personalized cold emails and subject lines but can also handle replies, manage sequences, and even book meetings.
• Mailshake: Mailshake also has AI features to help you send personalized cold emails. Its AI email writer helps you craft compelling copy, and its dynamic variables make it easy to create personalized cold emails at scale.

5. Prospecting and Data

• Reply: Reply has a prospecting component, but its database is not as extensive as other dedicated platforms. It does offer a data finder and a Chrome extension to assist with building targeted prospect lists, but its main focus is on engagement.
• Mailshake: Mailshake is not a prospecting database. It has a mailshake’s data finder feature that allows you to find verified emails for your campaigns, but its primary function is to serve as an email outreach platform, not to source data.

6. Deliverability and Warm-up

• Reply: Reply is known for its deliverability suite, which includes unlimited email warm up for every mailbox you connect. It helps you build and maintain a strong sender reputation, which is a significant advantage for protecting your email campaigns and ensuring they reach the inbox.
• Mailshake: Mailshake also has a strong focus on deliverability. It offers an email domain setup assistant to help you warm up your domain and ensure your messages land in the inbox. It also provides a robust suite of tools to track your campaign performance and avoid spam filters.

7. Pricing and Scalability

• Reply: Reply’s pricing is based on the number of users and active contacts. It offers unlimited mailboxes and unlimited contacts on its higher-tier plans, making it a scalable solution for growing teams.
• Mailshake: Mailshake’s pricing is user-based, and it offers a free trial on some of its plans. It also has a dedicated plan that includes unlimited free dialer minutes to North American phone numbers, which can be a significant cost-saver for your sales team.

8. Inbox Management

• Reply: Reply features a centralized master inbox that consolidates all replies from your unlimited mailboxes into a single dashboard. This allows your sales team to manage conversations and collaborate on responses without having to switch between different email accounts.
• Mailshake: Mailshake also offers a lead catcher feature that helps you manage replies and track your leads from a single dashboard. This streamlines the process of responding to prospects and ensures that no lead falls through the cracks.

9. Integrations and Workflow

• Reply: Reply has deep integrations with leading crms, allowing you to automatically log emails, schedule meetings, and sync data in real time. This ensures that your sales and marketing teams have access to up to date information and can focus on converting potential clients.
• Mailshake: Mailshake also has deep integrations with popular CRMs and marketing automation platforms. This allows you to easily import your lists and sync data, but some users have reported trouble uploading leads correctly at times, but the support team is there to help.

10. Customer Support

• Reply: Reply is known for its exceptional support team and a customer success manager that helps sales and marketing teams get the most out of the platform. They provide assistance with everything from setting up your outreach strategy to optimizing your campaign performance with actionable data.
• Mailshake: Mailshake is known for its responsive customer support team and helpful educational content. It offers live chat, a help center, and email support to assist with a wide range of issues.

11. Customization and Control

• Reply: Reply provides a high degree of customization for your sequences and workflows. You can customize your email templates and filters to perfectly match your sales strategies, which gives your sales team a significant advantage in the cold email outreach space.
• Mailshake: Mailshake also allows for a high degree of customization. You can personalize your emails with dynamic variables, and you can create a unique workflow that matches your specific business needs. Its simple and intuitive interface makes it easy to set up your first campaign quickly.

What to Look for in an Email Warm-up Tool?

• A tool that allows you to connect with prospects across multiple channels or multiple communication channels is crucial for modern sales teams. It is not enough to just send emails; you must engage your sales teams on their preferred channels to break through the noise and hit your sales quota.
• The best platforms offer a responsive and knowledgeable customer support team to help you with the technical aspects of setting up your campaigns and to get the most out of your software.
• Tools that provide unlimited mailboxes or the ability to use third party mail servers can help you scale your outreach without putting your sender reputation at risk. This is especially important for an email service provider that can help you manage multiple accounts and their respective sending domains.
• The best tools provide detailed analytics so you can gain valuable insights into your campaign performance, such as open rates, reply rates, and conversions. This data will give you the valuable insights you need to optimize your sales process and hit your sales quota.
• Look for a tool that helps you to get a comprehensive list of all the contact information from a specific company name, which is a great starting point for building a targeted list.
• A ray id is a unique identifier assigned to every web request. While it may not be a core feature, it is a great tool for a customer support team to have to help troubleshoot any issues with your website or email deliverability.
• A platform should be able to provide account based marketing features to help you create a highly targeted list of prospects and get the valuable insights you need to optimize your campaigns.

Veredicto final

Choosing between Mailshake and Reply.io depends on your needs.

Both are excellent tools with a lot to offer. But for most sales teams, we recommend Reply.io.

It offers slightly better deliverability and more advanced features.

This is important for managing a large number of email addresses.

Plus, its AI features can boost your outreach.

We’ve helped hundreds of businesses optimize their email outreach and seen firsthand how the right tools can make a huge difference.

Reply.io gives you the best chance of success. But don’t just take our word for it.

Try both platforms yourself with their free trials!

More of Reply IO

More of Mailshake

Preguntas frecuentes